We have used both type of pies over the years, but the majority of them being real cream pies. What type of pies would you rather see used in a shoot?

Discuss

Real cream pies love how it sleep off the face

I LOVE real cream pies! Or whipped cream with marshmallow fluff added!

Shaving cream is okay (after all, PieGirlKay has made a career of it, and she's done quite well ) but it basically leaves a big blob of cream that just stays there. I like how whipped cream breaks up and runs off a lady's face and drops onto their chest or into their lap.

Just my 2 cents worth ....

Norman

Real ones provided they are made right and stick well. You folks at Messygirl get them to stick very well.


If I am messing personally, I prefer shaving foam. Though, yes, it is just a type of soap, it can be very messy, and it is a much easier clean-up. Dissolving as it does, in water.

Definitely real.

I don't like shaving cream at all.

In a word, real

Real!

Real

You probably know what I'm going to say!

I do have an appreciation for real cream pies in the traditional sense. That being said, I'm a huge fan of full coverage and contrary to Norman I love how shaving cream just stays on you. Seeing a girl transform into an unrecognizable figure gets me going and very few substances can make that happen better than shaving cream!

Real. Models can't complain about the eye burning or the taste....

For me part of the attraction of the pie fight is that this pastry which was designed to eat has instead been used to humiliate someone, with a key part of the scenario being that this item was not designed for that purpose.

No-one would make a pie based out of shaving cream (except to hit someone with). A pie of shaving cream for me isn't a pie..it's a creation with shaving cream in it whose only function is to get someone messy, ergo it's not a pie, ergo almost the entire pleasure is removed...it's simply someone putting shaving cream in a container then hitting someone with it. As opposed to the conceipt that this is something designed to be eaten that, in order to humiliate and take away the dignty of someone else, has been thrown at them.

I think this is because i am 100% on the situationalist side of wam, where the erotic element derives from the set-up, the humiliation of the recipient etc, and for that to work it requires that the pie being used is a real pie being used to an end for which it wasn't made.

The only caveat being that if I don't know a pie is a shaving cream pie (ie if it could pass visual inspection as a real pie & no-one drew attention to its actual contents) I probably wouldn't care. However I like to think I can tell the difference & so the point is moot.

So, and I hope I haven't been vague about my view to this point, REAL

SHAVING CREAM.

I don't actually care, I just get annoyed at the real pie lobby. Plus I'm a jerk.

I believe they both have their place here. I slightly prefer real, But in a pinch or budget shaving cream works fine. Some times I'm just in the mood for one or the other as well.

As was already said by JediKnight, if it's an MG model in a video, then real pies have a splatter and a way of sliding off the face that shaving cream doesn't match. However, if it's me getting it then I much prefer shaving cream.

REAL. Foam pies are not pies for me, are foam in a plate...

There are so much offer in the market that I never buy a video with even only one foam pie... Yes, I'm a taliban again foam, I know...

Your real pies are very good, much much better than your foam ones...

Shaving cream all the way!

Definitely real or at least made using any combination of frosting, cool whip or marshmallow. I also am a big fan of either a blueberry or cherry pie with a gooey cream topping. You have used these pies before with great effect. A shoot with Vicky I believe mgdl-67 comes to mind.

Seeing a girl get a face full of chemicals is a bummer. The only thing that might be worst is reddi whip on a paper plate...

For me its a high floor/low ceiling kind of thing. A real pie delivered well in the right conditions will beat a shaving cream pie every time. However a shaving cream pie can easily out perform a real pie in coverage if the latter is not done correctly.
A shaving cream pie for me has to have crust, though.

Real. No other way around it.

Butterbean pies gets my vote.

I love the idea of real pies but I prefer the looks of shaving cream pies.

I would have to go with shaving cream.

The coverage is better, and I don't find much enjoyment with real pies.

Just my two cents.

Real so they can eat it.

Both x

As a brit....shaving cream. Considering we get horrible squirty cream as the alternative, shaving cream gives better coverage and the added bonus of not smelling like crap for days on end after it.

Although...shaving cream is basically soap, and something does seem a bit strange about the whole "I'm gonna get messy with something that's designed to make me clean"...

Gee, does that mean you would not have to shower afterwards?!

Watching, I don't mind either. I like shaving cream's coverage. It's constant. Where as real pies can sometimes have suck coverage depending on what they're made out of, how long they have been sitting out, etc.

Taking them, I much prefer something edible. Plus I make my own whipped cream from heavy cream so I can control the consistency.

Strictly, there are at least 2 categories of real pies.
One of these sticks less than shaving cream.
The other sticks & humiliates far better than even shaving cream.

The kind of real pies that stick less than shaving cream, I hate to say, are rather disappointing, because they peel off the face right away.

Shaving cream certainly "sticks" well to the face & covers the face. Yet, the part of my brain that recognizes sexiness - I think it's called the penis - is not fooled by the (fake) shaving cream. It KNOWS deep down that this shaving cream is really just the same as applying a lot of soap to the face.

The kind of real pies that stick even better than shaving cream, and certainly look more humiliating generally have marshmallow fluff, cherry pie filling, & fudge in them - the more the merrier. The kind of pies that fit this category are undoubtedly rare among both wam & non-wam pie videos:

Greta Thyssen getting pied & caked in The Three Stooges
Redd's naked ten-pie face smash (a Lenny production)
the old Tabitha video

Nothing has ever nor ever will top those pies. And, I am sure they were undoubtedly the most expensive pies possible.

The ultimate pie challenge: create a vegan pie
with the same consistency as these uber-pies.
A startup company, Muufri.com, with a laboratory out in San Francisco, I believe, is working on just such a problem. Well, they just don't know it yet. They're currently working on growing milk protein first. Hopefully after that they can figure out how to mass produce egg protein.

I like both, but my recent experiences with a woman in the bedroom have made me more of a fan of shaving foam than ever. I finally found a woman that will try all the messy stuff and we can actually have sex covered in sensitive skin foam and both be comfortable. Real pies, cool whip, reddi-whip were all fun, but too cold, hard to clean up and the smell gets stuck in the nose.