I'll run another round, picking options from all the rounds other people hosted. The buckets today have molasses, ranch dressing, cottage cheese, gravy, and green slime.
I got off lightly in the last splatter seats, a bucket of cold slimy gunge.
Next round has a twist and is not for the faint of heart. 5 seats, 5 pies but who gets the worst one? (Hint there's only one that's not gross) - Custard - Mushy peas and ketchup - Cream and brown sauce - Macaroni cheese and american mustard - Dog Food and mayo Pay up pics are required even if they're just pictures of the pies or the aftermath. If the game fails to get 5 players in one week then participating players will be picked at random to take multiple pies.