Blogs and Stories

chocolate covered female chocolate pies chocolate pudding chocolate cake batter hersheys chocolate syrup lost bet mess chocolate messy forfeiture chocolate pies to face chocolate gunge over head chocolate slime over head

Story by vols4everus3/12/24 376 viewsmale+female

I Told You SO: The Sequel

female female covered in chocolate chocolate pies chocolate pudding chocolate syrup topless female topless female covered in chocolate lost bet pieing messy sequel messy chocolate sequel

Story by vols4everus11/25/23 216 viewsmale+female

The Bears Still Suck

pies coed sports bet humiliation

Story by PieAnon3143/18/23 725 viewsmale+female, synthetic

I Told You So: Chocolate Heaven!

female female covered in chocolate chocolate pies chocolate pudding chocolate syrup topless female topless female covered in chocolate lost bet pieing

Story by vols4everus5/5/23 515 viewsfemale

A Chipotle Bet

females lost bet forfeit humiliation savory game

Story by thirdman4/20/22 1360 viewsfemale

The Olympic Hockey Bet

lost bet humiliation savory sweet female game

Blog by thirdman2/17/22 413 viewsfemale

The Olympic Hockey Bet

lost bet humiliation savory sweet female game

Story by thirdman2/17/22 1026 viewsfemale

the sloppy super bowl bet

females lost bet savory humiliation game sweet

Story by thirdman2/14/22 1593 viewsfemale

This Means War: A Chocolate Lover's Delight

losing a bet mess chocolate chocolate pies chocolate cake batter chocolate frosting chocolate pudding hersheys chocolate syrup chocolate covered woman total chocolate coverage

Story by vols4everus6/20/23 439 viewsfemale

Sunday Football Pats Vs. Titans

slimed slime fully clothed pied whip cream sport bet forfeit messy clothes messy fun gunge

Blog by Bostonsportsfan202111/29/21 376 viewsmale

A Playful Pieing (Part 1)

bellybutton navel pieintheface pieing

Story by mildlymessy12/30/18 111 viewsmale+female

The Forfeit

pie gunge bondage sweet savory bet humiliation

Story by BrigidofDerry2/1/20 2309 viewsmale+female

Naughty Lois

revenge gunge stocks partners messy bet

Story by Speccybeard11/22/21 1085 viewsmale+female

Messy in the Bank PT.3

gameshow humiliation savory sweet female forfeit bet wwe

Story by thirdman7/27/22 838 viewsfemale

Sunday Night Showdown Episode 2 Part 2

game female humiliation savory bet forfeit

Blog by thirdman9/19/23 441 viewsfemale

A fully-clothed Muddy turn-on.

mud socks fully clothed sex stuck lost shoes

Story by Lauren199/9/22 1229 viewsfemale

The Messy Wrestlemania Guessing Show Finale

wrestling gameshow female humiliation bet savory sweet

Story by thirdman4/5/22 878 viewsfemale

Card Wars part 1

gameshow humiliation bet spank pie wedgie

Story by randomwam9/1/21 1173 viewsfemale

The Messy University Vote part 2

vote loser humiliation shampoo savory sweet bet female

Story by thirdman3/8/22 1136 viewsfemale

WWE Survivor Series Messy Show PT.2

females gameshow bet forfeit humiliation sweet savory

Story by thirdman12/5/22 688 viewsfemale

Messy Wrestlemania Guessing Show pt2

wrestling gameshow forfeit bet humiliation female sweet savory

Story by thirdman3/31/22 774 viewsfemale

WWE Survivor Series Messy Show PT.1

females humiliation gameshow bet savory sweet

Story by thirdman11/24/22 655 viewsfemale

Mariah's messy meeting. For Mariah Part 1.

wet and messy clothed pieing

Blog by PrimeSlimeTime1/11/20 96 viewsfemale

The first time I got pied.

pie pie in the face pieing oatmeal filling panties panties

Blog by viaferrari1/2/21 435 viewsfemale

Tom the Chef

men pied slapstick chef humiliation comedy pie in the face custard pie messy men men pieing men clowns

Story by custardpiedchef1/2/21 866 viewsmale