Just curious to see what the fine folks of UMD like.

I'd have to go with the ThatsUnfairTv video with Teresa. I wish this had been shot more recently now that we have HD video, and I wish she would've stuck around and done more WAM, but this video is easily my favorite ever.

That's easy....A Messy Scandal I absolutely love this video and watched it tons.
Cinq X

It depends on the substance being used.

Pies: it's Anglefan AFL5 - Julie 3. She pies herself a LOT, with some hits you have to see to believe. There is some brownie batter as well (which I love), but the pie hits are amazing. But now that I think about it... there was one Pie Fight Girls video that was amazing -- the star was Tuesday (formerly of Messy Fun) who either pied herself, or had multicolored pies flung at her gorgeous face. That was a fantastic video, too.

Mud: There are a couple that I want to pick up, but of the ones that I have, it's clearly one from Mud Puddle Visuals -- Lena In Bubbling Clay (aka Lena is "Wow!" #4) Her squeals of delight as she submerges... good gracious, it's fantastic.

Slime: There are a lot here. The recent "slime compilation 1" from The Man and The Wife is a great one to go with, as well as "Keke's Repair Job" (from Baba Slimes) and this instant classic from Wambabes -- Ariel's orgasm in Mystery Substance (it's video number 358, if you're wanting to look) Also, there's the "Bad Signs" video from WetAndMessy.com, starring Samantha Grace. (There is another one I'd use from that site, but it's not in video form yet -- only in a photo set)

Those are my choices.

This: https://dl.messygirlvideos.com/cgi/autogal.pl?vidnum=tws-75-0124

This: https://dl.messygirlvideos.com/cgi/autogal.pl?vidnum=tws-75-0679

This: https://umd.net/download_info/dirty-girl-2 & http://houseofslime.com/slime/portfolio/slimecam/

Jazmine bloom was one of my faves, but she only modeled for a short time.

I love the simplicity of this question!!

What makes this slime video stand out from the rest?

Thanks for the shout out man! That comp is stuff she did for me years ago! Our personal stash if you will.

Almost everything from pievids/excessive mess. Messygirl too

Pievids - https://xxxmess.com/cgi/autogal.pl?vidnum=tws-440-0008 Girdle Circle
Messygirl - Messy Bed Play with Liz and Amy
Messyfun - Pie Wedgies

Pie Wedgies and Pievids start everything about the pie fetiche for me.

All-time favorite...that's a tough one. I'm going to do as others have and give a top 3, in no particular order.

The Seabrook Mud Wrestling video from Messy Fun, particularly the section where the 3 ring girls get pulled in in their dresses.

SS27 Sc 3. The slime meets Toshia's strapless bra for the first time.

Gunge Tank Girls 2016, Episode 8. Mia wins, gets pulled into the gunge anyway. I didn't like how Emily got away with running inside the house and hiding to avoid the mess (and standing there laughing at the other 3). IMO, once the host and the contest winner are covered in gunge everyone is fair game at that point and it's just unsporting to deliberately avoid it. So I personally saw to it she didn't, ultimately, get away with it ( https://customwam-store.umd.net/download_info/mia-gets-revenge-on-sweet-emily-in-gunge )

Excess pies and Lisa bonus by Most Wam, its a custom Charlotte did for me!

My favorite is the one that got me into WAM. Of course I was highly influenced by YCDTOTV but this clip back in 2000 reintroduced me to WAM.

https://youtu.be/jhw2EQ_lR9M

I'm going to be biased but it's the custom Charlotte did for me, in which Jess gets ridiculous amounts of mess when auditioning for a presenting role. But that's logical given that I did the script to match up to my tastes as much as I could.

Not counting that one, perhaps a Rhian v Amber custom. The game was rigged against Rhian, and then against Amber, and their reactions are priceless. Especially Amber when she sees a trolley of mess bring brought in. "Is that all for ME?"

Best moment was in a Casey v Emily one, where Casey sees a SECOND trolley of mess for her, gives the camera a forlorn glance, and says "this is a very sad day for me..."

I have like a hundred tied for 2nd place cause I'm a degenerate perv, but 1st place all-time is You Can't Do That On Patreon by MadLoversCosplay; https://mad-lovers-cosplay-slapstick-v.umd.net/download_info/you-cant-do-that-on-patreon

Perfect in every single way (for me at least)

Either the Bratty Bella video from WAMerica or the Messy Masseuse video from PieFightGirls

I'll just say every single pie vid from MostWam.

