Heads up.... This is my fantasy that I wrote, and I've decided I'm sharing. It's the kinkiest thing I've ever written so be warned! Lol!
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------MyPieRogatives fantasy

Around 8 o'clock last Friday night I was sitting anxiously on my sofa waiting for Blue Eyes to arrive to my house. We had plans to go to a bar not far from the house and discuss our upcoming trip scheduled for August. I was already feeling a tightening in the pit of my stomach knowing he would arrive at any minute. I hoped I could get my act together and focus on our little meeting instead of envisioning him fucking me and smashing creamy pies into my face. Thus far our plans to work on trip details had turned into just that.

I heard a light knock on the door and then a creaking as he opened the door and entered my kitchen. I was up and moving towards him immediately. "Hey baby", I said enthusiastically bouncing into the kitchen. He wrapped his arm around me for a tight hug and gentle kiss. When I buried my head into his neck his scent already started working its magic on me. I truly believe if I had a blindfolded test with 100 men, all washed with the same body wash and all wearing the same deodorant, I'd be able to pick out my sweet blue eyes from the lineup. I pulled away, knowing I must look flushed, and smiled into his eyes. He patted my butt and asked playfully, "ready to go baby?!" "Aye aye captain" I saluted to him, before grabbing my purse and heading for the door.

On the drive to the bar I stared over at him with a small smirk on my face. Looking at him I couldn't help allowing fantasies to flood my mind with all the experiences I wanted to share with him, thoughts of experiences he had already given me. He had his secret pie fetish that he shared with me, so I don't know why I felt I couldn't share all of my secret fantasies with him. He glanced over at me in the dark car, and asked with a cautious chuckle, "what?!" I was happy the car was so dark with its tinted windows and replied, "oh nothing. Just looking at you." He smirked, and continued driving. We pulled up to the back parking lot of the bar a few moments later, and proceeded to go inside to make our big plans. He gave my hand the usual small squeeze, and landed a little pat on my butt as we walked sending shivers up my spine.

We sat at a small table in a dark corner of the bar and began discussing our trip after ordering a coupes drinks. He ordered some fancy dark bitter beer that I had no interest in, and I grabbed my delicious sweet woodchuck cider. After an hour of going over prices, routes, and excursion destinations I stood up to use the restroom declaring, "time to break the seal," as I walked away. I heard another small chuckle from Blue Eyes as I began my walk toward the small bathroom. When I got to the door there was a beautiful curly red headed girl leaning against the wall by the bathroom door. I stood behind her to wait. She was wearing a little blue and green sundress that looked great with her red locks. Being a loud mouth I couldn't help but comment, "your hair is so gorgeous!" She beamed at me with a beautiful smile and responded with an almost shy "thank you." The bathroom door opened and she disappeared inside, as the current resident slipped out and back through the doorway leading into the dimly lit bar.

I took the red heads spot leaning against the wall and thought about how pretty I thought she was, and how nice her energy felt. I thought Blue Eyes would like her too, and at that thought I felt a twinge of jealousy creep into my chest, but immediately scolded myself for the insecure silliness. I sometimes hate being a woman. It seems those jealous feeling are sometimes unavoidable, even if you detest them. The doors opened and the red head walked away, smiling at me as she went. I watched her as she walked towards the bar and took notice of the way her hips twitched as she walked, and the dress hugged her curves. I entered the bathroom thinking once again about Him... and sex. I stood for a moment looking into the mirror thinking about whether or not I should share my secret fantasy with him. I began to imagine sitting and watching his naked body from head to toe moving against the red head. I closed my eyes and parted my legs slightly allowing space for my hand to drift up my dress and into my panties. I let out a deep breath as I began rubbing my clit imagining Blue Eyes making this red head cry out for him to fuck her harder, while I sat and watched, waiting with pies to slam in her face. Rubbing faster and harder I imagined telling this girl I'd share him with her for a night, allowing her the chance to experience his hard masterful cock that was all mine. I quickly came, moaning, and felt the sticky wetness below covering my panties, and my legs lightly trembled beneath me. When I opened my eyes I laughed seeing my dazed face in the mirror. I asked myself, "what in the hell am I doing," before using the toilet and exiting the bathroom quickly with a guilty look on my face.

