(Continued from Katy's Story- Chapter 7...)

Brian had finally been able to get home before 9pm for the first time all week and even though he was tired he missed hanging out with Katy. It was Friday, he had the whole weekend to recover so why not surprise her?
As he pulled up to her driveway, he gave her a call.
"Hey!"
"Hi!" Katy answered.
"Whatcha doing?"
"Nothing much. Just hanging out."
"What would you say if I told you I was here and wanted to see you?"
"I'd be very surprised. But I'd love to see you too...just...give me a minute..."
"Am I interrupting anything?"
"No, just give me a minute. I'm...I'm in the bathroom..."
"Oh, sorry. I'll be at the door."
................................
"What are you going to do?" Elizabeth asked from the tub filled with chocolate sauce.
"I've got to let him in. Just stay here, don't make a bunch of noise. I'll ask him if we can go to his place. Then you can get cleaned up whenever you want."
"Don't let him come down here."
"I'll slide this drop cloth around just in case."
................................
Brian patiently waited outside Katy's front door. He was a little anxious because of the surprise he had planned....
Katy opened up the door. She was wearing an old sweatshirt with the sleeves pulled up and some yoga pants. Her hair was a little disheveled, but she still looked great. Brian had to take a second to remember that this girl was wanting to be with him.
"Hi Brian! This is a surpr-"
At that moment Brian pulled a pie from behind his back and slammed it into Katy's face as she spoke. The pie covered her face and went into her hair, with the splatter hitting the doorway behind her as well as down the entryway inside the house. He let the pie just slide down onto her sweatshirt.
"I've really missed you. So I thought I'd surprise you."
"I was not expecting that." Katy said as she wiped the lemon cream from her eyes.
"How does it taste? I'm not used to buying cream pies."
"It's actually pretty good."
"I'm glad because I also bought these...". Brian said as he reached around the corner and showed Katy two large sacks with another 6 pies.
"Wow. That's another surprise."
"Shall we head downstairs?"
Maybe it was the wine she had been drinking, or maybe it was the fact that Brian had really turned her on in that moment, but she wanted nothing more than for Brian to cover her with pie and fuck her.
"I'd like nothing more." Then Katy remembered that her sister was naked in a tub of chocolate. "Come on in."
They walked inside and as Katy held the door open for Brian and the pies he had bought, she reached over and kissed him on the cheek, leaving a smear of lemon cream on his face. As she did so, Brian wrapped his arm around her.
When she pulled back away, Brian looked down at his arm, which now had a smear of chocolate on it. "Chocolate? Where did this come from? What have you been doing tonight?"
Katy realized that she had never cleaned off her sweatshirt from when they had dropped Elizabeth into the tub. "Uh, just having some fun by myself tonight. I didn't think you'd be able to come over."
"Do you have anymore of that?"
"I think I used it all."
"Let's go see." Brian replied and walked straight down the stairs.
.........................
Elizabeth just laid back into the chocolate. She did not want Brian to see her like this. She tried to listen to what was happening but she was too far away to hear. The moment with the dildo had passed, now she just wanted to get out.
She heard the door to the basement open and was hoping to see Katy's figure coming down the stairs through the drop cloth.
It was not Katy's figure. She slid down deeper into the chocolate, just leaving enough space for her to breathe through her nose, with nearly all of her head and all of her entire body submerged.
..........................
Brian carried down the bags of pies, emptied his pockets onto the small table by the stairs, and started to unload the pies onto the table by the platform.
Katy followed nervously, trying to see if Elizabeth was visible through the drop cloth that was hanging between the platform and the tub.
"I'm going to attempt one of your games this evening." Brian said as he laid the last of the pies out on the table.
"What game is that?"
"I'm going to ask you some questions. If I think you're not telling the truth I'm going to pie you. If we determine that you are telling the truth you can pie me back. If you tell the truth and we agree it's the truth, we both take an item of clothing off."
"I'm not sure you understand how games work..."
"Get over here and answer the questions."
Katy walked over to the platform, all the while trying not to look over at where Elizabeth was hiding.
..............
Elizabeth was now realizing she was going to be here for a while...she lifted her head out of the tub and rested her head against the back of the tub. Hopefully, no one could see her but there's was nothing she could do about it now...
................
"First question, did you get messy with another person tonight?"
Katy waited for a moment trying to build a story. "Yes."
"Ok, I believe you. Take off some of your clothes."
"What about you?"
"I will too."
Katy pulled off her sweatshirt, revealing the fact that she wasn't wearing a bra underneath it. Brian took off the t-shirt he was wearing, also revealing he wasn't wearing a bra.
