While this short 4-minute 20-second video is all face pie hits and one thick slime/gunge coverage. Sadly, not full body coverage and not an underwear scene. But, the pies are thick and sticky, which is great!

For the price ($3) it is ok, for this 3 minute video, but only for the sexy underwear. The shaving cream foam is very weak. But, I absolutely love the underwear they wear. I do wish they stood up more. I bought this because I was buying another video (from Port City Slophouse) and I had to exceed the $5 minimum purchase amount.

Nearly 17 minutes of good material.

0:00 to 0:40 excellent multiple pies to Liz Ashley.

1:25 to 1:33 overlaps with a scene from Vol 7 "The Early Years"

The Lexi pie hits in Volume 4 are different from those in Volume 3,

So that's good.

I liked all the models in this. Sorry--I don't know their individual names

other than Lexi & Liz Ashley & Fae (from justpieme.com) at the end.

I like that the models do not lick their lips or stick out their tongues.

I've always found that distracting in other videos.

I like that they just sit there and mostly take it.

Call me dull or uninspired, but a lot of imagined ideas & variations don't work out in practice. This Volume 4 keeps things simple.

I was thrilled with getting my money's worth on ph Vol 3: The Lexi Years. That was a concern prior to my purchase. PH3 is a full 16 min 53 sec. I had already owned PH7 "The Early Years", which includes the same Lexi "Pie Me" 3 min 46 sec scene of Lexi sitting topless in black panties getting pied with mostly all white pies. So I knew I'd pay for this same scene twice. But, even without this Lexi "Pie Me" scene, which is the final scene on PH3, I was still left with a full 13 minutes of new-to-me all Lexi material. And boy, does Lexi deliver! I finally got to see in full high-res glory all the Lexi pie scenes that I'd been seeing as low-res.gifs or.jpgs! Lexi reacts exactly as she should: by doing nothing! By not licking her lips! By just standing there, looking dejected. Now, I would prefer the shots to include the crotch. And I do prefer bras. And as a long-time customer of mg, I know bras are not their thing. So, I knew that going in. My one complaint: I'd prefer midway shots that include the crotch/panties. Most of the shots seem to be taken above the waste. However, the repeated pie coverage of Lexi made up for this minor issue. These are almost all standalone-and-get-pied-by-off-camera person, both thrown & smushed (I prefer smushed), hits.

I don't know what I can say to make this better.

The editors put in a labor of love stringing together all the facial pie hits from many scenes to cater to us pie-in-the-face humiliation fans. 27minutes of joy. Warning: The separate segments are not labeled.

Segment 1: Katie getting pied in the face by a clown.

Segment 2: Veronica pied in 2 separate scenes: first in blue nightgown, to topless then black nightgown to topless.

Segment 3: Brenda in red dress pied

Segment 4: Cute short-haired woman pied in black dress

Segment 5: Cute red-head whose name I had but forgot gets pied with fruit-filled white pies then white pies: head-on and side angles.

Segment 6: Cute short-haired blonde pied twice in pink shirt with all-white pies.

Segment 7: Large-breasted topless Raven pied with white pies head-on and side angles.

Segment 8: Maddie/Madison--the segment I longed for, not the least of which because it is long (longer than the others); Over 5 minutes of Maddie topless with black lingerie pulled down getting repeatedly humiliated with mostly white but fruit-filled and sticky-caramel-filled pies thrown from off-camera. While each pie throw does not cover her whole face, like the pies in the earlier segments, the accumulation of all those pies certainly does, making for a very sexy very humiliating experience. We get treated to head-on upper body shot then side angle showing Madison's lovely sexy long leg. Cut to Maddie-Madison sitting naked on floor with feet in stocks: she starts out clean, but many pies tossed into her face, mostly white but mixed with sticky fruits, accumulated for a very sexy humiliating experience for the viewer. Head-on full-body shot, then side angle full-body shot. All pies thrown quickly in succession with pie tins.

Segment 9: 1 minute 10 seconds Upper-body shot of topless Liz Ashley getting pied by off-camera with 3 very heavy very sticky white pies: head-on then repeat from her right side angle, pies quick in succession. Then 3 more, this time white mixed with chocolate, pies. First facing head on, then from right angle. Finally 2 white pies thrown, first one only partial hit, second one better. Again, 2 angles. All pies thrown quickly in succession with pie tins.