As I walked back up to the table I noticed a mischievous look on Blue Eyes face. He then immediately said very loudly, "that took a while! What!... were ya taking a dump baby?!" I rolled my eyes laughing and replied just as playfully, "no honey bunny... I was masturbating!" We both laughed and I sat back down across from him at our small dark table. When I looked up I noticed the red head sitting alone at the bar directly over his right shoulder, and smirked. He twisted around to look behind him before looking at me again and asking, "what are you looking at?" I was silent a moment and thought to myself, "crap. I'm just gonna spill it." Taking a deep breath I opened my mouth and spoke quickly, "so, I wasn't joking about masturbating in the bathroom. I have a threesome fantasy, and I started imagining you fucking that red head at the bar... And, well, I couldn't help it!" He turned to look behind him again and looked back at me laughing hysterically and said, "baby! Are you messing with me?! That's fucking hot!" I looked downwards blushing before returning my eyes up to his and asking softly and nervously, "so, do you want to try it?" He realized I might be serious and his face changed. There was a slight caution. Perhaps he was worried this might be some kind of weird messed up girl test. Luckily, his trust in my dirty mind won out, and he responded, "sure. What's your plan baby?" I took a sip of my cider and sat back realizing I didn't actually have a plan. It didn't take long for me to figure out that he would have to start this off alone, working his magic on her. "Go sit next to her and just start talking baby. After a few minutes ask to buy her a drink and I'll be over in a bit. Just make sure to be extra flirty! After you introduce me you can go to bathroom and I'll talk to her alone for a little longer." He laughed again shaking his head as if to say my plan was flawed, but being a good sport he got up, smiled, and walked to the bar.

I curled my legs up into my chair Indian style and leaned forward, cider in hand, ready to start the show. I smiled watching him begin working his magic. When she turned her body language changed immediately. The red head beamed at him, sitting a little straighter, and crossing her legs. "Hmmm? Maybe my plan will work" I thought to myself as I watched on. I heard her laughing and couldn't even begin to imagine what ridiculous silly crap had just come out of his sweet mouth. After about 20 minutes of them flirting the night away I decided it was time to walk up. I swigged the last sip out of my bottle and began the short nerve filled walk towards the duo. When I tapped on his shoulder he turned toward me smiling and looped an arm around my waste pulling me in. "Hey baby", he exclaimed brightly, followed by an introduction to the red head I now know as Katherine. She looked slightly confused, but smiled and said hello all the same. I sat down on the other side of Blue Eyes putting him in between us girls. We all chatted together for sometime. Katherine had started to relax again, probably due to realizing that my boyfriends atrocious flirting was apparently completely normal, and not upsetting to me in the foggiest. It was around ten-thirty when he excused himself to the restroom. Katherine wasted no time commenting on how lovely Blue Eyes was as soon as he departed. I smiled and told her, "I know it. He obviously really likes you." She looked slightly startled at my comment and hastily added, "I didn't mean anything weird by that." I laughed and said, "no it's cool! We have an interesting relationship. I actually asked him to come talk to you because I've been interested in trying a threesome." Her eyes widened, and I quickly continued," Sorry to be so blunt! I've never been in this situation before, I know I sound nuts! But... Ummm... Do you think you'd be interested in that? Like in kind of a sub role? I think you're gorgeous, and would love the experience." She started laughing and told me that she had experienced a threesome before with an ex-boyfriend. She further explained that she would be interested in being the "toy" girl in a threesome. Now it was my turn to have my eyes widen, "holy crap! Really?! So you want to try this with us?!" She laughed, and said, "sure! Why the hell not?!" I knew I liked this girl.

Blue Eyes returned from the bathroom just has Katherine and I were standing and closing out our tabs. I looked over to him and winked. His face went white with shock. I'm sure he couldn't believe what looked like was happening was actually happening. I turned to him and said playfully, " ready to go baby? Katherine wants to come over to play!" He responded with a low and cracked, "yep." Seeing his face made this so much fun already! On the walk to the car I walked behind Katherine and Blue Eyes. When Katherine turned to walk towards her car I noticed she brushed his hand with a very purposeful stroke of her finger. I smiled, knowing she wanted him to be inside her, and that it was up to me to allow it. On the drive home he began asking multiple questions about what I had said to her, and to make sure I was really okay with all of this. I loved him, and knew I could trust him. I explained this and let him know that his concern and asking all of these questions showed how faithful he is. I also explained that she had signed on to be our toy, and as long as she remained in that role then there was nothing to worry about. When we pulled up to my house I went upstairs ahead to pull out some supplies, yelling back to him to walk Katherine up.

