Something I've long wondered about - if a young woman is getting gunged with her clothes on, is it sexier if she wears short shorts, or a short skirt?

What's your view, and why? Please vote in the poll and add comments below, very interested to learn how other people think on this one.

Short skirt. Both are incredibly sexy but I think skirts are just that bit more. Maybe it's because I'm quite the underwear fan too.

I a big fan of sexy skirts, especially pleated mini skirts and skater skirts . They look really feminine and flattering and give the look of a smaller waist . Also of note most of these skirts have shorts built into them or can be worn with shorts , so that her secret parts are not on show .

The short skirt gets my vote. You can put anything under it. From leggings to commando, boybrief to g-string. The skirt is more versatile.

Interesting results so far!

Personally I've always thought shorts are sexier because you can see the actual point where the legs divide, front and back, and to me seeing the clothes covering that area get messy in a WAM scene is "the money shot". It's why I'm always death on camera operators who zoom in on the upper half and thus deny the viewer the chance to see what's happening below the waist.

Having a perfect crotch and bum view is also of course why I love to put girls in spandex catsuits and tight running leggings and yoga pants.

But I've always wondered how an actual vote on skirt vs shorts would go, been meaning to post this for a few years.

Of course we've done miniskirt and games-skirt scenes, which sell, and we have a rather good tennis dress one in the stockpile, we've also done quite a few short shorts scenes and those do well too.

Please keep the votes and comments coming, very interested to learn how others think about this.

Skirt.

I think I'll always prefer a long dress, but recently I've noticed that whenever I accidentally beat it to a video of someone getting gunged in a dress, it's a short dress and usually a video that doesn't look like it's being filmed by a producer ie the below video


https://m.youtube.com/shorts/JHDX8cvyOio

Both are incredibly nice and it's a shame to have to make a choice. A skirt wins it for me by a very small margin, probably because shorts are the more obvious thing to wear if a girl is going to get gunged, so a skirt is more eye-catching and daring. But either could be more appealing in specific situations. And both look.great wet too. Great poll, thanks, Peter.

Come on! For those who lived the 80's and 90's and seen a single rock video girl cross the tv screen like Donna Rupert or Lillian Mler from "Hot for Teacher", this is a slam dunk. LOL.

Not familiar with that one, but I certainly remember lots of rock chicks in jeans or denim shorts from that era, I had Kerrang's "Ladykillers" female rock compilation on VHS, which was basically a non-stop tight high-waist jeans fest. Mmmm, Lita Ford! The music was really good, too, just a shame no-one took female metal acts seriously back then.

I also saw Bon Jovi live on the tour for the "Keep The Faith" album at a massive arena gig. 75% of the audience was female and at least half of them were in denim dungarees. Heaven!

If you have a hard time remembering the time period, Bobbie Brown in "Cherry Pie" comes to mind

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=OjyZKfdwlng

I would always choose the shorts as long as they are the shiny nylon satin ones. I love the shine of t.hen when messy/wet and they cling to the shape of the wearer's bum. Perfection

Skirt for me, but has to have tights or stockings with it

for me it depends on the angle of the shoot. If there is a possibility of upskirt, then skirt it is! I love seeing the panties, especially getting messy.

However, If no upskirt then I want to see the shape of the butt through a nice pair of tight shorts. I love some VPL!

Skirt every time. Upskirt is another kink of mine so if I see a flash of panties it makes the scene that much better.

I wish I could pick both. I would love seeing shorts under skirts along with underwear under the skirts. Tight short shorts are awesome too cause it causes noticeable underwear lines. Each has their perks. As a fan of sitting on things yes a short shows more but the same goes for a skirt and if said person is sitting on something but is like carrying on like nothing is there and it's not noticeable is a huge turn on for me. It's like they are sharing a sexy time together that only they know about.

Ah, a fellow 'gap' fan.

It's ironic for me, because I voted Short Skirt, for many of the reasons mentioned (panty variety or lack there of, upskirt naughtiness etc.).

But I'm a sucker for gaps. Any woman that shows hers, does it on purpose.

Excellent question, as already shown by the number of replies!

Is it maybe ultimately a mood thing, like 'What is your favourite song/film'? There'll a load of things you always like, but the actual answer will be dependent on changing feeling on a given day...

I mean... A red hot youngish MILF in classic gameshow outfit of slightly too tight and lurid a tee-shirt tucked into slightly too short and tight a pair of shorts... Or a long-haired brunette, tossing her short tartan skirt around above her black satin stockings and suspenders while waiting on the inevitable mess to come/cum...

Call me team 'either of the above'...

A skirt always, particularly if it's flared/full. Even better if it's long!

I just think skirts are feminine and sexy, whilst shorts are largely genderless and unattractive.

Perhaps a bit of a cop-out answer, but for me its entirely on the model and which they feel better in.

I voted for skirts, but I like the idea of filling shorts with gunge and wedging them up

Skirt, every time. I like tight pencil ones, full pleated ones, and short ones.

TBH, shorts don't really do that much for me for some reason. Also, skirts come off easily!

Weak spot for a short skirt here

I'd say that a tight skirt is more important than a short skirt. Same with shorts. Tight spandex shorts are sexier than anything, while loose shorts are basically a skip for me.

Either way, if you can't fill it, it might as well not be there in my opinion. Swimsuits, panties, workout clothes are always going to be my preference.

Looking at your username- absolutely nothing better than a wet or messy maxi dress.

I chose short skirt. My fantasy includes ease of entry.

In walks her daddy standin' 6 foot 4
He said, "You ain't gonna swing with my daughter no more"

I used to dance to that at Northern rock clubs - epic track. Not keen on shorts cut so short the pocket bags hang down spoiling the look - if someone's going to do that either lose the pockets completely or shorten them - but otherwise, hell yeah! Just a shame we don't get to see her shorts getting soaked when the band hose her down.


Very much so. In fact of all the preview images I've released in recent years, I think the first of the attached ones, a very fit and athletic Isabeau in a spandex zip catsuit (with nothing underneath) about to get absolutely coated and drenched in mud, and then quite literally throw herself into the river (shots 5 and 6, which are vidcaps), is one of my all-time favourite pre-mud clean shots.

--[]--

Meanwhile liking everyone's comments, very interesting to see the various different approaches, including some I'd not previously thought of. Attached are two shorts shots, and two short(ish) skirt images. In the shorts, first Charity is having her PVC shorts filled before getting her own back by spreading handfuls of custard all over Honeysuckle's satin ones, and then we have Friday pulling her sports dress up to show off her nice shiny underwear, which then gets thoroughly flanned by Miss Abigail in the second of the two.

So far skirts has a commanding lead, but shorts have also had plenty of votes, and the poll runs till Wednesday so plenty of time yet. Please keep the votes and comments coming!

Where does the last pic you posted here come from ?

That's from "Pie Fighting Dress vs Skirted Swimsuit", which is currentlty in the Members Lounge at SaturationHall.com and will go live on our download store in 25 days time, Thurdsay 21st December.

Full details here: https://saturationhall.com/?set=gm-4f037

Not overkeen on shorts but I do like very tight, shiny leggings and disco pants

I'm one of the few that voted for short shorts, although it's by a small margin. Something is very sexy about seeing a woman (especially one with toned, muscular legs) wearing tight-fitting shorts.