"Next question, who was the first person you said you were first in a messy video with?"
"An old friend."
"Who goes by the name?"
"Carolyn."
Brian took one of the pies and slammed it into Katy's face, letting the pie drop slowly onto her exposed chest. "That's a lie. Care to try again?"
"It was an old boyfriend named Dave."
Brian picked up another pie and slammed it into her face, pushing the pie up and over her head, smearing it through her blonde hair. "Another lie."
Katy was running out of answers but with her sister literally in the room, she didn't want to be the one that gave her up. "Ok, it was one of my old girlfriends, Michaela."
And Brian delivered another pie, this one right to her chest. "I'm not sure why you're lying to me. I spent some time looking you up on that website. You have a lot of very hot videos. Let me skip to another question for a second. Have you watched the video that you made when you got me messy for the first time and did you enjoy it?"
Katy was glad to change the subject. "I've watched it three times and it turns me I every time I watch it."
"I'm glad to hear that. At some point I'd like a copy of that as well...let's remove some more clothing."
Katy pulled off her yoga pants, revealing her pink, thong underwear. Brian took off his jeans to reveal a pair of black boxers.
"That's nice." Katy said.
"I would say the same to you." Brian replied. "So, back to my other question...who was in that first messy video with you? I will tell you that through the link you sent me I was able to see all the videos you've posted on that website."
Katy was silent. The room was silent. She really didn't know what to do.
Out of nowhere, Elizabeth yelled out, "Dammit it was me!"
Both Brian and Katy jumped as Elizabeth pulled back the drop cloth from the ceiling and walked towards them, coated in chocolate, completely naked.
Before Brian could get a word out, Elizabeth continued, "If I ever hear one word from you to anyone outside these four walls you will be fired so fast and you will never work in this town again. Got it?"
"Yes ma'am."
"Now I know I interrupted your fun so, Katy, let's try the log drop to get you guys back into it while I get my drunk ass cleaned up."
Katy looked at her sister and smiled, glad that her sister was willing to play along even if Brian was involved. Katy grabbed one of the two remaining pies, while Elizabeth grabbed the other. Brian backed up a bit, not sure of what the "log drop" plan's meaning for him was?
Suddenly, Brian's head was sandwiched between the two pies delivered by the sisters and as he started to react to the mess, Elizabeth had wrapped her arms around his knees and Katy had grabbed his arms and somehow they managed to knock his balance off enough where he was being carried, or really swung by his legs and arms.
They were a little unsteady in carrying him but slowly they made progress towards their intended destination, the tub of chocolate sauce. It took their maximum effort to swing him up and over the edge of the tub and into the chocolate.
Brian was immediately submerged fully into the chocolate. It was an odd sensation but not one that he minded. As he tried to right himself and sit up in the tub, something was pressing against the back of his leg on the bottom of the tub. He reached down and pulled out a large chocolate covered dildo. "Is this yours?" He asked handing it to Elizabeth.
Elizabeth took it without comment and headed towards the shower. As Brian watched the person who was basically his boss walk to the shower, naked, covered in chocolate, he began to notice how sexy Elizabeth really was. He had never looked at her in that sense before.
His thoughts were interrupted by Katy jumping into the tub with him, sending chocolate sauce in all directions. She submerged herself into the sauce and while down in the chocolate, removed Brian's boxers. When she came back up, she slid onto Brian's erect cock and rode him hard.
Afterwards, Katy sat back at the opposite end of the tub from Brian and let herself slide down, submerging her head in the chocolate. She loved the feeling of being submerged in chocolate. She needed to remember this for a future video.
Out of the shadows walked Elizabeth, now clean, wearing just a towel around her body, with her wet hair coming down over her shoulders. "I owe you an apology." She said directly to Brian, who was just trying to process how amazing his boss looked.
"I'm a little drunk and there was no need to be mean to you. It's not your fault. If you're going to be in my sister's life, you're going to know more about me. And I'm coming to terms with that. We can talk about it in this house, but you have to understand that my career is the most important thing in my life right now and I can't have anything jeopardize that. Is that fair?"
"That's fair. I'm not going to say a word." Brian replied. He was definitely going to think about it though. There were all sorts of thoughts and fantasies running through his mind.
"You look good in chocolate by the way. And Katy, it's weird seeing a guy down here again." With that, she walked up the stairs, letting her towel drop at the base of the stairs. Brian couldn't take his eyes off of her.
Brian was awoken from his stupor when Katy pulled his legs and dunked him under the chocolate. "Not sure how I feel about you staring at my sister?"
"It's just weird to see my boss like that, that's all." It was definitely more than that, but that's all Katy needed to know.