Once in my house I went straight to the refrigerator and took 3 pies out and placed them near my bed. I then grabbed sheets from my linen closet and began spreading them across my floor and bed for damage control. When I looked up Katherine was in the doorway looking confused. I motioned to her to sit next to me on the bed, as he followed in behind her. I gave a brief explanation of our pie fetish, explaining it's just some silly fun, and that she didn't have to partake if she felt uncomfortable. She laughed in disbelief and stated firmly that if I was getting a pie she would try it too. Once again Katherine was proving to be a kindred free spirit. I excused myself to take a quick shower and giggled as I walked away, flirtatiously telling Katherine to feel free to start warming Blue Eyes up. He laughed and called back, "I don't think it will take much at this point baby!"

The hot water felt delightful running down my bare skin. I imagined what could possibly have started in the bedroom already and was dying to touch myself again. I decided against it, not wanting to miss any of the action going on on the next room. I quickly hopped out and dried off after my super fast lather and rinse. I applied a little lotion to my arms and legs before slowly opening the door and creeping into the next room. My pussy tightened immediately and began dripping when I saw him sitting on the side of the bed, looking down at Katherine who was wearing only a small black lace thong. She was on her knees moving very slowly up and down sucking my mans dick. He sensed my movement and looked up at me, I quickly motioned to him to not say a word. He watched me crawl up naked behind Katherine and kneel behind her, pushing my naked breast against her back and feeling her ass against my pelvis. She moaned when I pushed against her and began moving slightly quicker on his delicious cock. I wrapped one arm around her to massage her breast, and my other hand wrapped around her to slowly, and teasingly started massaging her clit. Blue Eyes let out a small sighing plea, as Katherine moaned a little louder. I whispered into Katherine's ear loud enough that he could hear, and staring into his eyes said, "he tastes good doesn't he? Do you like his big dick in your mouth?" Katherine muddled out a yes sound, unable to speak with his dick filling her pretty little mouth. I began rubbing faster, and she began moving faster, he began breathing faster, all the while looking back and forth from my eyes to Katherine bobbing up and down on his firm cock.

I grabbed a pie from the bed side table and quietly asked Katherine if she was ready to taste a creamy pie. She lifted her head, but I pushed her back down saying, "keep pleasing him Katherine, I'll pull your head up when he's ready." Blue Eyes groaned loudly upon hearing my commanding Katherine to continue servicing his sweet boner. I smiled into his eyes and winked at him. He smiled back, but quickly his face returned to a pleading furrowed state, concentrating on all the physical sensations of our little Katherine on his dick. I wanted to taste his come dripping down my tongue. I twisted my hand into Katherine's hair and firmly pulled her head back slamming a creamy banana pie into her face, and smearing it upward over her head. She squealed in surprise, and I pushed her mouth back down to his cock. Guiding her head up and down with my fingers twisted in her hair I never took my eyes off his face. I loved his immediate reaction to seeing the cream coating Katherine's face and dripping down his shaft. When he began to murmur "oh god, oh my fucking god" repeatedly I knew his hot spurts of come would soon be released. I pulled Katherine's mouth away saying, "this comes for me" and with my own greedy mouth began sucking on Blue Eyes dick. Hot come began shooting onto my tongue the moment I started sucking. I moaned loudly, happy I had gotten to him in time to drink it all. I felt Katherine's fingers entering my wet pussy from behind me. Holding his slippery dick in my mouth I felt a hard clenching deep inside me and began coming around her juiced fingers. I pulled back moaning "fuck", and asked if he could keep going looking at his still rock hard penis. He immediately said, "yes", and I stood and pulled Katherine up with me. She had wiped the cream from her eyes, and I told her she looked beautiful before kissing her deeply, feeling the pie spread onto my face. I pulled back and asked her, "are you ready to come? Can I watch him fuck you?" She replied softy, "of course", and climbed to lay on the bed.

After kissing Blue Eyes again, I took a seat in the swinging hammock chair next to the bed, wet and ready to watch him fuck this beautiful pie covered girl. He crawled toward her slowly, then after sitting up, he firmly grabbed her hips and yanked her pussy toward him. Katherine and I both moaned in response to this rough commanding gesture. I watched on, continuously rubbing and prodding myself faster. I could see his muscles flexing as his hand gripped Katherine tightly, I called to him pleading, "tease her baby. Open her up slowly, please." He looked over at me and smiled before returning to work. He loosened his grip and began slowly pushing his head into Katherine's wetness, gently opening her pussy before slowly pulling out completely, and leaving her empty and lonely inside for a few seconds before repeating this torturous move. Katherine began squirming beneath him, and whimpering. She pushed her wet pussy towards him spreading her legs wider, begging for him to fill her. I stopped rubbing myself and walked to sit on the edge of the bed right above Katherine's head, my back against the wall. I looked down at her and she looked back up at me with a painful wanting look in her eyes. I brushed her hair back and said, "If you want him to fuck you hard you have to beg." She responded immediately by lifting her head and looking to him begging him, "please fuck me! Please!" He looked to me and after one more teasing pull out he slammed his cock into Katherine. She cried out continuously begging him for more. I began touching my pussy again, using my free hand to squeeze and pinch at her nipples as they bounced up and down from him smacking into her. We all moaned hearing the wet sploshing noises from both of our dripping vaginas.

