There was once a download pie video store that last roughly for the same period of time that PieJinx & PiesNextDoor existed. Somewhere between 2004 and 2010. The problem is: I have very sketchy leads to go by.

As I recall:
1. like PieJinx or Messygirl's Justpieme.com download store,
it was just single women being pied.

2. American company

3. download store was also Vidown (like Justpieme.com) or TheMothership

4. Real pies were used. Incredible pie coverage.

5. The name of the store was something in sentence form, like "GirlsGetPied".

6. So far, 1-5 narrow practically nothing down. Here's my only lead, and it's a really tough hair-thinned lead. In one of their pie videos, or at least in the ad for the video (since I never bought the video), the music in the background used was Jacques Offenbach's "Orpheus in the Underworld", i.e. the "can can" music, performed by female violinist Vanessa Mae. I know, because at the time, I asked the store owner: "where did you get that arrangement of 'can can'?" and he told me "Vanessa Mae".

I always wanted to buy their videos but never could, kept putting it off, putting it off, saving money, saving money, hoping one day I could make enough money to buy a download. But by that time, it was too late: they closed their store.

(Actually, it's still too soon: I am even poorer now than I was back then.)

Was it Pie Fun? Trying to locate some pics from their shop -- they were good.

Any sense of whether this producer tried for comedy skits, or was it more just woman getting pelted with pies without any attempt for a reason why? Can you remember anything about how the models tended to dress, what the backdrops looked like, etc.?

If they went for the comedy angle, then it does mostly sound like Pie Fun Productions. Of course, that name isn't a sentence, so if your'e sure of that part, then these aren't the droids you're looking for.

Maybe https://umd.net/profile/piedinthefaceproductions ?

sounds like PiesNextDoor

Pies Next Door was basically just PieJinx Part 2. Same producer, identical style, but using different models. Neither of these stores featured real pies in their videos, though.

Yes! I believe it was Pie Fun (Productions)! Thank you, CKCP!

Forget the "sentence in the name" thing. Pie Fun Productions sounds closest to what I am thinking.

After I post the vidcaps for the winners in the PieJinx poll, my next vidcap project will be to do some of the Pie Fun Productions stuff. They're another big favorite of mine who sadly disappeared around the same time as Blue Leopard and PieJinx/PiesNextDoor.