"Well you've broken your pie fight cherry now Mindy!" Erica said as she high fived Mindy.

"Mindy go over there in the corner and grab that sheet cake! I want Charlie to 'Taste Test It' next!" Ally yelled as she almost tripped in her heels laughing, which would have been a disaster since she would've fallen face first onto one of the tables filled with pies and cakes.

"So this is what you guys do? You take the hottest guy in school and make him look like a chump?! I love it!" Mindy exclaimed and began laughing again as she walked over to pick up the massive sheet cake.


That was it for Charlie.It was time to turn the tables on the girls, in a big way.
"You know ladies, these pies and cakes are absolutely amazing! They all taste so good! SO good in fact that I am having a really hard time picking my favorite." Charlie said as he walked over to the table next to Erica and picked up a thick cream pie that had a light drizzle of chocolate syrup on it.
"See here I have one of Erica's famous chocolate cream pies that just has the most delicious pudding filling ever.wouldn't you agree Erica?" Charlie said as held grabbed the back of Erica's head and slammed the pie hard into Erica's face. The muffled 'WOMPF' the pie made as it connected with Erica's face made Mindy jump a little and almost drop the massive sheet cake she was carrying. Erica just stood there completely stunned, Charlie had never hit her that hard with a pie and the sudden and unexpected force of the pie hit made Erica weak in the knees. She simply stood there with the pie smushed into her face, totally blinded.
Ally watched in wide eyed shock as Charlie slowly walked over to her table while he wiped pie chunks from his face from the earlier onslaught.
"And your pies Ally, WOW, so sweet and full. So much cream and filling in yours!" Charlie exclaimed as he picked up an overflowing cream pie. This one appeared to have a bulls-eye drawn on it with strawberry cake frosting.
"Stop right there Charlie!" Ally stated with a stern look. "This was my idea and if anyone is dishing out pies it's going to be me!".

Charlie stopped and nodded and did something that shocked Ally, he handed her the pie. Ally looked down at the pie then back up at Charlie then back down at the pie. A naughty grin crept across her face as she steadied the pie with both hands contemplating on how to deliver the pie to Charlie. She decided on getting revenge for poor Erica who still had a mound of pie smushed into her face behind Charlie, and slam this massive pie she held into his face. Something suddenly hit her though that she didn't take notice until that momentCharlie still had his mischievous grin on his face. Ally only had a second to realize what was happening before Charlie quickly placed his hand under the pie she was holding and push up on the back of her le hands so she was forced to self-pie herself. Again it was dished out hard, Ally stood there holding the pie in her own face out of total embarrassment at how Charlie had gotten the upper hand.
This left poor Mindy standing in between Erica blinded by a pie smashed so hard into her face that the pie tin was bent around her head and Ally who was holding a pie firmly into her own face. Mindy frozen in place was holding a massive white and blue sheet cake that looked as if it had easily 2 extra inches of frosting on top of it. Charlie walked slowly up to Mindy, who was breathing quite heavily now, and simply reached behind her head and pulled her close to him and gave her a deep long passionate kiss. When he released her she nearly collapsed, she was completely blindsided by that and had fantasized about kissing Charlie for 2 years but never thought she had the chance to!
"Wow, Charlie, that was.." Was as far as Mindy got before she felt Charlie's hand under hers and him forcing the massive sheet cake into her face. She tried to scream but frosting invaded her mouth and her world went dark and quiet. Charlie had pushed the cake deep into Mindy's cute little face then wrapped the sides of the cake, since it was just long enough, around her head which basically incased her head in cake and frosting.
Charlie stepped back and admired his work for a quick second. Standing in front of him were three smoking hot girls all with their faces smushed into cream and frosting. Ally and Erica both at the same time cleared their eyes and looked over with slightly sheepish looks on their faces.