Segment 10: 3 minutes 30 seconds Lexi "Pie Me" session. All pies thrown quickly in succession with pie tins. Lexi sitting in cute sexy black panties on floor. She's topless. All pies very thick and sticky and white. Each pie causing devastating total facial coverage. Pie thickness here was greater than that of any other scene on this tape. Maximal sexy humiliation for fans of humiliating pie-faces. I admit: I prefer pies without tins. The tins accumulating distract a little. Pies thrown just in crusts I prefer. But I am sure that would add expense & time to the shoot. We have midway shots (torso & above) and wide shots showing her sitting in panties.

Segment 11: 1 minute Amber in white wedding dress pied with sticky thick white pies mixed with caramel and chocolate. 3 pies, face-on, repeated from angle, each pie totally covering her face, with pie tins. Then 2 pies, face-on, repeated from right angle, each pie totally covering her face, with pie tins. Amber's reactions were excellent. The pie also totally covering her upper chest. Shot from torso up only.

Segment 12: 1 minute Amber in this schoolgirl scene did even better acting of irritation. Midway shot only. Face-on angle only. Smushed-pied, not thrown, with tins, with Amber chewing gum with adorable pigtails dressed as a schoolgirl. Excellent facial coverage. Both white pies. Amber wearing white tied top. Then shot of after-green-slimed Amber, with top loosened to reveal breasts, still with adorable pigtails. Twice smooshed pies to her face, total facial coverage & humiliation and best reactions ever! Midway torso shot only from face-on. I do prefer smushed-pies in general to thrown.

Segment 13: One minute. I think this is Amber again. Midway torso shot only face-on only. Wearing green sweater. 3 thrown white pies, NO tins, total facial coverage from 1st & 3rd, very humiliating, and excellent reactions by Amber. Then, I believe Amber again, "Pie Me", midway shot only face-on only. Topless. Three white pies tossed in her face. Excellent coverage. Then she bends over for a butt shot

Segment 14: I believe the final three segments are all Vicky. I wish I could do her more justice. Vicky in kitchen wearing white tank top pied off hands with white pies filled with sticky fruit. Then she goes topless. I really liked that these pies had NO tins. And were mixed with sticky colorful fruit.

Segment 15: Vicky in wedding dress pied by clown hand with 4 pies. Very sticky white pies mixed with chocolate and fruits. Midway torso shots only. But first head-on, then repeated from angle.

Segment 16: The final minute of this video of Vicky naked, previously green slimed, but getting super heavy thick white pies, thrown into her face, rapidly in succession, with no pie tins, was the unexpected super sexy surprise of the video for me. First from torso-up only from her left angle. Then repeated from more left angle showing her entire naked body. I'm not a naked guy or a stockade guy. What made this one very exciting was each pie being thick, heavy, sticky, totally facially covering the actress, rapid in succession with great cumulative effect.

I selected pss3 because of the still photos shown of Linda & Sara (Segment 3) pied in the face and of Allison & Nikki (Segment 1) pied in the face. The facial pie hits from these 2 segments alone made me give this a "great scene" rating.

Segment 1 "Allison & Nikki" 10 minutes Allison & Nikki take turns giving each 3 humiliating pies in the face, while dressed.

Then they pour various colored gunge including chocolate all over each others' heads. They strip down to sexy panties and continue rubbing and re-using the pie & gunge that has already fallen all over each others faces to round out this segment.

Segment 2 "Linda & Sara" 4 minutes Linda wears a French maid costume while she gets humiliated with 3 pies to her face thrown from off camera. Then Linda gunges topless Sara with thick green gunge all over Sara's head. Finally, we are treated to Linda getting 3 thrown perfect white sticky pies to her face while Sara gets 2 perfectly thrown off camera pies to her face

Segment 3 "Raven & Sara" 5 minutes 30 seconds Raven delivers a fantastic sticky white pie to Sara's face at the beginning. Good long pause on Sara's face.

Then a double pie sandwich to Sara. Raven gets pied, too. Then they each pour less thick, more transparent lighter green gunge over each other while both are topless in panties. The final 20 seconds: an off camera white sticky pie thrown into Raven & Sara's faces one more time with excellent facial coverage of Raven.

Segment 4 "Slimed Lexi" 8 minutes 30 seconds

Lexi in a black lingerie sits on floor while yellow, then blue, then pink, and ultimately chocolate gunge cover her totally.

She rubs it all over herself. Super for fans of long segments of total gunge head to toe coverage and self-massage.

