Blogs and Stories

A 4th of July Sequel: Brooke and Bobby Battle at the Pool

messy food fight coed food fight xrated food fight erotic food fight pie fight chocolate fight

Story by vols4everus12/28/22 296 viewsmale+female

two females messy fight messy catfight pie fight chocolate fight chocolate pudding chocolate cake batter hersheys chocolate syrup messy clothes ripping clothes ripping

Story by vols4everus8/4/23 463 viewsfemale

Mud on the Water: A Messy Sequel

messy food fight coed food fight xrated food fight erotic food fight pie fight chocolate fight messy sex explicit sex

Story by vols4everus2/26/23 397 viewsmale+female

I Told You SO: The Sequel

female female covered in chocolate chocolate pies chocolate pudding chocolate syrup topless female topless female covered in chocolate lost bet pieing messy sequel messy chocolate sequel

Story by vols4everus11/25/23 216 viewsmale+female

Payback is So Sweet: Bagheera Receives Her Messy Comeuppance

chocolate chocolate mess chocolate pies chocolate pudding chocolate cake batter chocolate frosting hot fudge sauce hersheys chocolate syrup total chocolate coverage chocolate covered revenge

Story by vols4everus8/5/23 148 viewsfemale, explicit

Mel's Messy Story

chocolate covered female chocolate pies chocolate pudding chocolate cake batter hersheys chocolate syrup lost bet mess chocolate messy forfeiture chocolate pies to face chocolate gunge over head chocolate slime over head

Story by vols4everus3/12/24 378 viewsmale+female

Lauren's Story--Chapter 24--Lauren vs Sarah (One last time?)

pies chocolate syrup cake batter ice cream chocolate boots lesbian pudding frosting

Story by LongTimeLurker9/21/17 686 viewsmale+female

Tit for Tat: The Final Chapter; The Wedding: Part 2

man and woman fancy restaurant pie fight food fight chocolate slime chocolate cake

Story by vols4everus6/5/22 346 viewsmale+female

Ariana's Richly Deserved Dessert: How the Tables are Turned!

female pie fights pie in the face pudding pies chocolate chocolate pudding chocolate sauce chocolate brownie batter chocolate syrup chocolate gunge

Story by vols4everus3/30/22 885 viewsfemale

The Chocolate Tour (Full Version)

chocolate formal humiliation pie in the face pie slime cream enjoyment jelly suit

Story by SethJamba11/5/21 515 viewsmale

This Means War: A Chocolate Lover's Delight

losing a bet mess chocolate chocolate pies chocolate cake batter chocolate frosting chocolate pudding hersheys chocolate syrup chocolate covered woman total chocolate coverage

Story by vols4everus6/20/23 439 viewsfemale

The Sweet Factory

lesbian sweets toffee sugar glue stuck revenge machine

Story by Tar_n_Feathers1/25/22 785 viewsfemale

The chocolate rabbit

easter chocolate police girls fondant encasement vibrator

Story by cornonthecob7/24/23 784 viewsfemale

A Piggy's Day Off

bbw chocolate syrup cake humiliation butter sex costume

Story by Oink9/12/18 657 viewsmale+female

Lifeline through chapter 7

gameshow forced orgasm humiliation gunge rivals revenge pies

Story by enswan4/25/22 2248 viewsfemale

Friends with Forfeits

kiwimayotte yasmin teen nude gunge tank chocolate factory

Story by Kiwimayotte8/4/18 1406 viewsfemale

Lower Class Chocolate

formal suit tuxedo revenge chocolate uniform school uniform humiliation

Story by SethJamba2/8/21 429 viewsmale

I Told You So: Chocolate Heaven!

female female covered in chocolate chocolate pies chocolate pudding chocolate syrup topless female topless female covered in chocolate lost bet pieing

Story by vols4everus5/5/23 515 viewsfemale

Tiffany's Chocolate Factory Humiliation

gangbang impregnation blonde chocolate humiliation tattoo clothing destruction mud food lesbian

Story by Salirophilia4/13/21 1499 viewsfemale

Oh What a Tangled Web We Weave: A Lost Bet, Indeed!

chocolate mess chocolate pudding chocolate pies chocolate syrup female messy play messy nudity

Story by vols4everus3/15/23 200 viewsmale+female

Abbie and Leah #1: A Birthday Adventure

clothed pies custard syrup caramel sauce chocolate cream cake batter frosting

Story by cabbie3134/9/21 1199 viewsfemale

Messy Models

model chocolate commercial caramel strawberry lesbian

Story by cornonthecob12/29/22 769 viewsfemale

The Jar

kiwimayotte mia lesbian teen naked revenge ice cream molasses changing room

Story by Kiwimayotte7/7/18 710 viewsfemale

Tit for Tat: The Final Chapter; The Wedding: Part 3

man and woman fancy restaurant pie fight food fight chocolate slime chocolate cake

Story by vols4everus6/5/22 210 viewsmale+female

Silly Lilly the Sillybitch: Can't Win for Losing Part Two Th...

total messy humiliation mud chocolate pies cakes pudding shaving cream slime gunge messy dares

Story by vols4everus7/14/23 819 viewsfemale