Getting pied has become one of my favorite messy expierences. It gets me every time. I can never seem to get enough of them either. So I'm looking for ideas of types of pies I should use next. I like actual crusts with nice fillings to stick to or drip onto me. I'm looking to try out new colors textures and flavors. Any input from things you personally like or would like to see in regards to types of fillings or specific kinds of pies would be greatly appreciated.

Oh my - you and pies... Where do we start.

You guys have cool whip don't you. Coloured up and piled high oh and plenty of them. What about the ones in my profile? Use crusts without plates or tins. Pie sandwiches are a big hit for me plus pie hats. Also thrown pies and pie barrages, quick and fast. I have used cake batter pies here topped with fruit filling and other goodies. How about those.

I cant wait to see you take a whole barrage of pies. Heaven! Keep up the oh so good work...

Pumpkin pie filling, peanut butter and chocolate mixed runny at bottom n heavy cream mixed w marshmallow fluff on top! And then anywhere and everywhere!

At some point I got it into my head that someone should do a pie for each letter of the alphabet. From Apple Cream to Zucchini. Seems like a reasonable life goal for anyone really.

Ohh I love it already. Especially the pb chocolate plus fluff suggestion.

I have been toying with ideas for new pie fillings but got shot down with a those kinds aren't messy enough comment so thank you guys for replying on this so far. I'm very excited to make lots of different kinds.

My girlfriend and I used fruit pies in our last session, very sticky

And I (and I'm sure many others here) are in turn very excited to see you get plastered in your pretty puss with a panoply of pastries. From everything we've seen so far, you sure can take a pie like a total pro, and and they look sensational on you!!

Cherry pie filling always *looks* amazing, fwiw.

Here's a try - -

A=Apple Cream, Avocado,
B=Blueberry, Beans
C=Custard or Crisco, Cake
D=Dream Whip, Devil's Food Batter
E=Eclair
F= Flour (yep, plain old flour)
G=Greek yogurt
H=Hellman's Mayo, Honey
I=Ice cream
J=Jelly
K=Karo Syrup, Ketchup
L=Lemon meringue, Lard, Limberger Cheese
M=Marshmallow or Molasses
N=Nutella
O=Oleomargarine, Oreo Ice Cream
P=Prune Filling, Potatoes (mashed), Peanut Butter
Q=Queen Bee Honey, Quiche
R=Ricotta
S=Shoofly pie,Salad Dressing, Sour Cream, Spam
T=Treacle
U=unsalted butter (warm)
V=Vaseline
W:Waffle syrup
Xmas cake
Y:Yams in syrup, Yogurt
Z:Zabaglione

Hersheys syrup on top of chocolate pies.

I personally love the cookies and cream pies messygirl used in some of their videos. Seeing you rub that filling all over your body.....woooooooooo lawd id need a shower lol

You should definitely experiment with a variety to see what you enjoy best. It surprises no one that the fake pies are my favorite. Barbosal shaving foam pies stick and cover so well!

One fun idea I did with my messy partner was we took nasty substances like salad dressing an BBQ, tartar sauce, etc and made pies out of those. But we topped each one off with a layer of whipped cream. So we didn't know if it was going to be a tasty pie or a "punishment " pie. It added to the suspense of the thing. It really got us to a new area of wam in a way. The not knowing part made us more nervous.

We decided next time we try it whoever gets the most punishment lies has to go down on the other. Now the stakes are even higher

"Asian Creampies"

Fill up some pies with pudding. Super fun sloppy texture!!

I am also a fan of the lemon and pumpkin pie fillings that are easy to get.

Icing and Fluff pies while your laying down and giving him a blowjob. First 2 pics are pictures of what pies should look like pie and last 2 pics are of what the scene should look like (the one directly over head should be more zoomed out). It would literally be a dream come true to see a scene like this. Especially if you did it.

In the WAM novel I have been working on for some time, I had my main female character make pies out syrup, regular crust and then topped with whip cream...just a thought!

Also if any remember the episode "Hollywood at Last!" from I Love Lucy and the scene where William Holden gets pied, they used applesauce topped with whip cream to make it stick better for the camera...just another thought!

Speaking of lots of pies, you might get inspiration from another awesome WAM couple, Infi's photo sets....!

https://umd.net/forums/had-some-fun-with-my-girl-yest

One key difference: we don't hide our faces

While I agree Infi's stuff is great, this thread is about different pie recipes to try out.

As for ideas, I've had good experiences with home made whipped cream recently. No additives, just whip up in a bowl and throw!