Thin and watery? Thick and creamy? Chunky?
I especially like it as the consistancy of paint--thin, but with a nice brown color on the girl it's on.

I can go with thick and creamy or thin and watery..as long it coats the babe all over!!

THICK, creamy and/or goopy. Stuff that you can tell is hard to move around in and sticks to the body/clothes really well. Basically the stuff that Fred588 has been cookin' for years now, with MPV making their own pits that compared just as well.

This right here^^^

What I would do for a mud scene in a skims dress.

I really like the clay pudding consistency MessyGirl outdoor mud pit and Phil's outdoor clay pit. It coats and feels heavy, but not too thick to the point you cant recognize the shape of the model..

Thick and creamy, but not too thick. Somewhere between the consistency of custard, and that of melted cooking chocolate.


Nailed it, thick enough that it's definitely mud, but not so thick it obliterates the details.

See the attached pics for our mud ideal, featuring Violet Vixen and Maude playing in it in PVC, and Lady Jennifer and Miss Abigail playing in it in sportswear. Because they are tidal the Marsh House mudbanks constantly change, every visit is slightly different, it's always great to play in but every now and then we get a consistency that is just absolutely perect, and these were two of those days.

Note how in the first pic, Miss Abigail's leggings are totally coated below her thighs, but you can still make out the detail of the iconic stripes down her legs, the next pic shows her rolling forward into the mud and you can see how it's coating her outstretched arm, and you just know how it's going to engulf her leggings and swimsuit as she rolls her front down into it, and then in the third shot her clothes are totally coated but you can still see her shape, and even the detail of the circular cut-out in the back of her swimsuit, plus you can make out the shape of the waistband of Lady Jennifer's equally mud-drenched leggings, under the coating of mud.

The second set of three shots are of Maude and Violet Vixen, both in PVC catsuits, demonstrating the coating abilities of the mud, no peeling off or leaving clean patches, even on shiny PVC, but also still revealing both girls' shapes clearly.

Out of all the mud scenes we've shot, I think these two are some of our finest work.

These images speak for me

Keke "The Poacher" - heavy and exaggeratedly
Some classic ClubMPV pic - creamy
Zoey - Engulfed - thick, creamy and you can recognize the model body


exaggeratedly

I endorse this message and agree with it fully

I find it really hard to specify a favourite. I enjoy lots of different types of mud!

Of course there is no right or wrong answer, as it's all down to personal preference.

And in fact the same question could be asked about other substances (watery or thick gunge?)

Personally I would say thick and creamy. But not to detract from the curves of the model(s).

It's messy but still showing the beauty of the human form, rather than a big blob of mess.

This of course could be hard to achieve if it a mud pit, so it's then up to the model to show her creativeness.

I guess you could say how much is too much mess, but again that's down to personal preference.

Creamy, and dark. Nice coverage!!

Really anything except that fake gray bentonite "clay." Or "bleck." Potting soil is a tough wank, but I'd even take it over those.

Anything that isn't purely thin and watery is a win for me. I love when it fully coats the body with a sheen, like Violet Vixen's mud scenes that Dungeon Master One shot.

Ball Clay mixed with Kaolin.... Or Tidal silt

Thick and creamy

I like it thick enough to be heavy but thin enough to see body parts clearly. Plus the thicker it is the harder it is to fuck in! And ever inch of depth the more difficult to move in.

Phil

Sticky and gooey enough to coat the body but thin enough so I can appreciate every curve and a lot of her features.

Oh... this

The thicker the better

EDIT: Oops, forgot to credit the pics.
1 - Brooke Maddison
2 - Route 207
3 & 4 - Mud Puddle Visuals

Thick and gloopy every time, like the latest slop Mel had to endure

That is an amazing picture. So thick!

I love thick creamy mud that coats the model's body in a layer of it and hides features and details. I love it when I cannot see a nude model's nipples, vulva, and butthole . I just find it very erotic when a model gets into a position that would expose her privates, but mud is covering her privates.

Always liked the Doronko mud!

Creamy and covering.

They sure are covered!

The real-deal digging in the ground mud like Rob Blaine used.