Let's give this a try. If it works, great - if not, it will just fade slowly from view. The idea is to have a single thread where we can post comments, photos, and links to photos for all of our lost messy dares. Those dares would come from threads such as Loser Has To, Messy Hot Potato, and anything else that would result in a messy forfeit. Many of us come to UMD in search of such content, so having it all in one place might make some sense.

I lost this Messy Hot Potato:
1. Cover yourself from head to toe in brownie batter.
2. Give yourself a pie sandwich to the head, and one to the crotch and ass.
3. Give yourself a chocolate frosting facial.
4. Fuck a jar of peanut butter.
5. Give yourself a mayonnaise shampoo.

Some photos below, others in my profile:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/messy-hot-potato-lost-dares

For the first "Ladder Messy Game" I got off extremely easy, with having to do only 1 of the possible 12 messy items. It was shaving cream down my boxers.

More pics can be seem here:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/ladder-messy-dares

Video dare on my page....

I lost this "Loser Has to" dare: Loser ties feet together and hands behind back, kneels down and falls face first into two HUGE pies - one for face and one for crotch. Then stays like that for 5 minutes while humping the crotch pie. More pics here:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/loser-has-to-dares

I did a personal messy dare for MrPieNPlay: "Spread mayo all over yourself then your fill boxers with mayo front and back and then sit there for ten mins."

I used a full gallon of Mayo. Pictures can be seen here:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/personal-messy-dares

I lost a Messy Dice Game dare:
1. Chocolate Pudding Facial
2. Pie to the Crotch
3. Head dunk in a Bucket of Beans
4. Bucket of Ice Water
5. Porridge
6. Cover your Crotch in Peanut Butter

Photos can be seen here:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/messy-dice-game_2

Loser Has to dare with pics:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/loser-has-to-dares

I completed my forfeit today for losing the following messy dice dare. See my album for more photos:

1 - Bucket of whitewash (shaving foam & water mixed together) over your clothes.
2. Gravy in pants
3. Tub of ice cream in a swimsuit, let it melt before going onto the next. (My local shop did have any tubs, only blocks of ice cream).
4. Two cans of beans down the front of the swimsuit.
5. pie to the crotch, ass and chest
6.Custard down the back of the swimsuit

I recently lost a round of loser has to, where I had DM the victor for my forfeit, which is below. I completed this today and there are more photos in my album.

"I'm sure you've got plenty of heels so I want you to wear your favorite pair with stockings, and a nice dress with a bikini underneath. I really love the blonde hair you've got going on and keep the vibrant lipstick it looks wonderful under mess The mess you'll need is as follows; 4 large foam pies (preferably filled) a large bucket of slime, 4 cans of custard, a cake/trifle for your bum and bottle of syrup.

Start off barefoot (I'd love if you painted your toes as well) and stick both feet in the slime before putting on your stockings. Once you're in your heels use a little of the syrup and drizzle all down your legs to your toes. Then smack your ass a little spread those cheeks and hop right onto your trifle! Mush it around and feel the mess seep into your bottoms before it gets a little worse. I hope you really enjoy clothes filling because the custard is going down each leg!! I want to see it ooze from your stockings. Take two of the pies and give yourself a pie sandwich. By now you should look pretty messy but I want your dress trashed. Empty what's left of the syrup onto your outfit and face rubbing in the sticky goo. Once you're nice and sticky take the other two pies and put one at the front and rear of your crotch. Get ready to get the works, all that is left is the big bucket of slime and I want you to start by filling your bottoms until they're dripping with slime. Take what's left and give yourself a nice slimey shower to cool off"

Lost Messy Hot Potato:
Head dunk in a bucket of slime
3 containers of rice pudding
Pudding (didn't have custard) over head

Just completed this VERY messy personal dare from MrPieNPlay:
1) Fill your boxers with Shaving Foam til they are full.
2) Add a full bottle of Ketchup front and back.
3) Cover your face and chest with Foam Pies.
4) Pie to the crotch whilst pants are still full.
5) Cover your feet and legs with Mustard.
6) Give yourself a Mustard pie sandwich.
7) Give yourself a Mayo facial.
8) Give yourself a Wedgie front and back.
9) Finish with 10 Foam pies to the face that have Ketchup on them as well.

All pics can be seen here:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/personal-messy-dares

Just posted an album on my profile with a lost dare (recreated a shaving cream scene of the winner's choice).

I did a personal messy dare from MrPieNPlay:
"Whilst naked cover yourself in mayo and then cover yourself in ketchup."
I added some shaving cream to help with the cleanup

Pics can be seen here:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/personal-messy-dares

I lost a "loser has to" dare involving a full submerge, custard, flour and well, rest of pics on my profile

I was in the ladder game. Had to do shaving cream in the pants, cool whip, cake batter, cream pies, custard and applesauce. I've got pics of the shaving cream and ending pics with the applesauce here. Will add a few more of the middle items soon.

I lost a mk7 dare and was told to wear a tong to do this.

Loser has to take a warm bucket of oatmeal / porridge in an outfit of the winner's choosing from the loser's wardrobe.

