Here's what Jessie had to say about this scene when it was first released in 2013:
It is now my turn to be the "donkey"... Annabelle is blind-folded and handed pies. She actually does very well, but there is a bit of cheating along the way, on both parts!
Although Annabelle does well, I remove am a little bit cheeky and pie Annabelle while she is still blind-folded! Needless to say, Annabelle swiftly removes her blindfold and pies me back!
We end up having a bit of a pie fight, but it's all good fun!
EnglishGent said: These two were so good together. You could see they were having fun
I loved the fact that even when she was dishing out the pies, Jessie would usually find a way to end up on the receiving end of one herself
Hahahaha I noticed that too. I am not sure whether it was because she thought it would help sales (almost certainly it would have) or because she just preferred getting messy to dishing out mess (which, tho it doesn't mean it's true, she told me on many occasions was the case).
I do lean towards the latter, simply because I wrote many customs for Jessie and in them she would often stay clean, and one time she emailed me and complained that she wasn't getting messy enough in my scripts .
In any event, I am so pleased that you love the scene.