Charlotte was backstage at Smackdown a week after she humiliated Dana Brooke. Charlotte was looking in a mirror putting on makeup. She was doing another open challenge this week, and was wondering what woman would have the guts to face her this week after what she did to Dana Brooke last week. "God. Charlotte is such a bitch." Charlotte peeks into the locker room to see Carmella talking to Dana Brooke. Carmella had been gone for a while, and was catching up on things. Dana told her everything that happened last week with Charlotte. Carmella was disgusted. "I can't believe she did those things to you. I am going to answer her open challenge this week. She is going to pay for all of those things she had done to you." Dana warned Carmella. "You better win or else she may get you even worse than she got me. Carmella dismisses the warning. "Oh Dana, don't you remember? I have beaten Charlotte Flair twice. And besides MELLA IS MONEY" Carmella gets ready for the match tonight.

Charlotte smiles and goes back to doing her makeup. She is excited that Carmella is answering her challenge. Carmella has bragged for years that she had beaten Charlotte twice. This challenge has provided an opportunity for her to shut up Carmella once and for all and besides those victories were not even legitimate. One was a money in the bank cash in after the IIconics attacked her. The second time was her cheating the entire time. Charlotte knew she was the better wrestler and she was going to prove it tonight.

Later in the night, Charlotte makes her way down to the ring for her match. She is wearing her red gear. Charlotte enters the ring and takes off her robe. She faces the entrance ramp with a determined look on her face. "F-A-B-U-L-O-U-S" Carmella makes her way to the ring doing her signature moonwalk. Carmella is wearing her light blue and green one piece. Carmella gets in the ring.

The bell rings and Charlotte takes advantage because Carmella has not wrestled in months. Charlotte shows off her dominance early. Charlotte gets cocky and grabs the bottom of her one piece. "WEDGIE" Charlotte says as she pulls up on her one piece. Carmella screams and swings her fist at Charlotte which connects and dazes Charlotte. Carmella makes her comeback and hits Charlotte with a superkick. She goes for the cover "1.....2..." Charlotte kicks out. Carmella immediately locks in the Code of Silence hoping to make Charlotte submit. However, Charlotte uses her strength to pick up Carmella and hit her with a powerbomb. Charlotte locks in her Figure Eight submission maneuver.Carmella flails her arms trying to reach the ropes, but she is not close enough. Carmella can't take the pain anymore and taps out.

Charlotte goes under the ring and grabs a tray with ten pies on it and puts it into the ring. However, she also gets two buckets from under the ring and brings them in. Charlotte grabs a coconut cream pie from the tray and approaches Carmella. Carmella is focused on her injured leg that she doesn't know Charlotte is behind her ready to attack. Carmella turns around and her world is turned white as Charlotte slams a coconut cream pie right into her face. Charlotte laughs as she rubs the pie tin over her face and on her hair. Charlotte then grabs a chocolate pudding pie and opens up the back of Carmella's one piece and gently places the pie. Charlotte then lifts Carmella and does a body slam to Carmella which smashes the pie and chocolate goes everywhere inside Carmella's one piece.

"Oh my God. What the fuck? My gear is ruined" Carmella screams. "Oh shut up."Charlotte smashes a strawberry cream pie into Carmella's face. The force causes Carmella to fall backwards and back onto the pie that was in her one piece. Charlotte grabs the front of Carmella's one piece and pulls up on it giving Carmella a frontal wedgie. "Oh Carmella nice camel toe. However I think we should cover you up." Charlotte slams an apple pie right onto Carmella's pussy. Carmella rolls onto her stomach to cover up her pussy. Charlotte goes back to the tray and grabs two custard cream pies. As Carmella gets on all fours Charlotte simultaneously smashes one pie into Carmella's face and another into Carmella's ass.

Charlotte goes and grabs one of the buckets and places it under Carmella's face. Carmella is shocked at what is happening to her as she stays on all fours. "I can't believe you tapped out. Not even Dana tapped out." Charlotte laughs as she takes off her boot and places her foot on the back of Carmella's head. "Since you submitted to me, now you will submit to me." Charlotte uses her foot to force Carmella's face and head into the bucket of green cake batter. Charlotte keeps Carmella's head into the cake batter for about 8-10 seconds before taking her foot off of Carmella's head. "Well you say Mella is money, and money is green, right?" Charlotte says as she lets out a giggle. When Carmella comes up for air, she is instantly met with a french silk pie to the face. Charlotte gives Carmella a couple of seconds to breathe before using her hand to force Carmella back into the cake batter. Another 8-10 seconds pass before Charlotte let's go. Carmella comes up for air again and is hit with a banana cream pie to the face. Charlotte forces Carmella's head into the cake batter one final time. Another 10 seconds pass before Charlotte lets Carmella breathe. Carmella comes up and is hit with a pumpkin cream pie.

"Now Carmella, I have one pie and one bucket left. Since you have been through a lot, I will not mess you up anymore."Carmella let's out a sigh of relief. "On one condition, you have to lick my foot completely clean of cake batter." Charlotte raises her cake batter covered foot up to Mella's face. Carmella just wants this messy torture to end so she starts licking Charlotte's foot. After a couple of minutes, Carmella finishes cleaning Charlotte's foot. "Wow you did a good job Carmella. It's too bad I lied though." Charlotte opens up the front of Carmella's one piece and smashes a vanilla pudding pie right into Carmella's breasts.

Charlotte grabs the final bucket and raises it over Carmella. "Now Carmella I am a huge fan of your podcast. I noticed you said you liked golden showers." Carmella looks up at Charlotte. "Well I am not peeing on you so here is a nice replacement." Charlotte turns the bucket over and a stream of yellow cake batter covers Carmella's face and hair. Charlotte takes joy in covering Carmella with yellow cake batter. Eventually, the stream ends and Charlotte places the bucket on Carmella's head. The bucket says PIE CLUB MEMBER. Charlotte leaves the ring as Carmella sits there messy and humiliated.

THE END

Who should be the next member?