My Blogs and Stories
Highlights
Latest
Trending
Bestsellers
Reviews
All Tags
Your Price
Stores
Streaming
Recommended
Trailers
Bundles
Non-wam
Customs


40 results
Mel's Messy Story
chocolate covered female  chocolate pies  chocolate pudding  chocolate cake batter  hersheys chocolate syrup  lost bet mess  chocolate messy forfeiture  chocolate pies to face  chocolate gunge over head  chocolate slime over head
Story3/12/24 369 viewsmale+female
I Told You SO: The Sequel
female  female covered in chocolate  chocolate pies  chocolate pudding  chocolate syrup  topless female  topless female covered in chocolate  lost bet pieing  messy sequel  messy chocolate sequel
Story11/25/23 213 viewsmale+female
So, You Think You Know It All!
pies  cream pies  pies to the face  mud  messy game shows  messy humiliation  topless  messy topless
Story11/1/23 314 viewsfemale
Payback is So Sweet: Bagheera Receives Her Messy Comeuppance
chocolate  chocolate mess  chocolate pies  chocolate pudding  chocolate cake batter  chocolate frosting  hot fudge sauce  hersheys chocolate syrup  total chocolate coverage  chocolate covered revenge
Story8/5/23 146 viewsfemale, explicit
Hikari and Paoli Fight over a Boy
two females messy fight  messy catfight  pie fight  chocolate fight  chocolate pudding  chocolate cake batter  hersheys chocolate syrup  messy clothes ripping  clothes ripping
Story8/4/23 462 viewsfemale
Silly Lilly the Sillybitch: Can't Win for Losing Part Two Th...
total messy humiliation  mud  chocolate  pies  cakes  pudding  shaving cream  slime  gunge  messy dares
Story7/14/23 818 viewsfemale
This Means War: A Chocolate Lover's Delight
losing a bet mess  chocolate  chocolate pies  chocolate cake batter  chocolate frosting  chocolate pudding  hersheys chocolate syrup  chocolate covered woman  total chocolate coverage
Story6/20/23 438 viewsfemale
I Told You So: Chocolate Heaven!
female  female covered in chocolate  chocolate pies  chocolate pudding  chocolate syrup  topless female  topless female covered in chocolate  lost bet pieing
Story5/5/23 515 viewsfemale
Oh What a Tangled Web We Weave: A Lost Bet, Indeed!
chocolate mess  chocolate pudding  chocolate pies  chocolate syrup  female messy play  messy nudity
Story3/15/23 200 viewsmale+female
Mud on the Water: A Messy Sequel
messy food fight  coed food fight  xrated food fight  erotic food fight  pie fight  chocolate fight  messy sex  explicit sex
Story2/26/23 397 viewsmale+female
Sorry Chloe: You Lost
chocolate mess  chocolate over her head  chocolate cake batter  chocolate custard  hersheys chocolate syrup  wet tshirt  big boobs  chocolate covered boobs  lapstick comedy  messy forfeitures
Story1/7/23 765 viewsmale+female
A 4th of July Sequel: Brooke and Bobby Battle at the Pool
messy food fight  coed food fight  xrated food fight  erotic food fight  pie fight  chocolate fight
Story12/28/22 296 viewsmale+female
Dee's Wet Fall
wetlook  female wetlook  comedy wetlook
Story11/11/22 551 viewsfemale
Silly Lilly the Sillybitch: Can't Win for Losing Part Three
total messy humiliation  chocolate  pies  cakes  pudding  chocolate syrup  shaving cream  slime  gunge  messy dares
Story7/8/22 507 viewsfemale
Silly Lilly the Sillybitch: Can't Win for Losing Part Two
total messy humiliation  chocolate  pies  cakes  pudding  chocolate syrup  shaving cream  slime  gunge  messy dares
Story7/8/22 347 viewsfemale
Silly Lilly the Sillybitch: Can't Win for Losing
total messy humiliation  chocolate  pies  cakes  pudding  chocolate syrup  shaving cream  slime  gunge  messy dares
Story7/8/22 692 viewsfemale
A 4th of July Mud Larking Adventure Brooke Battles Bobby in...
male vs female  mud fight  mud wrestling  wet and muddy love  muddy sex  explicit sex
Story6/15/22 262 viewsmale+female
A 4th of July Mud Larking Adventure Brooke Battles Bobby in...
male vs female  mud fight  mud wrestling  wet and muddy love  muddy sex  explicit sex
Story6/15/22 189 viewsmale+female
A 4th of July Mud Larking Adventure Brooke Battles Bobby in...
male vs female  mud fight  mud wrestling  wet and muddy love  muddy sex  explicit sex
Story6/15/22 318 viewsmale+female
A 4th of July Mud Larking Adventure Brooke Battles Bobby in...
male vs female  mud fight  mud wrestling  wet and muddy love  muddy sex  explicit sex
Story6/13/22 420 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: The Final Chapter; The Wedding: Part 4
man and woman  fancy restaurant  pie fight  food fight  chocolate slime  chocolate cake
Story6/5/22 291 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: The Final Chapter; The Wedding: Part 3
man and woman  fancy restaurant  pie fight  food fight  chocolate slime  chocolate cake
Story6/5/22 209 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: The Final Chapter; The Wedding: Part 2
man and woman  fancy restaurant  pie fight  food fight  chocolate slime  chocolate cake
Story6/5/22 345 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: The Final Chapter; The Wedding: Part 1
man and woman  fancy restaurant  pie fight  food fight  chocolate slime  chocolate cake
Story6/5/22 410 viewsmale+female
Mud on the Water: part 3
coed  female  male  mud  mud fight  mud wrestling  erotica  explicit sex
Story5/18/22 248 viewsmale+female
Mud on the Water: Part 2
coed  female  male  mud  mud fight  mud wrestling  erotica  explicit sex
Story5/18/22 202 viewsmale+female
Mud on the Water: Part 1
coed  female  male  mud  mud fight  mud wrestling  erotica  explicit sex
Story5/18/22 393 viewsmale+female
Ariana's Richly Deserved Dessert: How the Tables are Turned!
female  pie fights  pie in the face  pudding pies  chocolate  chocolate pudding  chocolate sauce  chocolate brownie batter  chocolate syrup  chocolate gunge
Story3/30/22 885 viewsfemale
Tit for Tat: Roberto and Ivanna the Sequel: The Entire Story
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story3/5/22 330 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: The Entire Story
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story3/5/22 369 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: Roberto and Ivanna the Sequel: Epilogue
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story2/14/22 158 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: Roberto and Ivanna the Sequel Round: Six
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story2/14/22 163 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: Roberto and Ivanna the Sequel: Round Five
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story2/14/22 159 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: Roberto and Ivanna the Sequel: Round Four
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story2/14/22 185 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: Roberto and Ivanna the Sequel: Round Three
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story2/14/22 166 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: Roberto and Ivanna the Sequel: Round Two
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story2/14/22 176 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: Roberto and Ivanna the Sequel: Round One
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story2/13/22 271 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: Roberto and Ivanna the Sequel
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story2/13/22 214 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: Part 2
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story2/6/22 324 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story2/3/22 506 viewsmale+female
About & FAQ
Preferences
Night Mode
Terms & Privacy
Contact Us
VIP Upgrade
Open a Store
Report Piracy
Link to UMD
UMD Fetish
Design & Code ©1998-2024 Loverbuns, LLC     2257 Statement      Epoch Billing Support      Log In