Thanks to all who participated in my last poll asking if you prefer to see a girl pie herself or be pied by someone else. The poll closes on Sunday, but it looks like the majority of you like to see someone else pie the girl, about 2 to 1. It was very informative and interesting to hear your reasons why, too. And I agree that it also has a lot to do with if the person is enjoying themselves as well! That being said, I have another burning, pie-related question to ask y'all... The question is - Do you have a preference with seeing pies with or without crust, or does it matter either way? I resoundingly prefer to receive my pies WITHOUT crust, and I'll tell you why. Now, hear me out - it's NOT FUN for me to rub the mess around if there's crust involved because it feels gross, sandy and gritty! I really need the textures to feel smooth and sexy to turn me on. I can't even think about getting off if there is any amount of grit or scratchiness involved anywhere; I like things to slide and glide for me to ride. You feel me? And so, it kind of bothers me when I see pie crusts in videos or photos because in my mind, that wouldn't feel good or sexy and that really bums me out! I need my pies to be 100% smooth and creamy, or I'm just not happy! I can't be alone in my thinking with this, can I? That's why I gotta know! So, if you're reading this, please take a second to weigh in with your vote or your thoughts on the matter. I would really appreciate it! I can't wait to see the results of this one!

Photos appear courtesy of messygirl.com and messyangel.com

Fully get the sand/gritty texture you describe and you certainly can't get as carried away with it mixed in with the pie filling if you know what I mean. However, I massively prefer a pie with a crust when it's smushed in my face as it makes the pie feel at least 10 times as good. I tend to prefer to use crust pies with foam on my face and paper plates with foam everywhere else to get around the issue.

Interesting to hear other opinions. Matt x

Well.

If I pie myself it will be without the crust. As you said it just feels like sand.
But when I watch movies the crust looks better.

For me, from a visual standpoint, it's all about the coverage, and crust not only adds to the coverage, a well-delivered crust can keep a lot of pie sticking to the face for longer.

Love the 'KfaD FfaL' sig, btw.

Wow, thanks Newton! Nice catch on that KFAD reference! I absolutely adore Mike Patton and pretty much anything he is involved in! Unfortunately, my boyfriend hates him! He made me take down my life-sized Patton poster. Tragic.

I really love how a crust can just trap you into a mess. I really love when the crust is just perfectly on someone's face. One of my fav things about wam

Good, good! These are all good. The great thing is, there's no wrong answer! I am learning a lot! I'm feeling more forgiving of an old friend who used to insist on buying my most-hated pies with crusts for our kink play! I would get SO PISSED at him and thought he was an absolute selfish jerk, when really, it sounds like this is most people's preference! I can respect it!

Crust pretty much makes or breaks a scene in my opinion. Seeing a woman's face completely encased with a full crust wrapped around her face, cream popping out the sides- has to be one of the greatest sights to behold.

I blame the SD era of Rich's work for making me fall in love with that kind of pieing

There are a small handful of scenes I appreciate which involve no crust, but I think each one would be better if there were crust

I am 100% in favor of actual cream pies. With cream, filling, and of course CRUST! They look great, feel amazing, and are easy to control. I get the whole sandy, gritty feeling being uncomfortable but I never had that problem. I bake my crusts, so they shatter but never crumble. If that makes any sense. The tins, however, I could understand a bit more. Recently, I've been getting into taking the shell out of the tin. Don't get me wrong, I still enjoy the visual aspect of a tin every now and then.

I have a quite sizeable Patton collection, off the top of my head, the obvious ones (FNM, Tomahawk, Bungle, Fantomas) along with Lovage, Maldoror, Kaada/Patton, Fantomas Melvins Big Band, General Patton Vs. The X-Ecutioners, a couple solo albums and a bunch of records he did for John Zorn. I know I'm forgetting something, and yet there's still a ton of shit I don't have... but must! Oddly, I still have yet to hear much Dead Cross, even though hardcore is one of my favorite genres.

I think I agree with most on here the crust gives a more realistic look and effect, but my wife and I agree about uncomfortable gritty sand like feeling that comes with it. Also if we're playing in the tub or shower the crust bits don't wash right down the drain.

I enjoy the look of texture in a pie hit; how it clings to the face or other areas.