Hi everyone!

I wanted to try a new game out that is kind of similar to Lucky Boxes, but with an element of social deduction if you've ever played Mafia or similar game where you have to bluff your friends. The name of the game comes from an 8 out of 10 Cats skit called Carrot in a box, where this game was basically played between 2 people.

Rules:
- Just like lucky boxes, there are 11 boxes available with box number 11 going to the host.
- The host can arrange the other 10 boxes but must have a "stay clean and become new host"
- The other 10 boxes can be what the host decides; I'd recommend that the host reveals the prizes, but a more difficult/maybe more fun way to play would be to not reveal what you're playing for.
- Once all the players have joined the game, the host will tell the players through DM exactly what is in their box.
- Before box swapping begins, each player should say whatever they want about their box in this thread. The idea here is to try to convince others to take your box if you have something you don't want, or you should try to convince others to not take your box if you have something you want to keep. You can say exactly what is in your box, lie and claim it is something else on the list, say something vague, etc. This discussion time will be capped at 72 hours, but once each player has said something the box swapping can begin.
- When it's your turn, you choose to keep the box or switch with ANY PLAYERs box that has not already gone.
- Once you make your choice. The host will announce what was in your box in this thread. If you swapped, the host will DM the swapped player what's in their new box. Your box will be locked in, and no one can take your box from you.
- You have 72 hours to make a decision or you will keep your box. Anyone over 72 hours also will pie themselves with a pie on top of the box for not responding.
- Host: Since you know all of the boxes and who has what, you cannot take part in the player's discussion of their boxes only speak about your own. This is also why you are left with the final box.



OK! I'll naturally be the first host

Here are the fabulous prizes you are playing for!
1. stay clean and become new host
2. stay clean and give another player 2 pies
3. stay clean and give another player a bucket of slime
4. stay clean
5. take a pie sandwich
6. take a pie sandwich
7. take a bucket of slime
8. take a bucket of slime
9. Go to the Pie Pod (per wwyd game rules)
10. Go to the Pie Wash (per wwyd game rules)
11. 3 day vote against another player for 3 buckets of gunge and 4 pies.

Sign ups are open
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11. Sploshd

I love this idea! I'll take box 6

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6. Wam262
7.
8.
9.
10.
11. Sploshd

Channeling my inner Sean Lock

1.
2.
3. 314d
4.
5.
6. Wam262
7.
8.
9.
10.
11. Sploshd

A new game - cool! I'm glad to support a new game. I was also Sent here from If You Can Catch Me.

Since options are good and I was sent here, so I'll go with almost-minimum chances of switching.

1.
2.
3. 314d
4.
5.
6. Wam262
7.
8.
9.
10. Texas Beau
11. Sploshd

1.
2. FatPieFan
3. 314d
4.
5.
6. Wam262
7.
8.
9.
10. Texas Beau
11. Sploshd

1.
2. FatPieFan
3. 314d
4.
5.
6. Wam262
7.
8.Dare me
9.
10. Texas Beau
11. Sploshd

Gonna maybe finally have some free time for a session, I'll go in on this one.

1.
2. FatPieFan
3. 314d
4.
5.
6. Wam262
7.
8.Dare me
9. SuperSloppy
10. Texas Beau
11. Sploshd

1.
2. FatPieFan
3. 314d
4.
5.
6. Wam262
7.Dassault
8.Dare me
9. SuperSloppy
10. Texas Beau
11. Sploshd

1.
2. FatPieFan
3. 314d
4.
5. Messymax
6. Wam262
7.Dassault
8.Dare me
9. SuperSloppy
10. Texas Beau
11. Sploshd

Sure. I'll give this a whirl.