I lost this "Loser has to" dare a while back: Loser uses the wheel to decide on which 5 messy items and 5 actions to use. Spin the Messy Items Wheel until all 5 of the messy items have come up, writing down the sequence. Unless you're extremely lucky, the sequence will include more than 5 entries. Then spin the Messy Actions Wheel once for each entry in the messy items sequence.
Messy Items Wheel:
http://wheeldecide.com/index.php?id=119522

Messy Actions Wheel:
http://wheeldecide.com/index.php?id=115965

The result from the wheel is pictured below

More pics are in my profile:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/loser-has-to-dares

From the Ladder Messy Game, Round 2, here's what I had to get messy with:

Custard
Mayonnaise Shampoo
Tub of Cold Cream
Thick n gooey flour slime
Cool Whip face coverage

A few pics below, more here:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/ladder-messy-dares

Here's a lost dare from the "If you catch me" game:

1. Put a goopy Bar of Soap in my mouth and keep it there until the end of the dare.
2. Cover my face with Chocolate Frosting.
3. Shampoo my hair with Mayonnaise.
4. Take a Shaving Cream Pie Sandwich to my head.
5. Empty an entire tube of Toothpaste onto my crotch and massage it in.
6. Take a Shaving Cream Pie Sandwich to my crotch and butt.

More pics are here:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/if-you-catch-me-dares

A personal dare from @Shampoo1 was to gunge my hair with vegetable oil, eggs, and mayonnaise. Then to clean up using tons of shampoo. I used about 7 large handfuls of shampoo, and then covered my face and ears with it in the end.

I got a personal dare from MrPieNPlay:

1. A plate of Mustard to the face,
2. Mayo cover yourself all over and face,
3. Beans over the head,
4. 5 Foam Pies with BBQ Sauce topping for face and body,
5. pour Paint over your head preferably Pink Paint,
6. finish with Ketchup all over head and body and lots of it.

As punishment because I didn't have a one-piece swim suit, I also had to fill my mouth with Mayo and leave it in there til I finished.

All the photos can be seen here:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/personal-messy-dares

Result of my punishment (from "If you catch me"), sorry some of the pictures aren't good towards the end, had some camera problems (one being that it got messy!), but shows that everything was done! For some reason umd put a couple of photos out of their order at the end, don't know why!

Didn't do very well at mixing the gunge, was rather lumpy and thick! Having to prove my cock isn't the biggest was probably the most embarrassing thanks to spankandgunge

Photos in profile here:
https://umd.net/profile/i/cd43/section/photos/album/if-you-catch-me-punishment

This was actually from a lost "If you catch me" dare on FetLife. I had to use up an entire bar of Pink Dove soap by covering my face, hair, ears, neck, and mouth in a mound of soapy lather. It took just over an hour to do. Here's the link to the game:
https://fetlife.com/groups/3462/group_posts/11879771

I lost this one !
Next loser will pie themselves in the face, crotch and bum and then pour a bucket of shaving foam slime over their head.
Pics/vid are here
https://umd.net/profile/i/pit76/section/photos/album/lost-at-loser-has-to
https://umd.net/profile/i/pit76/section/videos/video/lost-at-loser-has-to

Thanks to novagunger !!!

Lost this "potato" :
1) smash 5 shaving foam pies on you (face, chest, crotch, butt x2). Do this twice and finish with pie sandwich
2) paint your jeans with custard
3) wear a white t-shirt and paint it with 1 bottle of chocolate syrup

I was so happy to have lost my "potato" that I did a little more and went crazy!

PIcs and 2 Vids here :
https://umd.net/profile/i/pit76/section/photos/album/lost-at-hot-messy-potato
https://umd.net/profile/i/pit76/section/videos

Lost a "Loser has to... dare, the dare was a "Total Shaving Foam Annihilation"
I have to pie myself with 7 shaving foam pies and pour 6 buckets of foam gunge.
I made the shaving foam gunge buckets from the most liquid to the cremiest and decided to do a head dunk in the leftovers with a last-extra bucket as a cherry on the cake !

Click here for the two parts of the videao : https://umd.net/profile/i/pit76/section/videos

Just did this personal messy dare:

Crack 10 eggs over your head.
6 eggs down your pants.
Fill your pants with mayo.
Cover your face / hair with mayo.
Pour custard over your head.
Pour ketchup down the back of your pants.
Give yourself a wedgie.

More pics are here:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/personal-messy-dares

This was from a personal "If you catch me" dare, played here via personal messages. I had to head dunk in a bucket of chocolate pudding - but I didn't have enough pudding to fill the bucket so I added a container of marshmallow fluff and 2 cans of shaving cream. It got a little more runny than I expected, but it was sufficiently messy.

Pics are also in my profile:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/personal-messy-dares

This is my first loss in the Spin for a Pie game. I had to take 4 pies: 1 to my face, 2 for a pie sandwich, and 1 to sit on. More pics are here:
https://umd.net/profile/i/tiedandmessy/section/photos/album/spin-for-a-pie-game