We thought Hannah Graeme from Messyworld fame looked a lot like one of our regular studio visitors, Ivy Rain. When we had the option of working with them both, it left us with a delicious dilemma: two perfect candidates for gunging, one chair, and a whole lot of orange slime waiting for us to make a decision.

We couldn't choose--so we handed the call to the audience at home.

Watch as our two contestants plead their cases to stay clean and send the other to the chair. They argue, they laugh, they plead; every plea adds a little more tension, and the anticipation for that splash of orange builds The studio (and the viewers) watch on, guessing who will dodge disaster and who will end up dripping in goo.

It was a truly unique matchup Hannah and Ivy side by side, the similarities uncanny yet the rivalry fierce. Each tried to prove why they should be spared, while the other deserved the slime. With every grin and every glance, the audience was left wondering: could we really tell them apart when the slime started pouring?

But who ended up covered in all that orange slime?

You'll have to watch (or check the spoilers below) to find out.