Blogs and Stories

GF's Mom Cream Pies Me a Second Time

the pie boy rubber leather pvc cream pies humiliation orgasm pvc raincoat

Story by ThePieBoy10 days ago 188 viewsmale+female, explicit

Coming Out of the Pie Closet

the pie boy rubber leather pvc cream pies domination humiliation

Story by ThePieBoy15 days ago 117 viewsmale+female, explicit

GFs Mom Takes Me on a Road Trip for PVC

the pie boy cream pies pvc raincoat latex rubber humiliation teasing

Story by ThePieBoy16 days ago 109 viewsmale+female, explicit

GF and Mom Cream Me at Dinner and Publicly

the pie boy rubber leather pvc cream pie public humiliation orgasm

Story by ThePieBoy19 days ago 207 viewsmale+female, explicit

Saturday at the Office

pie in the face banter messy sex

Story by PieWriter11/23/20 2650 viewsmale+female

GFs Mom Creams Me w/Pies for the First Time

the pie boy cream pies humiliation pvc rubber vinyl raincoats

Story by ThePieBoy19 days ago 207 viewsmale+female, explicit

The Wall of Shame (Part 2): A What Would You Do? Story

pie chocolate gameshow stripping underwear nude bra panties leggings humiliation

Story by hooliham1/1/23 2888 viewsmale+female

J's Interview (A Prequel)

pie in the face wamdom sex

Story by PieWriter12/6/23 1107 viewsmale+female, explicit

The Start of Something Messy

pie in the face pie play sex

Story by PieWriter9/2/21 2550 viewsmale+female

The Pie Boy Creamed for the First Time/The Morning After

the pie boy cream pie rubber leather pvc pvc raincoat humiliation orgasm

Story by ThePieBoy12 days ago 105 viewsmale+female, explicit

Southern Belle Pie Fight

pies pie fight humiliation formalwear

Story by Marlowe4/13/22 1748 viewsfemale

PVC outfits/GF humiliates me in Public w/Pies

the pie boy public humiliation cream pie grocery store pvc vinyl rubber raincoat

Story by ThePieBoy27 days ago 133 viewsmale+female, explicit

Kelsey (The Interview Sequel 1)

pie in the face nude sex dominated

Story by PieWriter12/10/23 1193 viewsmale+female, explicit, synthetic

Twisted Darts--A What Would You Do? Game

pie humiliation slime coed gameshow what would you do

Story by hooliham6/22/21 3201 viewsmale+female

GFs Mom Catches Me in the Act

the pie boy pvc rubber leather cream pie humiliation

Story by ThePieBoy20 days ago 391 viewsmale+female, explicit

Whose Pie is it Anyway?

pie in the face pie fight pie catapult game show parody

Story by theoldmanandthepie4/16/25 367 viewsmale+female

GFs Mom Teases and Embarrasses Me in Public

the pie boy pvc raincoat public humiliation cream pie latex rubber

Story by ThePieBoy16 days ago 116 viewsmale+female, explicit

College Drama Pie Revenge: Part III

fff pie pies cakes

Story by KakeKid5/19/23 1876 viewsfemale

The Wheel O' Stuff--A What Would You Do? Game

pie humiliation slime coed gameshow what would you do

Story by hooliham1/12/21 3578 viewsmale+female

GFs Mom Fills My Rubber Pants w/Pies+Takes Me to the Mall

pie boy public pie humiliation leather pvc rubber

Story by ThePieBoy9/18/23 179 viewsmale+female, explicit

Ann Ruins Everything (II)

pie vegas pie fight

Story by Sure11/13/17 1151 views

Elimidate! a "What Would You Do?" Game

pie humiliation slime cake coed gameshow what would you do

Story by hooliham10/2/21 3016 viewsmale+female

A Sweet Connection (part 1 of 5)

pie in the face coed sex

Story by PieWriter4/15/25 518 viewsmale+female, explicit

Ariana's Richly Deserved Dessert: How the Tables are Turned!

female pie fights pie in the face pudding pies chocolate chocolate pudding chocolate sauce chocolate brownie batter chocolate syrup chocolate gunge

Story by vols4everus3/30/22 1136 viewsfemale

College Drama Pie Revenge

pie fight female

Story by KakeKid12/25/21 2541 viewsfemale