Here's what Jessie had to say about this scene when it was first released in 2013:

It is now my turn to be the "donkey"... Annabelle is blind-folded and handed pies. She actually does very well, but there is a bit of cheating along the way, on both parts!

Although Annabelle does well, I remove am a little bit cheeky and pie Annabelle while she is still blind-folded! Needless to say, Annabelle swiftly removes her blindfold and pies me back!

We end up having a bit of a pie fight, but it's all good fun!