I wanted Katherine to lick my pussy while she got fucked, so I asked Blue Eyes to stop and flip her over. He immediately pulled out and flipped Katherine in one movement. I slid against the wall until my pussy was in her face. Katherine had no hesitation and shoved her tongue into me. She began swirling it up and down my clit and I cried out and looked up at Blue Eyes who was back inside Katherine pounding and watching us. I wanted Katherine to arch her back and push her ass higher so I could see the smacking ripples on her skin as he fucked her. When I said this he slapped her ass and commanded, "push your ass up!" Katherine and I both made satisfying moans at his forceful commanding tone. I grabbed another pie from the table and pulled Katherine's head up. I wanted to see the pleasure in her face getting fucked by my man. Her face was tight and and she bit her lips letting out small pleading sounds, I kept asking her questions, "does that feel good," "Do you want more," "Is he fucking you hard baby?" Each reply was "yes", louder and louder the closer she came to climax. I looked up at him and demanded he make her come. I handed the pie to Blue Eyes asking him to squish it against her ass. I loved the way the cream felt on my ass, and wanted to let Katherine feel it too. He moaned, and fucked her even harder as he smashed the pie against her ass. I watched him smear the creamy banana pie across her skin and give her a firm smack. Katherine began crying out and I shoved her face back down to me, feeling her scream her orgasm into my pussy. Blue Eyes pulled away panting, saying he wasn't ready to come yet. Katherine caught her breath and continued working my clit with her tongue. I stared into his blue eyes as she brought me again. The orgasm ripples through my body leaving me panting and moaning squirming on the bed. He then stood up and told me to lay flat on the ground with my legs in air. I rolled off the bed to the floor and obeyed.

When I was in his requested position he smacked my feet and said, "flat." I flattened my feet and he proceeded to gently pop a pie from its tin and place it on my feet. "Don't drop it" he growled. I obeyed. He then put his hand out to Katherine pulling her to stand in front of my up stretched legs and the balancing pie. My legs felt weak and were lightly shaking from the orgasm, I silently prayed that I didn't drop his pie. I watched him cautiously as he positioned and watched us carefully, all the while slowly stoking his cock with his free hand. When he had us lined up he wrapped his hand in Katherine's hair and took a deep shuttering breath before pushing her face down to my feet. I felt the pie squeeze between my toes and I began rubbing my feet against her face. He held her in place as I wiggled my toes against her and prodded her mouth open. Katherine moaned and opened her mouth and began sucking my toes. I stretched my legs further twisting my foot pushing it as far as I could into her mouth, continuously rubbing her skin with my other foot. Blue Eyes moaned and pulled Katherine back. He put his hand down to me and yanked me to my feet twisting me and forced me to lay at the edge of the bed. He looked like a wild animal and began fucking me hard and deep. I motioned for Katherine to climb up and told her to straddle me. She followed my directions and laying on top of me we began kissing with her pussy and ass tempting him as well. I stopped kissing her long enough to tell Blue Eyes to fuck both of us before plunging my tongue back in Katherine's mouth. He pulled out of me and I felt Katherine's body sliding against my skin. She began moaning again and so did I. He moved back and forth between our sopping wetness bringing us to the brink of orgasm before moving to the next pussy. The torture seemed to continue forever, until finally he cried out letting us know he was about to come. I pushed Katherine off me, our cream covered bodies allowing her to slide smoothly to the floor. I knelt beside her and we opened our mouths waiting to share the fresh stream of his hot come. He cried out as we rubbed our clits in unison, our eyes pleading with him to feed us. His come began to shoot out, and he twisted his hips from side to side sharing his come between us. When the come stopped dripping we both began licking the remaining sweet juice from his dick, each rubbing and bringing ourselves to climax yet again. When we were all satisfied we dropped to the sheets on the floor panting, caressing, and making small contented moans. We laid like that for a while before cleaning up.

Katherine announced she needed to be getting home after we had cleaned off and settled down. She gave us her phone number on a piece of paper, and after hugs departed. Blue Eyes and I high-fived, and I took Katherine's number saying cheekily, "I think I'll be the one to keep hold of that... My lovey dove."