No particular order on my favorites

Liz
London
New Amy
Lexi
Raven

5. Vika -- Love her willingness to push her limits.
4. Fae -- Her bush was everything, and those gorgeous eyes. Just my type of girl.
3. Zayda/Wednesday: Is it cheating to put the two of them together? They really did incredible things not just individually but in tandem, as did Wednesday did with Gia, who almost made my list.
2. Naomi -- Did a MG BJ video that still remains one of the hottest things I've ever seen. She seemed to have so much fun during the experience, that really made the video.
1. Sara -- One of the first exposures to WAM I ever had. Still the perfect blend of girl-next-door cuteness and realness with a raunchy side underneath.

1. AMY (NEW)
2. JUSTINE
3. VIKA
4. LIZ
5. PENELOPE

1. Leah (the original messy girl)
2. Justine
3. Lexie
4. Amy
5. Sara

1. Liz
2. Lexi
3. New Amy
4. Lane
5. Penelope

This is tough.

1: Cami. A member of the public who wanted to get messy just to find out what's it really like to be messy. As others have mentioned her BJ shoots were amazing. I think the fact that you knew that this was not a case of someone having meaningless sex and instead that of a loving couple being intimate with each other made the videos more enjoyable.

2: New Amy. The camera loves her. She loves the mess. She's gorgeous. And she's blonde.

3: MILF Michelle. For proving that WAM isn't just a young person's game. Her Messy Housewives shoot is a standout.

4: Gia. For her surreal commentary during her first BJ shoot.

5: Zeyda. For her BJ shoot dressed as a Maid. Her "boss" did a brilliant job in smashing those pies in her face.

Thinking about it, the guys in the BJ shoots should have performed cunnilingus. Wouldn't have objected too much if the females had taken revenge.

what about your top 5 "house of mess" girls....lets see....

jayce
jayce
jayce
jayce
jayce

cause i spit hot fire! (anyone who knows, this is a chappelles show reference. lol)

no but really. i dont have a top 5 i dont think but i have some faves.

new amy
penelope
vicky
liz
lane

wait that is 5!!! welp there you have it!!

Not sure that I could even narrow it down to just five.

Sara
Amy (new Amy)
Vika
Penelope

and I can't decide on a fifth because at least Lexi, Liz, and Lane all deserve that spot and probably a few others that I am not thinking of right now.

In alphabetical order:

(new) Amy
Emma
Justine
Lane
Lexi

I can't put together a straight list of 5, but I can't help but add some more support for Jacy. I couldn't believe I didn't see her in more of these lists. Also, I saw one person mention Katie, and yeah, I really liked her too.

Lexi

Then in no specific order:
Penelope
Connie
Emma
Christina

Oh wow! After fifteen years of following your work that's a tough list to make. So, my top five Messygirls (Not in any strict order) are:
* Sara - the first Messygirl I saw, cute, sexy, fun! Her "Saralocks" video is still as funny and sexy as ever.
* Katie - an early local Messygirl beautiful, curvaceous and extremely sexual in mess.
* Vika - I can remember seeing her transition from JustPieMe to Messygirl and then watching her just bloom into the extreme Messygirl she is now.
*Amy 1 - just something girl next door, with a sweet but badass attitude about her. Sexy, funny, and a surprising but really effective top. Especially in her recent scene with Vika in the TittyBar.
* New Amber - as another poster has mentioned there is just something about her. Beautiful, with a sultry voice, and sexy moves.

Close Calls - Allison, Jacy, Alana, Fae

In no special order:
Sara
Liz
Raven
Amber
& Vicky/London

Don't have a top 5.

But my three all time favs are:

1) Liz
2) Amy
3) Messygirl

I have my favorite Messygirls over the years. All of the Messygirls who have done at least 1 shoot on any of MG's platforms are deserving, but I really like Sara, Liz, Hannah Perez, Ms. Bee, Lexi and Messygirl Leah, the original Messygirl

Well, Leah, you are absolute tops on that list. After all, you are THE Messygirl.

Beyond you, I would say Lexi, Liz, Sara, and Linda.

I'm old school.

There have been dozens of fantastic models on your site over the years; Jack has become a new favorite and Wednesday, Zeyda, Liz, Sara, Amber, and Lexi are all excellent. But if I had to pick my five favorite:

5. Michelle - I remember she appeared on some sort of documentary talking about WAM right around the time she started working with Messygirl.

4. Raven - I was a fan of her fun loving attitude, especially during her two girl scenes.

3. Vicky/London Andrews - She was the first model who I ever hired for a custom. I remember finding a picture of London on a cigar fetish forum and emailing Messygirl to ask if she and Vicky were the same person.

2. Messygirl - Leah was one of if not the first pie girl I ever found on the net. One of the first clips I found was only a few seconds long and featured Messygirl looking right into the camera before saying, You know you want to do it, followed immediately by a pie in the face. I couldn't believe that such a perfect clip existed. Thanks, Messygirl.

1. Linda - Still my all time favorite messygirl model. She was fun loving, attractive, took and threw a good pie, and really seemed to enjoy making videos. I don't know if she was ever available for customs; I would have loved to pitch a cigar/pie scene to her. I still enjoy her clips.

Thanks, Messygirl!

I know it was long ago, but do you have any hi-res pictures of Sara? Or maybe typical res of the time but just her clean face? She's quite the model and many of us miss her.

Raven!! And classic Amber! They're the stand outs for me.

1) Vicky
2) Vicky
3) Vicky
4) Vicky
5) Vicky

Wait, what?...

In no particular order

Vicky
New Amy
Vika
Penelope
Lexi

You know we've being listing our favourite Messygirls, however I think we ought to turn the tables on *BOTH* MG and Mr MG and ask them who their top 5 Messygirls are.

New Amy
Sara
Lexi
Liz
Lane

Sara
Liz
Lane
Hannah
New Amy

I honestly came up with this list without seeing MG's own list immediately above, but it looks like we have 4 out of 5 choices in common.

Also want to note that Mrs. Bee would've made my top 5 for sure, but I can't really think of her as a Messygirl, despite her affiliation. She's more of a unique force of nature unto herself.

I'm telling Vika, Alana, and Penelope about this.

1. Lane - I've never had anyone as difficult and fun to work with than her.
2. New Amy - IMHO the most complete WAM model in the biz.
3. Lexi - What you saw on camera was who she was behind the camera.
4. Penelope - I have a personal closeness with her like no other model.
5. Vika - If we asked her to hang upside down and get pied, she would do it.

mr_MG; that last one... we dare you lol

Please please PLEASE tell us some stories about working with Lane!!! Was she difficult on some shoots and loads of laughs on others, or were the fun and frustration always there simultaneously, like a swirly cone of pleasure and pain?!?

DYLAN
DYLAN
DYLAN
DYLAN
DYLAN


I was literally looking through the comments to see if anyone had said this. You beat me to it Jayce!

But, since I'm here..

5. Raven
4. Vicky
3. Lexi
2. New Amy
1. Jasmine Mendez

Not Leah?!

SAVAGE.