"You both have been very bad and I still think you need punishing. The punishment has to fit the crime to be fair, and this is only fair." Charlie said, then turned around and picked up a massive banana cream pie from the closest table.
He then walked over to Erica, who was standing next to poor Mindy whose face was still incased in cake, (which she was holding in place), a pie in one hand and a sexy grin on his face. Erica could hardly control herself, she had no idea what he was going to do next and that's what made her the most nervous and turned on.
Charlie came up real close to Erica's ear and whispered "Assume the position". Erica could not wait to comply. She quickly turned around and faced one of the pie filled tables and bent over with alarming speed and force smashing her own face into a deep thick layered chocolate cake. Next she reached back and flipped up her French maid skirt and yanked down her thong. Charlie then turned and locked eyes with Ally and blew her a kiss. At that exact moment he spanked Erica's exposed ass with the massive cream pie and rubbed it in slowly. Ally watched the scene unfold and slowly crept her hands down between her own legs and began to massage herself, biting her lip ever so lightly wait for her turn.
Charlie rearmed himself and slowly walked over to Ally. Ally then shocked Charlie by snatching the pie he held and turning around only to place it on the table she was facing and promptly slam her own face into the pie. Charlie laughed and picked up another chocolate cream and slammed it into Ally's ass giving her the same treatment that Erica received.
Now it was time to turn his attention back to poor Mindy whose face was still engulfed in the massive cake which she held in place. Charlie slowly lowered her hands as she gasped for breath briefly. Mindy looked up at Charlie with innocent confusion.
"Butbut" Mindy stammered
"Shhh" Charlie said as he put his finger to her cake covered mouth to quiet her.
Charlie then handed Mindy an overflowing banana cream pie and hooked his thumbs around her panties and pulled them to the floor. Mindy was shocked but did not seem to resist.
"What's the pie for?" Mindy asked as she batted her eye lashes at Charlie.
"Oh it's a tradition Ally started the first time weexperimented with baked goods." He said with a smirk, and with that he lowered himself so that his face was eye level with Mindy's deliciously shaved pussy and buried his tongue inside her.
Mindy let a gasp of shock but then quickly turned into moans of ecstasy. Charlie darted his tongue back and forth across her sweet clit as her breathing became quicker and more urgent. Meanwhile Ally and Erica COMPLETEY oblivious of what was taking place only mere feet between them each had their faces buried in their own cream pies and fingering themselves furiously. The combination of Charlie's amazing talents, and the fear of being found out by Ally and Erica was enough to bring Mindy to a climax quickly and forcefully. Charlie was timing it perfectly, right as Mindy's thighs gripped his face and her breathing stopped momentarily she began to yell out "I'm Cum.." that's as far as she got when Charlie quickly reached up with one hand and pulled on the neck of her maids outfit and at the same time pressing up on Mindy's hands causing her face to jerk down towards the pie and her hand rush the pie up to meet her face. The result was Mindy smashing the pie into her own face so hard that it seemed to multiply the intensity of her orgasm 3 fold and she screamed into the thick creaming filling of the pie.
Charlie felt her juices flow over his face as he stood up and sat back down in the chair in front of Mindy. He sat there waiting for the rest of his scheme to unfold. Mindy dropped the pie away from her face, spit out a large mound of pie frosting and filling and wipe her eyes clear as she breathed heavily. She then took several quick steps towards Charlie, grabbed him by the face with both hands, and proceed to kiss him passionately for make her cum harder and better than she had in her whole life. Mindy kissed him all over his face and was making out with him when she slowly began to realize somethinghe wasn't kissing her back. Mindy let go of Charlie's face and took a small step back looking at him to see what was going on. Charlie had both hands up and an evil smirk on his face, then ever so slightly his eyes darted from left to right.
"Oh no!" Mindy sighed right before Ally and Erica sandwiched her head between two huge pink frosting covered cakes.
"What the fuck do you think you are doing!?" Ally shouted as she rubbed in the cake.
"Charlie is ours! Not yours to play with! That was not part of the deal" Erica exclaimed as she too took pleasure in rubbing in the cake into Mindy's destroyed head.
Both Ally and Erica turned to their tables to pick up a huge cream pie each, Charlie took this opportunity to unzip his pants and pull out his rock hard member and slowly begin to stroke it as the fun unfolded. Ally placed a hand on Mindy's shoulder and spun her around to face her.
"How long have you been wanting to steal my man?!" Ally yelled as she hit Mindy directly in the face with the massive pie and twisted it in for good measure. At the same time Erica had hit the back of Mindy's head with an equally huge cream pie and gave the pie a good twist as well.
Both girls picked up another pie each. This time Erica swung Mindy around and gave her a full in the face pie and made sure to push the pie tin up and over Mindy's head while Ally rubbed another pie into her hair.
Charlie was really enjoying himself at this point. Watching the girls actual pie someone out of anger was such a huge turn on. His member was sitting there hard as a rock while Charlie waited his time for when to best jump in and get himself satisfied. At that moment Mindy, whose face was completely unrecognizable under mounds of pie filling, cake, and cream turned towards Charlie blindly. Ally and Erica were armed again ready to give poor sweet Mindy another massive pie sandwich when she suddenly went limp at the waist exhausted and fell forward perfectly so her mouth fell right onto Charlie's hard dick. At the same time Ally and Erica went in for the sandwich, missed, and clobbered each other straight in their faces.
Ally and Erica blindly rubbed their pies in the other one's face while Charlie had a look of shock on his face while Mindy's mouth quickly tightened around his shaft. Mindy slowly tightened and relaxed her jaw muscles while running her tongue around his dick. Charlie could barely contain himself when Ally and Erica both cleared their faces to see how things had gone so wrong. This is when they noticed Mindy with Charlie's dick in her mouth.
Charlie looked between Ally and Erica quickly and realized he was in trouble

Part 6 to come soon!