I think all of them are funny and fun, but I'm curious what everyone's favorite is. Feel free to reply with your reasoning.

You're right - this one was difficult to chose! All these experiences are valid in their own ways and people should have a great time no matter what! Thanks for posting!

My pleasure!

bieng transformed and the makeup part is the part i enjoy the most and that i wanna experience~<3

Being pied as a clown.
Although am looking to do a clown pie off soon

pies is wonderfull

I agree. My face seems to love them

I've never been in clown make-up, but I would like to pie a clown and be pied by a clown.

Being pied by a clown. Especially if he's laughing at me as he is pieing me.

I want to be a clown's stooge.

Anyone interested in a 'straight' dressed guy to mess?

I just want to do a tit for tat slapstick decorating routine with loads of paste, paint and slosh. We get totally plastered in dungarees and then we get totally plastered naked too.

Any takers?

I'm definitely trying tit-fir-tat bakery slapstick next. Not sure whether to return to whipped cream pies, or stick with dough pies?

What do you guys think?

Whipped cream pies, pleasewith me being your tit for tat.

There needed to be a 5th option ...

Um ... yes?