Either of these two

https://mywam.com/cgi/autogal.pl?vidnum=tws-93-0017

https://www.clips4sale.com/studio/4502/9594487/snobby-sumiko-gets-hers-with-a-face-full-of-pies

Nostalgia is a powerful thing, and this is one of the first wam videos I saw, but I has to be the coloured slime game with Liz from Wambabes.
https://umd.net/download_info/vintage-liz-plays-the-colore
Some things that I think makes this video really great:
- Loads of batter slime and even some pies at the end, great amount of mess. The different colurs and the texture of the slime was great.
- Both girls had great reaction and were having a good time, no one was uncomfortable, Liz was 'humiliated' but laughing and was not upset. Ariel was really enjoying sliming Liz which made the video even better.
- Simple premise, and to the point. I also personally prefer when only one girl get's messy and the other stays clean.
- Fixed camera (!!!)

For me, a little bit of everything.

I think green slime on white clothes always makes for a great visual.
I also really like the slime they used. No idea what their recipe was, but it looked great.
I have a thing for hair and she hers held slime really well.

And probably the biggest thing, IMO, she's very pretty and gives off an air of class. She took the slime really well, considering it was clearly the first time she'd ever done it. You could tell she was probably used to glamour and glitz and getting messy was a new experience for her.

And maybe the fact that she never did more. As far as I know she did this and one pie video and then split, so she still has that 'mystique'. What was that old P. T. Barnum saying, "Always leave them wanting more". She did.

Without a doubt, Messy and Naughty Raven from MessyGirl. I'm obsessed with her (I have a type, and that type is definitely curvy BBWs). I'm not even one for messy clothes, and prefer all mess to happen naked, and yet this one gets me going every time. The way she says "I need a good sliming today", and then massages her tits in the slime does crazy things to me. It's a shame she's no longer doing MG videos, because she stands out.

https://dl.messygirlvideos.com/cgi/autogal.pl?vidnum=tws-75-0133

WTF downloads Heather Tied - includes sweet, savoury, gunge, bondage, blindfold, clothes slipping off, clothes filling & a really cute model.

Deserves to be recreated in my opinion.

Mine is most definitely the custom that Jayce did fit me with Ariel. A chocolate pie fight bake sale. It was spectacular.

That all makes sense. She is gorgeous for sure!

Ok so ignoring Melania and Buck Johnson Pie videos which I can't post publicly, I have two that I love the most, but I just can't decide between them!

1) Phoebe's Pie Sandwich. Just amazing posing beforehand, great anticipation and delivery

2) Anglefan's Bigshipper BS-3. Ok so her hair's wet from the previous sessions but its just a great succession of pushed shaving cream hits taken by a wam legend.

Wish the Splosh videos and all the others from that era had been done in HD.
But on a side note I often wish the picture stills from the clips were in fact the video angle. I just think that that they catch the mess at the better angle. Such as the Redd pie picture, watched it loads of time put don't enjoy that pie scene as much as the picture. Not sure if others understand what I mean.

A custom I got through wamcustoms highly recommended just message Charlotte she is very helpful and gets it done how you imagined it

Yep I get that totally. It's one of the best pie images in WAM history...but it oversells the film a little. This happened an awful lot in the early days of downloads - when a set of high quality (often 35mm film) stills were taken alongside the video. The video often being offered as a 'bonus' to the picture set.

I have to agree with all of this. Just downloaded the video today out of curiosity and wow, what a great sliming! Love the slime consistency too.

My Favorite is the chocolate pudding bath with Liz and Lexi from Messygirl. A classic indeed!

It is so difficult to choose with so many great producers and excellent movies.But for the theme, delivery, the variety of mess both sweet and savoury and the lovely model I would have to say that my all-time favourite is Charlotte filling Mia's Tights from Customwam. Mia gets complete coverage and the mess just goes on and on. It can be found here:

https://customwam-store.umd.net/download_info/i-fill-mias-tights-with-various-foods

If I had to name only one, for me it would probably be Camilla VS The Naughty Cakes, which I mention on my profile page. Just great reactions from a gorgeous girl sitting on gooey cakes.
Many other vids that I love but it was this that sprang to mind.

Two come to mind:
Anglefan's Natalia vol. 73-3.
I watch that one probably more than any other in my collection.
Also from Messy Girl - Vicky take a cream bath starring the legendary London Andrews.
Either of these get me excited just thinking about them.