1.
2. FatPieFan
3. 314d
4. Blue Griffin
5. Messymax
6. Wam262
7.Dassault
8.Dare me
9. SuperSloppy
10. Texas Beau
11. Sploshd

1. Underwearfiller
2. FatPieFan
3. 314d
4. Blue Griffin
5. Messymax
6. Wam262
7. Dassault
8. Dare me
9. SuperSloppy
10. Texas Beau
11. Sploshd

The studio lights blaze to life as eleven gleaming boxes sit on podiums arranged in a circle across the stage--each podium includes a contestant sat behind nervously waiting to learn whether they will be going home clean or a complete mess. The audience murmurs with anticipation, knowing that inside each container lies a fate yet to be revealed. The pie pod is set up with 4 pies and a crowning glory to the right of the stage while the pie wash sits to the right, a chair with straps connected to hoses already slightly linking whipped cream.

Welcome players, to the moment of truth! The rules have been laid out, the boxes have been sent to you in your inbox (message me if you questions or issues), and now the real game begins! Each of you holds a mystery--something delightful, something devious, or perhaps something that will have you begging for a swap. Only you know what's inside your box... and only you decide whether to share that truth with the others.

For the next 72 hours, this thread is your battlefield. Deceive, confess, bargain, or bluff--whatever strategy you think will get you the outcome you want. Want to keep your prize? Convince everyone else it's worthless. Desperate to swap? Make your box sound irresistible. Or stay silent and let them wonder. Just remember: your fellow players are doing the exact same thing to you.

The clock starts now. Step up to the mic at your podium, players--tell us what's in your box... or at least, tell us what you want us to believe is in your box.

As your host, who will eventually end up with the fabulous prize you all don't want, I could tell you that my box has a ticket that says "Stay clean and give another player a bucket of slime, " but I think you'll all know I'm lying (Why would I let you all know I have such a great box? ) So, instead I'll just stay a bit mysterious and say I feel neutral about my box. I wouldn't mind switching for something better, but there are worse things out there.

As the host, who knows everyone's box. That's all I will say during this discussion time unless something is directed at me/my box specifically.

Well I'm definitely going to be swapping my gungey box. Just need to work out who has the good carrots. Since I have box 6 I won't be able to swap for the first 5 of you so what's in your box Dassault?

All I'll say is I sure hope no one steals my box!!

Great that i'm fifth, because i'm definitlly swapping mine, i don't want to be slimed hahaha

Yeah this box is getting swapped for sure, fortunately being 2nd means I'll definitely get the chance to ditch this mess

Oh, Okay!
So, that's what is in my box -

Well, I am familiar with the contents of my box. How does that phrase go ...
Been there, done that.

Having seen the game before on time, I'm excited to give this a whirl as the host introduces the game.

With everyone else starting, I crack open the lid, peek inside, close it, and smile, arms crossed.

I'm assuming someone is going to steal my box. That person will regret it

Sure wam262, I will take yours

Being sent here from IYCCM, I took the last guest spot for my prize.

Let's assume that I unfortunately can't hold onto my prize but I do get another great prize like the one I have. After I am notified of my new prize, can I post back on here to try to dissuade anybody from taking that, or will all discussions have ended?

If being last I fall under the radar and I can keep it so that nobody swaps for my prize, then I don't even have to worry about this.

Yes you definitely can continue posting about your box or asking questions from others about theirs after this discussion phase. This 72 period is really just to make sure there is time for people to talk about what they have and we don't go right into opening boxes

And with that contestants, the discussion phase is over! It's time for the main event!

Underwarefiller, do you want to keep your box or steal another players?

While Underwearfiller ponders the difficult choice to choose a box, the timer ticks down to under 24 hours remaining.

The other contestants continued to try and deceive him and each other in the mean time

100% swapping my box with him if he doesn't reply soon. Think he deserves the contents of my box for holding us up

Well, I have a bit of time before I have to decide, but while I don't often have this happen to me it has. So at least I have some familiarity with my prize

As it has been 72 hours, underwearfiller finds his box opening on its own. First a pie flys from a hidden compartment in his podium that hits him square in the face as punishment for going over the time limit.

Underwearfiller wipes his eyes to read the ticket found inside his box, "Take a bucket of slime". A bucket of green slime pours from the rafters of the studio directly over underwear fillers head! And the audience howls with laughter.

Moving right along after that interruption, Fatpiefan do you want to keep your box or trade it with a player who hasn't opened theirs?