SploshD said:
4. A can of pie filling in your clothes per person getting messy.

subadubdub said: 1.. Spaghetti in your underwear.
2. Fill a pair of leggings with rice pudding
3. Pie yourself with (1) pie. If the number of pies is less than 5, rejoin the game and increase this pie counter by 1.
4. Cake batter over your head
5. Make yourself into a human sundae - ice cream, two syrups, whipped cream, sprinkles and a cherry. Tuck your shirt into your rice pudding filled leggings and dump the sundae down your shirt.
6. dunk your top clothing in a bowl of vanilla pudding and your bottom cltohing in a bowl of chocolate pudding then get them with your teeth and hands behind your back then pour the vanilla pudding in your bottoms and the chocolate pudding in your top