After getting stripped and receiving a brutal shoulder wedgie off-screen, Fabian finds himself tied up at the mercy of an intruder. He's bound with his hands tied above his head, blind-folded with a bandana, and forced to sniff his own sneaker tied to his head. The strange intruder unmuzzles Fabian and demands that he give him the code to his safe. He refuses, and with that, his captor unleashes a barrage of pies and torment, all while Fabian squirms and begs him for mercy.

The pies never seem to stop coming. His captor drizzles him in cold chocolate syrup, and uses mini pie tins to get at his more... sensitive areas. After Fabian finally gives in to the mess, the intruder makes it known that he already knew the code to the safe, and Fabian's messy humiliation was all solely for his pleasure. He laughs at his stupidity, and leaves him tied and trashed for someone else to find.