People All WOTD Gallery Party Blogs Stories Events POTD Hangout
Stories
UMD Stories
Add
Stories tagged with pie fight
273 stories

all genders ▼



Ariana's Richly Deserved Dessert: How the Tables are Turned!
female  pie fights  pie in the face  pudding pies  chocolate  chocolate pudding  chocolate sauce  chocolate brownie batter  chocolate syrup  chocolate gunge
Story by vols4everus3/30/22 896 viewsfemale
Mud on the Water: A Messy Sequel
messy food fight  coed food fight  xrated food fight  erotic food fight  pie fight  chocolate fight  messy sex  explicit sex
Story by vols4everus2/26/23 402 viewsmale+female
Ann Ruins Everything (I)
pie fight  vegas  pie
Story by Sure11/6/17 1151 viewsmale+female
1

"That Was Exhausting"
food fight  cake  females  naked  celebrity  sex  orgy
Story by Ozian5/15/23 815 viewsfemale
The Bridal Party--A What Would You Do? Game
pie  humiliation  slime  female  gameshow  what would you do
Story by hooliham3/28/21 2778 viewsfemale
1

wwyd Roleplay
wwyd  pie pod  humiliation  gameshow  nudity  roleplay  lesbian  public  car wash  gunge
Story by GungeSlut967/29/21 1808 viewsmale+female
Happy Birthday
pies  coed  pie in the face  sex  nudity  naked
Story by PieWriter5/24/18 3013 viewsmale+female
3

Meringue Girl
pies  naked  sex  pie in the face  dunked
Story by PieWriter12/5/23 946 viewsmale+female, explicit, synthetic
Bitter Rivals
kiwimayotte  rivals  teen  naked  rugby  minute to win it  dunk tank  food fight
Blog by Kiwimayotte7/8/18 105 viewsfemale
Bitter Rivals
kiwimayotte  rugby  rivals  dunk tank  teen  naked  shower  minute to win it  food fight
Story by Kiwimayotte7/8/18 793 viewsfemale
Newlywed Messy Olympics
pies  food fight  gameshow
Blog by TimsMessyFiction6/1/20 1346 viewsfemale
2

The Restaurant: Waiter vs Customer Part 3
pies  pie fight  humiliation  stripping  water  wet  retaliation  surprise  innocent victim
Story by pracman4412/31/20 798 viewsmale
3

Darcie Chapter 18--Darcie Makes a Convert Part 4
wet wedding dress  muddy wedding dress  trash the dress  cat fight  stripping  clothes ripping  sex
Story by wetgalfan5/5/18 128 viewsmale+female
Next Fantasy Pie Fight Fuck
pie fight  men  gunge  sex  gay  pie
Story by FunPieGuy1/31/19 1429 viewsmale
Serum 41: An Elegant Affair
cakes  females  mind control  pie fight  pies  stripping
Story by Deeppan912/26/18 2718 viewsfemale
5

Darcie Chapter 24--Darcie Takes Her Medicine Part 2
pies  pie in the face  wetlook  swimming in clothes  humiliation
Story by wetgalfan5/5/18 85 viewsmale+female
Tit for Tat: The Entire Story
pie fight  man and woman  fancy restaurant
Story by vols4everus3/5/22 376 viewsmale+female
A Twist of Fete
pie  gunge  foodfight
Story by briff1es8/1/18 1156 viewsfemale
2

Pie Per Reply What Did I Do?!?
pie per reply  pie in the face  pie  pies  slime  sliming  slimings  demolished  brat  bratty
Blog by viaferrari1/10/21 261 viewsfemale
4

The Oreo Banquet
formal  banquet  tuxedo  pie fight  rivalry  pie  pie in the face
Story by SethJamba7/22/21 279 viewsmale
WAM Date--Helene
female  custard pie  handcuffs  heels
Story by AJ22/28/24 806 viewsfemale
Alternate Rules/Variations For (Pie)Fight Club
men  pies  nudity  pie fight  game
Story by JayTee6/27/23 342 viewsmale
The Greatest Crossover Event of the Summer--Finale
cake  pie  sex
Story by briff1es8/18/19 761 viewsmale+female
1

Sweet Course: Chapter 3 of 3
dessert  food  cake  cream pie  sensual  threesome  japanese  messy hair  elegant
Story by Anon_Acct10/8/23 286 viewsfemale
Tit for Tat: The Final Chapter; The Wedding: Part 2
man and woman  fancy restaurant  pie fight  food fight  chocolate slime  chocolate cake
Story by vols4everus6/5/22 349 viewsmale+female
12345
11

About & FAQ
Preferences
Night Mode
Terms & Privacy
Contact Us
VIP Upgrade
Open a Store
Report Piracy
Link to UMD
UMD Fetish
Design & Code ©1998-2024 Loverbuns, LLC     2257 Statement      Epoch Billing Support      Log In