Home Coming Bake off part 2

Ally picked up the heaping large cream pie with some effort and turned to face Charlie.

"So you like to be smothered huh? Well let me show you how I smother!" Ally yelled and before Charlie could say a word Ally had launched the cream pie directly towards his face. Lucky for Charlie he had the reflexes and agility of a young high school quarter back and deftly ducked out of the way of the oncoming creamy confection. Unfortunately though Erica had moved behind Charlie to get away from Ally's wrath and thus put her sweet round face directly in the path of the oncoming pie. All Erica had time to do was close her eyes the split second before the pie exploded into her face. Charlie slowly stood up realizing that Erica had just been on the receiving end of the pie that was meant for him.

"Oh my god! I'm so sorry Erica" Charlie cried out.

Charlie began to wipe some of the pie off of Erica's stunned face while Erica just stood there with her arms at her sides, she was beginning to get used to having pies shoved in her face tonight.
Ally enraged at her miss reached over and selected another massive cream pie; this one was chocolate cream and overflowing with fluffy topping. Charlie didn't notice Ally's reloading of sticky ammo but when Ally tapped Charlie on the shoulder and he turned around she again launched the pie towards Charlie's face, this time being close enough to shove it hard with her hand behind it. Charlie again ducked out of the way and let poor Erica take his punishment. Ally struck Erica's face hard and Erica had no warning since her face was still partially covered from the last mistaken missile. Erica's head rocked back as Ally shoved the pie up and over her head.

"Stop moving around and stand still! " Ally yelled at Charlie.

"What did I do to piss you off so bad?! And will you stop trying to hit me with pies?!" Charlie exclaimed as he looked into Ally's furious eyes.

Then all of a sudden Ally's eye softened to an evil mischievous glare. "Alright Charlie, I'll stop trying to hit you with pies. Here" Ally handed Charlie a rather large and round banana cream pie "I want you to hit yourself with that pie." Charlie looked back at Ally surprised.

"What if I don't?" Charlie asked uncertainly.

"Then you won't get laid for a year." Ally said coldly and just stood there with her arms crossed in front of her.

Now Charlie was faced with quite the dilemma, Smash this massive pie into his face, humiliating himself in front of his girlfriend and his ex? Or risk not getting any action for a very long time, he was in high school and that kind of thing was pretty damn important. The power that woman have over men at that age is just too much! Charlie looks from Ally to the pie then back to Ally as she just stands there with her arms crossed waiting impatiently. Mean while Erica had regained her sight and walked over next to Charlie.

"You don't have to do that Charlie, don't let her boss you around, she's not worth it Charlie pie!" Erica cried but she could tell that Charlie had already made up his mind.

Holding the pie with both hands in front of him at waist level he prepared to smash this creamy sticky pie into his face with enough force to satisfy his already pissed off girl friend and hopefully not incur anymore of her wrath.
Erica stood there helpless watching Charlie about to lower himself to Ally's knees. He was actually a really nice guy and she had really fucked up in losing him. Even still today he tried helping her wipe the pie off her face when she had accidentally taken the pie that was meant for him and then she could tell that he was really sorry about seeing her hit in the face with it. She had to do something.
At that moment Charlie brought the pie up quickly and with force into his own face but as he rushed the pie towards himself Erica quickly bent over and placed her own face in the oncoming path of the huge pie Charlie was holding. Charlie not expecting Erica's facial sacrifice didn't react fast enough and thus continued to bring the pie up with plenty of force into Erica's face. Erica took the blow like a champ, bent at the waist with a pie stuffed into her already destroyed face. Charlie stopped the forward momentum of the pie as soon as he could but the force of Erica smashing her face into the pie continued for a moment after squishing the pie deeply into her beautiful features. Erica remained face down in the pie for several seconds since this also had become a position that she had grown used to over the evening's events. Charlie just stood there stunned that Erica would make that kind of sacrifice for him. In the silence though Charlie sensed something that startled him more than seeing his girlfriend and his recent ex having an all out pie battle, he was seriously turned on! Was it the position of Erica's body, face down ass up, that turned him on so much? Was it the fact that Erica's cute round little face was totally smothered in cream right now turning him on? Or was it the fact that he had just delivered total humiliation to this girl who had really made a fool out of him by cheating on him? Whatever it was Charlie loved it, and he wanted more. The silence was immediately broken.

