Hello there! I wanted pose a question to all our pie video producers "What is your all time number 1 selling pie video?". By this I mean what 1 video sold the most number of downloads?

I think it might be interesting if we got enough responses here to.see if there are any connections through themes, models, or details.

Here are our top 5.

Pie Business
Liz, Amber and Vicky
Liz, Vicky and Danielle
Tilly and Penelope
The Naughty Pie Fight

still Tales of the Unexpected with some stiff competition from Sorority Bakeoff. heh heh stiff competition.

For Pied Pinups best seller, surprised it's not the Red Curtain Sessions:

https://piedpinups.com/cgi/autogal.pl?vidnum=tws-129-0022

Excellent question, Kake!

The MG one with Penelope in the blue pictured above, I do believe is one of MGs best pie fights indeed!

And I love Tales and Sorority too! They are best sellers for a reason!

I'm slightly fascinated that there's no New(er) Amy vids on there as far as MessyGirl goes -- i feel like she would've cleaned up, but I also feel like her stuff must be resting just beneath all those others.

I love that the Penelope-Tilly one's on there; one of the hottest, sexiest, most sensual of all time.

Probably Naughty Girls:

https://umd.net/profile/i/mudmadphil/section/videos/video/naughty-girls

Closely followed by Pie Heaven:

https://umd.net/profile/i/mudmadphil/section/videos/video/pie_heaven--trailer

Mine would definitely be the Pie Pod series, but "Lilly James in the Hardcore Pie Pod" is the clear winner.

https://umd.net/download_info/lilly-james-in-the-hardcore-pie-pod

why cant this happen for me??? ^^^^^ WHYYYYEEEEE????!!!! I NEED the men in my life (which are all "friends" and "roomates") why cant they just get it together and make this happen for me??? HUH???!!! DAMNIT!!

it looks amazing!

this is ONE of the pie ones that sold well when it was released, right off the bat.

I think people dont come to me for pies for some reason but i make some really awesome pies, actually! these were not even my best. i think the outfit and the whole idea is what sold it it was cute as can be! plus some slime and hijinks were had.

ill post some others in a bit...im looking through sales. i just remember this one doing well right off the bat.
I remember them asking for shaving foam pies and i asked if i could do cool whip pies...so we did. I threw in a couple and the ones that were foam? had a large heaping of cool whip underneath. but most were cool whip. i prefer it. they were cool!
this is fun to see which ones did okay and try to figure it out. i never will but its fun to try. haha

https://umd.net/download_info/because-i-deserve-it-pies-s

1. Target Practice
2. Thank You! (again!)
3. The Meet and Greet
4. The Receptionist
5. Fan Mail

However! 'A Day in the Life (of The Wife)' is our best seller in the entire store, but I wasn't sure how to classify it for your question! It has 8 mini scenes that have The Wife go from clean to messy; 4 with a slime, and 4 with a pie.

This is a Great Thread Idea. It's so hard to keep up with all the various producers who come and go, but when the established ones give you their top of the pop, it's easy to see why they've stuck around for so long.

My top 5 would be

1) The Epic 9 Girl Restaurant Pie Fight
2) Miss WAM Party... Pts 1 and 2
3) Pies On A Plane
4) Totally Trashed 2: Maria's Naked WAM Shame
5) Bridesmaid V Waitress Messy Catfight

Though, as The Man said, it's difficult to judge what counts as a pie video. I excluded a few scenes which had a few pies but where I felt that the majority of the mess was non-pie. For these 5 the majority of the mess is pies (and cakes) but only Pies On A Plane has nothing but pies. I think I have only made about 5 scenes with nothing but pies, so that list would write itself!

I think it's pretty obvious why my collaboration with The Moomins is No 1. 9 Girls, the happy marriage of the Moomins' amazing sets / pies and my script/set-up and great models from both studios. Amazing pies both pushed and thrown. It was a Hollywood budget production and it shows.

The Miss WAM scenes are probably there because I priced them under $3 as most of the footage came out in 1998 level quality..but it showed that if you price fairly and are upfront about flaws, there's still interest in seeing 3 amazing models, including the mega popular Honour May, in a pie fight for less than the price of a cup of coffee

Pies On A Plane was a custom and the first part, especially, really landed with people. Kacie James, Louise Lee and Kyla Louise and loads of pies..what's not to love

Totally Trashed 2: This is the oldest scene on the list, so it has had plenty of time to build an audience. Maria gives a terrific performance, and Jessie and Kitten do a great job in tieing her up and destroying her.

Bridesmaid v Waitress: Again..a simple concept but it seemed to land very well, and Axa and Chloe were always great together..as they were best friends in real life, they weren't afraid to pie like they meant it.

Great thread indeed.

I'm pretty sure there are a butt-ton of men out there willing to do this to Jayce!

And wow, are we the only PG store in this thread so far? lol

We aren't really a piehaus, though we do sometimes do scenes that feature pieing as part of more overall wenchmessing. Looking across our stores at the moment, our five best selling scenes where pies are a significant part of the action are:

1. MyPieRogative's Initiation: https://umd.net/download_info/mypierogatives-initiation
Rosemary initiates the legend who is Maria into the way of things here at Saturation Hall.
Rosemary wears dazzling white polo shirt and cream jodhpurs, Maria wears a lovely skin-tight purple running outfit. Both get very messy!

2. Slave Maude's Punishment Pies: https://umd.net/download_info/slave-maudes-pies
Slave girl Maude, in a very short black dress, slave collar and chain lead, gets totally destroyed with pies and custard at the hands of our spike-heeled, pinstriped, and corseted German dominatrix Willomina Worry, who also gets drenched in mess.

3. PVC, Pudding, and Pie: https://umd.net/download_info/pvc-puddding-and-pie
Friday and Chastity, both in black PVC, totally cover each other in pies and custard.

4. Pies and Custard and Glitter: https://umd.net/download_info/gunge-and-glitter
This was a scene Chastity actually requested for herself, where she first gets pied and then gets a bucket of custard dumped over her, all delivered by Willomina Worry. Chastity then gets glitterbombed too, just to finish things off.

5. Schoolgirl Pie Fight: https://umd.net/download_info/schoolgirl-pie-fight
Maude and Rosemary, both dressed in black and white school uniforms, destroy each other with pies, including lots of face hits - we shot this one deliberately as a pie-focused scene.

Some images from each set attached, mainly the actual pie ones from each set, click the links above to see the full previews for each scene.

Great lists!!

I'm long-time retired now, of course, but Tabitha's First Modelling Shoot takes the cake (or pie). It cost me 180.00 to produce (in 1998, using a hi-8mm key camera and an 8mm b-roll camera), but over it's many reincarnations, has sold/earned more than 25 times that amount.

I remember this one from way back. It's a classic.

Hmmm, wonder what the connecting thread is (in 4 of 5 anyway). Feels like you guys have strayed away from the kissing/lesbian vids lately. Too bad, you have some great ones in the archives.

As Tom DeLonge once put it (before he went all UFO crazy)

"The most special kind of love is the love that exists between two naked women while I watch"

This old thing...