As I do at least a dozen or so pies per session, I find the cheaper sensitive skin shaving cream is better for me. That and I don't like any type of whipped cream.
Shaving Cream is what I've always used, and I've found it works for me.
VictoriaK said: Now if you just knew someone to experiment and tweak ideas for both you could have a lab inspired scientific research for all your pie query needs.......
I cackled at this!! Glad to have you back, have I told you that lately?
WAMOptimist93 said: As more of a visual wammer (my pleasure derives more from seeing others wam than doing it myself), I think I actually prefer the look shaving cream gives you when you plant the pie onto your face! I'm thinking of the extra spicy Milf scene that used to be up here where you're sitting on the floor. When you pied yourself in the face, it pretty much covered everything, and all that was visible was your mouth opening. That along with your very apparent arousal did a number on me. That video has been replayed and enjoyed many times since I bought it.
Wait-that was cool whip only! I don't use shaving cream often bc I am a cool whip gal, but the few times I have, I forget all about the encasing which you are absolutely right-brings a complete different appeal! Haha I did remove that scene for a bit-maybe it's time to bring back? It's still up on OF!
trt23 said: id like to some pics where a coolwhip based pie(not bakery pies) were used and the coverage was good.
Surprise there was no mention on the temperature the coolwhip was used etc..
Hah! Now that is a great point! Mine are so freaking cold, adds to the sensation, but I believe the reason no one said anything about bad coverage is bc cool whip pies are what brought me to wam a million moons ago and *tooting* my own horn-I have good coverage
SlapstickStuff said: Six or seven years ago, I had people on this forum straight up tell me, "Oh man! That girl is beautiful! And you hit her with 14 pies, right? But the last couple at the end were shaving cream? Sorry, no sale!"
I (jokingly?) offered to edit out the last couple minutes myself for one guy, just so his perfect scene wouldn't be "spoiled" by shaving cream at the end. Still no sale.
And that's the main difference: SC fans are usually OK with some Cool Whip mixed in, but the Cool Whip crowd generally HATES SC and considers it a deal-breaker. Plus the models absolutely hate it, and the new Barbasol formula burns the eyes, so I don't even bother anymore. It also looks super fake as camera/picture quality improves.
As usual, Rich FTW!!! Spot on assessment. On a somewhat related aside, I'd think the models prefer Cool Whip for the pieces that inevitably seep into their mouths. On the lone time my wife let me clobber her with pies, the single redeeming quality of the experience for her was that at least the pies tasted good.
And I almost forgot... Bratty, you're GORGEOUS! Thanks for your contributions!!!
Brattyshortcakes said: What are your thoughts? *bonus points if you guess which pie is filled with what below!*
The pie dress picture is a lovely shaving cream pie and the yellow shorts pic has some cool whip. I hope both went to your face and my bonus points are something similar !
I personally love shaving cream because of how much mess I can make in a really quick time at a low cost and clean up super easily. The obvious downsides are that you can't eat it and that it can sting or irritate your body, but since I don't take those pies on a super regular basis it isn't the biggest deal. I also love how many ways you can manipulate shaving cream with different colors and consistencies and just how it looks when it piles up on a face!
That being said, pies are pies and I will gladly take them all!
This is a great thread! I love the feedback that everyone has for what they use. For a long time I've been using shaving cream only (due to its great coverage and cost performance), but recently started trying out other kinds of cream fillings, and also with and without crust. I loved the results of using cool whip and heavy whipping cream, so it'll be fun to try out the other variations mentioned here. Recently I also tried out real pies, which were yummy, also tried out non-dairy whipped topping which I think I whipped up too stiff, so might try it out again a bit softer next time. I've been leaning toward using edible creams and real pies these days, but they do take some time to clean up (especially with the not-so-good water pressure where I am), while cleanup of shaving cream is of course a breeze.
Cool whip or heavy cream for me is looking at videos / pictures Wife hates smell from heavy cream so we switched to cool whip but she also hates taste if it lolz. Add cake icing for flavor and to thicken it up some but can't quite get the mixture to be thick enough to splatter and cover her vs being too runny or to hard and hurts / doesn't stick at all
It in my youth did enjoy shaving cream fights at the pool will one day got a little bit in my hole and was like NOPE !!! That shit burns to much!
SlapstickStuff said: Six or seven years ago, I had people on this forum straight up tell me, "Oh man! That girl is beautiful! And you hit her with 14 pies, right? But the last couple at the end were shaving cream? Sorry, no sale!"
I (jokingly?) offered to edit out the last couple minutes myself for one guy, just so his perfect scene wouldn't be "spoiled" by shaving cream at the end. Still no sale.
And that's the main difference: SC fans are usually OK with some Cool Whip mixed in, but the Cool Whip crowd generally HATES SC and considers it a deal-breaker. Plus the models absolutely hate it, and the new Barbasol formula burns the eyes, so I don't even bother anymore. It also looks super fake as camera/picture quality improves.
As usual, Rich FTW!!! Spot on assessment. On a somewhat related aside, I'd think the models prefer Cool Whip for the pieces that inevitably seep into their mouths. On the lone time my wife let me clobber her with pies, the single redeeming quality of the experience for her was that at least the pies tasted good.
And I almost forgot... Bratty, you're GORGEOUS! Thanks for your contributions!!!
Ooooo now this post is one I will always endorse! Thank you for your support!!!
VictoriaK said: Now if you just knew someone to experiment and tweak ideas for both you could have a lab inspired scientific research for all your pie query needs.......
Sure you would be a suitable target for experimentation. Would love to see the results!
Sweet Messy Tanya said: As I do at least a dozen or so pies per session, I find the cheaper sensitive skin shaving cream is better for me. That and I don't like any type of whipped cream.
Shaving Cream is what I've always used, and I've found it works for me.
To each their own.
Not a shaving cream afisheeuhnahdo lol.... but I think you have great pics.
Slapdash WAM said: If you won't buy something because they're not "Whipped Cream" pies- You're part of the problem, quite clearly. It's not like whipped cream is as inexpensive or as useful as shaving cream. Especially if it's both types of pies being used- Chances are they're looking for any reason not to buy something.
Would they really say that "As long as they're whipped cream they're the best" and still feel the same way if every pie had it's whipped cream melt and they're basically getting hit with plates of cream that looks like soup.
I feel like if it's really that important to you, you're getting the fetish wrong or at least are not very good at having one.
Besides, since I actively act upon the fetish, it's especially hard to take someone's inherently flawed prefence seriously or even care- If they've barely done anything messy or haven't contributed any content.