People All WOTD Gallery Party Blogs Stories Events POTD Hangout
Stories
UMD Stories
Add
Stories tagged with first time
23 stories

all genders ▼



Dave and Amy 1: Amy Learns her Lesson
first time  swimwear  custard  pies  cake  spanking  dry humping  hand job  oral sex  vaginal sex
Story by 8bitchiptune1/14/24 693 viewsmale+female, explicit
Acting 101
pies  first time  male  female  piefight  comedy
Story by GreetingCard12/5/21 1693 viewsfemale
Antigone: A First Date
coed  pies  first time  clothed
Story by GreetingCard6/4/18 1346 viewsmale+female
5

Dan and Lindsay's First Time
first date  experiment  dorm  classmate  flats  feet
Story by messyman882/19/21 887 viewsmale+female
3

Tough-Luck Todd #1: Seven Hundred!
coed  game show  humiliation  first time  gunge  wetlook  clothed
Story by writingismylife12/14/18 861 viewsmale+female
1

Sucessfully Introducing Wam to a girl
first time  wam  pie in the face  story
Blog by mtessex11/13/19 584 viewsfemale
Anna's First Time With Pies
college  first time  pie in the face  leggings  athletic
Story by messyman882/18/20 1346 viewsmale
1

Sadie's Present
coed  first time  pies  clothes
Story by GreetingCard10/12/19 1708 viewsfemale
1

So my gf and I got messy together for the first time!
first time  custard  chocolate  game
Story by SplashSerpent2/6/20 702 viewsmale+female
A Fun Time
pies  coed  first time
Story by GreetingCard1/1/21 1901 viewsfemale
9

Anna Part 7: Roommate's First Time
roommates  lesbian  first time
Story by messyman884/21/20 1137 viewsmale
The Price of Admission, part 2 (spin-off of Kiwimayotte's &q...
coed  gunge  game show  first time  pies  food  blindfold  clothed
Story by writingismylife12/13/18 568 viewsmale+female
What got me into Wam?
discovery  exploration  first time  celebrity  q and a  male  experience
Blog by SoldHisSoles3/12/23 232 viewsn/a
Savannah's Long Awaited Mess
gunge  pies  masturbation  slime  first time  dildo  anal
Story by wammonster161/13/23 1057 viewsfemale
First time fun
first time  yogurt  chocolate
Story by Wamhunter3/4/21 737 viewsfemale
1

Imagining the worst...
fantasy  first time  imagined
Blog by Brattybaby2/1/24 398 viewsfemale
New Job
blackmail  bondage  gunge mess first time
Story by Madelyne138/22/20 523 viewsfemale
1

First Blog
mud  first mud  story tell  story  fun
Story by Edu Mud Lover11/28/20 538 viewsn/a
2

My story
Story  background  first messy tee  grand WAM plan
Story by MessyJC7/10/17 448 viewsn/a
My First-Ever pie
pie  pie in face  first pie  messy  interview  key lime pie
Story by Bostonsportsfan202111/26/21 521 viewsmale
WAM trivial pursuit
trivia  first time
Blog by brokentinman12/28/19 475 viewsmale
Rachel 1--Leavers day
wetlook  pool  first time
Story by Wamhunter2/2/22 619 viewsfemale
Short gunge tank story
gunge  gunge tank  female  first time
Story by The Lost One10/15/21 1036 viewsfemale
About & FAQ
Preferences
Night Mode
Terms & Privacy
Contact Us
VIP Upgrade
Open a Store
Report Piracy
Link to UMD
UMD Fetish
Design & Code ©1998-2024 Loverbuns, LLC     2257 Statement      Epoch Billing Support      Log In