You are Batman observing a police line up of every single Cat Woman over the years (with their masks off of course). You have one pie!!! Who gets it?

Probably Halle Barry.

Not necessarily because she's the one I want to pie most, but more because there's no amount of retribution that is enough to justify the existence of her Catwoman movie.

Use a TARDIS to pick each of them up during the filming of their respective Catwoman movies, bring them all to the same time and location, and have them mud-wrestle each other, in costume, in one of Robn Blaine's mud pits in 1995.

Anne Hathaway by a mile

But where is Lee Meriweather?

I feel like Michelle's Catwoman would have the best reaction/facial expression post-pie to the face, so I vote her.

Michelle Pfeiffer definitely.

Me too

Oh that would work

If you had selected a full-body picture of Julie Newmar, she would be leading the poll

Especially amazing considering her shot was on only-3-networks mainstream television in the 1960s!

Probably because she wasn't 18 when she starred in Gotham

This one (Newmar, I think, from the original BM series)

OOH! This is an incredibly tough decision for me. I've been itching to see Catwoman in general get wet and/or messy, regardless of which actress played her.

What's Batman doing with only 1 pie? Surely he could pull out a dozen pies from his utility belt.

This was a very very difficult decision. They're all sexy as hell.
Brain: "Eartha Kitt! Wait, no, Julie Newmar! Wait... Michelle Pfeiffer for sure!" [page loads] "Oh yeah, Anne Hathaway!!"

Went with Anne.

Also, I think we'd all be afraid to pie Eartha Kitt. She'd kick your ass in real life.

Anne Hathaway is on my "tricky ones" list. Sometimes she does nothing for ne, but as Catwoman she looked pretty amazing.

This is a tough one cuz I love the image of Julie Newmar's Catwoman getting slimed.
Anne Hathaway definitely ranks as someone I'd love to see get slimed (and pied)
But Michelle Pfeiffer was so hot as Catwoman. Hell I have a hard time picking if I want classic mask or - as one of my friends called it - crazy mall hair at the end.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VcoTMBPJPMc

Random observation. Three of the hot women in this thread, Anne Hathaway, Halle Berry and Michelle Pfeiffer, are 39, 55 and 63, and all look amazing.

I think that women, in general, seem to age much less than they did years ago, this might come out as sexist, but that's not the intention, it's a positive observation. I mean when I was a kid, in Lancashire in the 60s, a woman in her 40s then often looked proper ropey and quite old, but now they don't. If you look at pictures of women in their 40s, taken in the 60s, they often look like Nellie Pledge, but today, a fair proportion of this age group will be outstandingly attractive, they seem to look after themselves better, nice outfits, hair, nails, make up etc.

So, how come there's a 'cat woman' but only a 'bat girl' ?

"I have a show on the CW.....................
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=b7RPQMBhVcM

they've been putting me in ALL of the animated movies, even storylines
that I wasn't available for in the comics.....................
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PYPqTLS_g9c

and this person still doesn't know that I exist????"

May be recency bias for me having just seen it but ZoKravitz is so frickin hot in that so she gets my vote.