If you could choose any of the contestants from love island (either UK or US, I've only seen the US version) to get messy, who would you pick?

We were blessed to see many of them get (slightly) pied during one of the scenes, but in this case, a full on WAM scenario.

My picks would be Genny Shawcross and Phoebe Siegel. Would absolutely love to see these two hotties take cake batter slimings and get pied in the face

I'm a big fan of Genny, and I was happy that she got pied -- and I'd say she more than "slightly pied" -- on the show. The main problem with her pieing was that, as is so often the case, the camera angles for her pieing were crappy. Genny's pieing had the added bonus of her sexy friend on the Island, who had previously showed some serious signs of being sexually attracted to Genny (don't know her name but she had purple hair at the time), leaning over and licking some of the pie off her face.

A whole mess (pun intended!) of screencaps attached below...

I would choose both of those ones for a Human Garbage Disposal.

Chloe Burrows was always me fave. She had a quirky personality and was great on the show. She did get pied but it wasn't great even though that episode of smog marry pied was the best one we had on the UK edition. I'm still bitter the US version of the show had FAR superior pies to us even though we created the fuckin thing. Most successful show we got over here and the miserly bastards can't still scrimp lol.

I'd merely like to see all the actual LI USA pieings, because on at least one series they didn't show them all, or at least I haven't seen full clips anyway.