She agreed to get messy awhile back and she loved every second of it when she finally did it! I used 3 bowls of batter, some oatmeal and 2 pies. She seems instantly hooked.

Now my question is what should be do next? We are looking to get messy next weekend

We thought about turning it into a game but not sure what game if we do that. We also do not know what substances to try, she says she is willing to try about anything once.

What should I get her messy with and how should we get messy?

any ideas?

If she's still fairly new to it and isn't into humiliation, surprises or submission, I'd likely stick with what you used last time, possibly adding a few of her favourite things in the mix. If she likes jelly add jelly or if she likes prosecco you could always pour some fizzy wine over her.

We are not certain what she is fully into yet, that is why we are looking for ideas. See what her potential limits are

Can't go wrong with puddin!

Marshmallow cream and or fluff is great!

I've loved using chocolate syrup, and to a lesser extend strawberry syrup.

Making it a game that she likes to play is definitely a wise move, in my opinion. The more fun she has, the more fun you have... and the sooner you will get to do it again.

My wife and I used to like playing Trivial Pursuit, and we added the element that, when you answer a question for a pie wedge, you get to to nail your opponent with a pie if you get it right. (And your opponent gets to nail you if you get it wrong.)

Getting messy never was my wife's thing, and it goes without saying that watching me get messy didn't do anything for her. Yet, she knew both things really turn me on, and she liked that. She also likes to laugh -- and we all know, nothing in the world is funnier than a pie in the face! Pretty soon she started to ham it up and add her own super-cute reactions.

If your fiancee is anything like my wife, then try to make it fun as fun for her as you can. Talk about what you like, and what you think would look really good on her. Before you know it, she will be proposing ideas of her own.

lucky

Awesome suggestions so far guys! If anyone else has any please leave them here I will let yall know how it goes if we do any of them