"Are you fucking kidding me?!" Ally yelled, she couldn't believe what she was seeing.

How hard was it to smash a pie into her Boyfriends face for something he didn't really do?! Erica bolted up right and wiped the pie away from her face, then marched over to the closest table of pies and cakes. She was pissed. She picked up two cream pies then marched over to Ally with a seriously scowl on her face. The first pie was slammed into Ally's clean ass and then smeared around. Pie squished between Ally's legs and ass crack as Erica rubbed the pie in. This caused Ally to lose her balance in all the slippery pie filling that coated the floor and made her feet fly out from under her and she landed in the sweet muck with a satisfying *SMACK*. Ally sat there for moment with a sad pouty look on her face as Erica prepared to deliver the next attack. Charlie watching this began to feel his heart rate begin to jump. He wanted to see Ally get hit so badly with that pie he almost yelled it out.
Erica grabbed Ally by the bottom of her chin and squeezed, this forced ally's pouty lips to stick out further as if she was comically puckering up to kiss someone. With Ally's face firmly in Erica's grasp Erica tilted her face upwards so that her face was almost looking straight up. Then Erica planted the second pie firmly into Ally's upturned pouty face. Erica delicately removed the pie tin so that the crust remained in place. Now another very curious thing happened here, Ally didn't attempt to move from her position nor did she attempt to remove any of the pie from her face. She just sat there, knowing what was to come next. Since earlier when Ally's face was stuck deep in Erica's ass pie, Ally found herself getting turned on surprisingly by Erica hitting her with pies. Especially when Erica's ass was involved. Ally always was able to appreciate a beautiful girl, but hadn't really ever tried getting intimate with one. Ally became quite wet between her legs at the anticipation of what was to come next.
Erica turned around, still missing her panties from Ally's earlier attack on her sweet round bubble butt, gave Charlie a sexy wink through all the pie on her face then without warning sat down with some force onto Ally's upturned pied face. The force and pressure of Erica's ass sitting on Ally's face caused the pie to be shoved deep into all of Ally's face's crevices. Erica just sat there for a moment and giggled at her victory over this spoiled little brat. Charlie could not take it anymore. Charlie picked up two pies for himself and walked over to Erica as she sat on her "Ally chair".

"What are you doing with those pies?" Erica asked nervously. Charlie just stood there with a mischievous grin on his face.

"Oh no, you're not going to hit me in the face with those pies are you?!" Charlie nodded "But why?! Erica cried with a slight smile on her face.

Charlie couldn't contain himself for another second; he smashed both pies at once sandwiching Erica's face as she let out startled muffled cry. He twisted and turned the pies until Erica's face was completely unrecognizable under a massive layer of pudding, cream and pie crust. At this point Ally pushed Erica off her, needing oxygen and all , and stood up. Ally wiped the pie from her face and looked over at Erica whose entire head looked as if it were just a mound of pie filling. Erika then took both hands and wiped down her face to clear most of the pie from her eyes and mouth. Both girls stood there glaring at each other for a moment then grabbed the closest desert they could reach. Ally grabbed a thick Strawberry cream pie and Erica picked up a large round white cake with extras thick frosting. The girls posed to attack each other with their tasty weapons when Ally stopped and noticed something that shocked her.

"Charlieis this turning you on?!" as she had noticed a large bulge in the front of Charlie's pants that was totally pointless to try and hide because he was so aroused.
Ally and Erica then looked at each other with a smirk and knew exactly what to do.