I thought it might be fun to start a list of different substances that are rarely used.
Here are some of mine everyone is welcome to add

1. Apple sauce
2.Yogurt ,one of my favorite pie filling it's messy relatively cheap and to be honest I don't like the taste which adds to the humiliation.

I'll add more as I think of them.

Bird seed I always wanted to try or see someone try to re-create the scene and or look from home alone two.

I used apple sauce on a few xs back but she couldn't get it out of her hair and never tired again on anyone

I've used chocolate tea shavings and a added "feathering" with her sprinkles toward end of seshs


She let me use a tin of grub worms that had gone a month or two past use by date as a very humiliating added fun "feathering"

Dried fish skin "chips" made it into her savory slime I cooked among other old meals added two cheese rind ends to thicken the slime as well


And my favorite frozen cum cumtainor pours

Pumpkin Pie or Pumpkin Puree - I rarely see this being used. I know of a few scenes like from Stella, and can search to find more. But why is it so infrequently used?

Pastry Piping Bags or Decorating Bags - These are used to decorate a cake. Why not use them to decorate a body? I usually seen Reddi Wip or squirty-cream cans being used.

Refried Beans - I know wetandmessy Naomi K got covered in Refried Beans once. Why always whole beans? Why not more refried beans?

Mashed Potatoes - I remember Deja from iwam. Why not use mashed potatoes more? Maybe boxes of instance mix? Or mashed sweet potatoes, mashed carrots, or mashed any vegetable.

Spinach, Green Beans, Avocado, or other green vegetables. I feel like there is potential here to blend these up and add them to a slime to add texture.

Crisco or Vegetable Shortening - There was an OnlyFans creator that used Crisco but this was deleted. I feel like a greasy white substance would be fun to see, right?

I know one problem is that the search only works if the producer puts the words in the descriptions. Sometimes these items may be used with a mix of other items. There are probably more scenes with these which I might be missing.

It feels like the most common items are: gunge, cake batter slime, custard, paint, black grease, mud, whipped cream pies, shaving cream, chocolate, peanut butter, marshmallow fluff, oatmeal, porridge, pudding, yoghurt, honey, jelly, cakes, buttercream frosting, treacle, and trifles. (also savory condiments, cheese, gravy, spaghetti hoops, beans, and salad dressing) (oh and disgusting items, dog food, and simulated messes).

It seems like some items are underutilized though. Maybe due to price or availability? To much of a pain to prep or clean up? Do they have undesirable characteristics? Or maybe no one else likes these items?

Below are various items that were used at some point in my shoots, in no particular order. There are many others I've just forgotten.

Many are effective, some are genuinely not recommended but most obscure items were actually pointless other than to be novel and say we'd used them!

Potting soil
Lard
PVA Glue
Glitter glue
Passata
Pea soup
Hair gel
Festival dyes
Soya mince
Pulped mango
Condensed milk
Acrylic primer undercoat
Used fryer oil
Marmalade
Clotted cream
Banoffee sauce
Poultry seed
Straw/hay
Silly string
Lettuce
Lentils

!

Potting soil
Lard
PVA Glue
Glitter glue
Hair gel
Festival dyes
Acrylic primer undercoat
Used fryer oil
Clotted cream
Poultry seed

Wow that's horrible!!! Can they even leave the house after all that?!

One put two lesser used items - a couple have already been mentioned, but I've also made some comments about them:

- PVA glue. Reading about this it seems to be entirely non toxic and water soluble, so pretty safe to use. I've found it exciting to know I'm covering my wife in glue, it feels particularly "naughty" in hair, but it does actually wash out well. However, it's not actually very sticky - more slimy - and after a while, as it begins to set, it does that "copydex" thing where it just peels off skin with friction, taking any other mess with it and leaving a distressingly clean appearance behind! So possibly more exciting in theory than in practice.

- Wallpaper paste. Having spent a while trying to find one that didn't contain a toxic fungicide this was actually a disappointment. Made her body and clothes look a bit "wet" but was neither particularly sticky nor especially visually exciting. Not worth the effort.

- Yoghurt, passata, ketchup. They sound very different but they're all disappointingly "thin" when applied to skin. They look good initially but rapidly wipe away so you'd barely know they'd been there.

- Mashed potato and gravy. They work well in combination. Both are quite quick and cheap to make in quantity from instant powders. I tend to make them very concentrated with hot water then dilute down to a reasonable temperature with cold. Mashed potato particularly satisfying to work into hair, then gravy soaks into it to make a nice slimy substance.

- Salad dressing. Slippery, but that's about the only good thing to be said about it. We both agreed we'd struggled to get excited with the powerful vinegary smell of it permeating everything!