I was disappointed by the pie recipe I used in my last set of videos, so this time around, I'm not relying on faith ... I'm testing out new recipes. On myself. Whenever I feel like it. (The joys of permanently having an apartment all to oneself.)

So would you be so kind as to view this 2-minute video and let me know what you think of this new recipe? It's equal parts Cool Whip (which I let thaw for several hours) and icing. Too runny? Just right? Just the splatter you like? Model too ugly? Leave a comment for me, please!

Hopefully this will be the first of a handful of tests, leading up to what I hope will be a new episode later this winter!

https://youtu.be/8L2WsuF7WyM

Slightly runny I believe is best. It makes a bigger mess

They all look great. Your videos are always creative and some of the best out there!


I think that should be your next video. Billy is still a poor college student and answers a craigs list add to be a product test subject.

Billy gets to the site and he is met by 2 scientists. They make Billy change into a nice speedo or thong and escort him to a room.

They sit him down and than reveal 2 tables, one on each side. One table has sloppy pies and the other thick pies.

The scientists take turns hitting Billy all over and taking notes on coverage, feel, etc.

It is finally revealed at the end that the scientists are from the frat getting revenge on Billy for reporting them to the Dean.

But Billy gets his ultimate revenge at the end when both scientists are ready to hit Billy in the face with pie, he loosens his ties and pushes the same pie in their faces.

I think you've got the right consistency with this new mixture - not too solid that it just sticks to your head, but not too runny that it all drips off onto the floor. However, we still need to see more possibilities, so keep them coming! And thanks for all the videos over the years - quite the collection!

Not sure... we're probably going to see to see a hundred or so examples to really get a good idea....

Thanks for all the feedback, guys! Keep it coming!

Some takeaways:
- The pies are still a bit runny
- Runny does still work for some folks out there
- It's just as fun for people to watch me getting "punished" as it is for people to watch enjoying taking it
- I should invest in some really good moisturizer, because my face is going to take a beating over the next few weeks

Noted.

I'm not familar yet with the different pie recipes available, but those look like they'd work well for a variety of slapstick pie hits and sandwiches. But since you're not entirely happy with the recipe, practice makes perfect. The genuine hilarity in your videos is just the best.

This is amazing!

The new pie recipe looks great! They give a good splat and they're not too runny (in my opinion). I've discovered that I like the feel of the pie dripping down after impact, so I tend towards pies like these. I've never used icing before - I thought it would be too thick, but maybe blending it with something else is the trick. I've used pudding for pies before, but they can thicken over time, so you have to be a little careful. Keep up the good work!