So I took the time to add up all the votes everyone cast for all the different models and below you will find a list of the "top ten" most popular ones. (Which is really a top sixteen, because there was an 8-way tie for ninth place.)

#1
Toshia (8.5)

#2
Breana (7)

#3
Crystal (5.5)
Ginger (5.5)
Taylor (5.5)

#6
Deanna (4)
Shelley (4)

#8
Jill (3.5)

#9
Abby (3)
Brin (3)
Carrie (3)
Erin (3)
Jen (3)
Lyndsay (3)
Mya (3)
Scarlett (3)

~~~~~~~~~~
A couple of procedural notes for anyone who cares (probably nobody!):

Each post was given up to five points, one point per model. If the post only mentioned one or two models, each of those models got one point. People's "honorable mention" or "near-miss" models were not counted as votes.

In the case of ties for various places, I have listed the models in alphabetical order.

If you're wondering how a number of these models got half votes, it's down to a couple people splitting votes between two models, but mostly it's the result of UMD member PMG casting 10 total votes back on page 1 -- 5 for older models and 5 more for newer ones. The only fair way to deal with this, I felt, was to give half a vote to each of the 10 models.

I appreciate the effort that went into this.

Interesting that Deana has the 3rd best selling SS scene of all time, and Toshia has the second.... But the model who stars in the all time biggest seller wasn't mentioned once! (Also, she was a one-and-done....)

And in the HD era, Carrie and Breana appear in some of the biggest sellers, but always with another model.... While the woman who has the two best-selling clips always shot solo, and juuuust missed the tie for 9th place.

I was going to guess Tracy of SS99, but she did get a single vote back on page 1, so can't be her.



Methinks this must be Kylie, who I believe secured one of those two honors with your first-ever topless scene?

I think the biggest-seller may be Kara and Shannon from vol. 42...

Correct! The slingshot scene from SS137 with a few slips, and then the topless scene a few months later.

DING DING DING!

Rich, do you mind saying what the second (Toshia) and third (Deanna) best selling scenes of all time were?

Inquiring minds want to know!!!

#1 is definitely Julie

No argument about Tracy getting away.... Just bad timing, right after we shot that her idiot husband cheated on her, and the divorce must've been tough because soon after she deleted ALL her social media. And she was a big-time model too. You can find pics of her up through 2010 or so but basically nothing after.

But yeah, she was ready to do LOTS more messy scenes. Shame.

So the 3rd best selling scene of all time is Deana & Casey in our first-ever two-girl scene, from SS14!
https://slapstickstuff.com/SS14.htm

Side note: Deana is also in the 4th best selling scene, which is the slime clip from that same volume, AND the 5th best selling scene, which is her solo slime-centric one from SS25. Deana is like the Pink Floyd of WAM models. She keeps selling every year!
https://slapstickstuff.com/SS25.htm

And Toshia's best-selling scene, and our 2nd biggest seller ever, is (to no one's surprise) SS27... AKA "Never Wear A Tube Top To A Slime Scene."
https://slapstickstuff.com/SS27.htm

Any worthwhile story as to why Crystal didn't come back? I'm surprised she has as many fans as she does here...I was worried I was the only one! She didn't seem "into" the mess per se but I felt like she was totally not bothered by the whole thing. And I said this before in this thread but she really knew how to clover herself with the self pies.