Segment 5 "Liz's Oatmeal Bath" 7 minutes

Liz Ashley in a vinyl dress submerges herself entirely into a bath of oatmeal. Although not my reason for selecting this video,

I praise this scene for using a much less explored WAM material: oatmeal, and for helping to keep the oatmeal companies in business. Liz does a great job, fitting into this tub, total facial coverage, self-massage, and stripping down naked for naked fans.

I have to be honest: I have to tie this review with reviews of two other Messygirl videos which I purchased at the same time as this one with the 2-for-3 offer: Pied, Slimed, & Submerged 3 (psg3) and Pie Hits Volume 7: The Early Years. My main desire was Pie Hits Volume 7. I wanted to try the 2-for-3 offer, and I am glad I did. However, I really wanted only the Pie Hits series of videos for pie-hits to faces only (specifically Vol 8 & 9 and "The Lexi Years", but are not available in the vault) especially in underwear.

The sample photos in the Messy Girl Vault of totally pied in the face Nikki & Lexi convinced me to select this video for purchase

I'd seen those still photos for so long. Finally glad to see the actual video.

Nor each of the genres portrayed in this anthology video or compilation video, someone will love the style of that genre. And, statistically, many of you are more likely to be broader in your fetishes. I'm a pretty tough critic.

So, I will avoid saying "I don't like this way" simply due to my personal tastes when analytically describing each action.

But I will say what bits I like.

What I know will appeal to everybody: All the shots are well lit, well focussed, obviously much work was put by the actresses & director to make sure no pie or gunge deliveries were accidentally "clipped' or "missed" from the beginning as some of the most amateur stuff I have seen on YouTube happen. never do the actresses accidentally turn away or the shot fail. Now the details:

Segment 1: "Sisters." 9 minutes

Lexi & Nikki start out by slowly humiliatingly giving each other extremely sticky pies in the face.

Love the stick pie quality, total coverage, I love the pause after each pie TO the face! None of that pie a person and then jerk the planet to Pluto like mainstream "comedy" shows, both in the English speaking & Latin worlds often do.

Then Lexi sits on the floor in white bra & panties while getting gunged green by Nikki.

Then Nikki sits on the floor in black bra & panties while getting gunged with chocolate by Lexi.

I love plain nonthong panties & bra like these & chocolate gunge!

Segment 2: "Messygirl Rita" 6 minutes 30 seconds

Rita takes 3 good humiliating pies tossed into her face while dressed, at the beginning.

I love that these same shots are repeated from a second angle, the side, which is an absolute treat,

but double the work for the producer!

Then an off-camera hand dumps thick green gunge all over her head and face. Again, good giving the audience the time they want & paid for. I have to admire the thickness of this green gunge,

and as always: total head & facial coverage.

This is not some cheap kid's show thin transparent green slime.

Then off-camera hand dumps chocolate all over Rita's head.

Then she sits on the floor, massaging the chocolate all over her, still dressed.

Then lovely Rita treats us pie-face fans to a self-pie in the face, rubbing the pie tin vigorously.

Segment 3: "Messing Around" 10 minutes 45 seconds

Liz Ashley and Amber tit-for-tat while clothed pie each other in the face with whipped cream pies, 2 pies each. I love the tit-for-tat style and, again, holding, for each aftermath.

Then they pour pink, then green, gunge, and chocolate down each others' clothing and over each others' heads.

Then they undress to just panties.

Liz pies Amber in the ass & in the face, horsey-style. (Or doggy?)

Then they sit facing each other on the floor,covered in goo, & proceed to do another tit-for-tat 3 pies in the face each.

Very sexy, very humiliating.

Segment 4: "Sticky & Gooey Michelle" 19 minutes

Michelle does a fantastic job of slowly covering herself with sticky marshmallow while she wears a crotchless thin white lingerie that comes off halfway through. Several closeup crotch shots of her covering herself with the white stuff.

And then Michelle pours very sticky chocolate syrup and butterscotch syrup all over her face and body.

The total facial stickiness of syrup appeals to us humiliation fans.

Outtakes & Bloopers: 2 minutes

psg ends with cute outtakes from Segments 1 & 3

For the $10 average price that the 2-for-3 offer gave me, this video was worth it for me. I was able to extract at least a dozen of the slapstick-style pie-in-the-face or thick-chocolate-fudge-gunge-over-the-head scenes and piece them together in a clip for myself. It has given me a way of seeing what next to buy.