Athena/Ember Moon took a cake in the face last night on ROH from Abadon which made me think, loads of female pro wrestlers have been caked or pied before so i thought i'd compile a bit of a list!....

Athena/Ember Moon - caked on Roh
Charlotte Flair - pied Wwe
Stephanie McMahon - pied Wwe
Thunder Rosa - pied on her youtube show
Toni Storm - pied Wwe
Sunny/Tammy Lyn Sytch - Caked Wwe
Nyla Rose - caked Aew
Lana - caked Wwe
Michelle McCool - caked Wwe
Zelina Vega - caked Wwe
Asuka - pied in Japanese fed
Nikki Cross- caked Wwe
Mickie James - caked Wwe
Natalia Neidhart- pied Wwe
Layla El - pied and caked Wwe/ecw - multiple times
Karen Angle - pied Tna
Victoria/Tara - pied Tna
Kelly Kelly - pied WWECW
Stacey Kiebler - pied Wwe, caked Wcw
Joy Giovanni - pied Wwe
Mae Young - caked Wwe
Stevie Turner - caked Nxt
Fabulous Moolah - caked Wwe
Marina Shafir - pied Nxt
Santana Garrett - pied Nxt
Chelsea Green - pied Nxt
Rita Reis - pied Nxt
Vickie Guerrero - pied and caked Wwe
Nikki Bella - pied Wwe
Brie Bella - pied Wwe
Maria Kanellis - pied Tna
Gail Kim - pied Tna
Rebel - pied Tna
Alicia Fox - caked Wwe
Torrie Wilson - pied charity challenge
Americana - pied Glow
Vicky Victory - pied Glow
Daffney - caked Wcw
Harley Cameron - caked Aew
Lisa Phoenix - pied UK indie show
Milena - pied Wwe
Nadia Sapphire - Pied UK indie and own clips4sale adult content
Chardonnay (uk indie) - pied clips4sale

Some of these cakings are very very weak btw

Do you have a link to the last 2?

When was Harley Cameron caked in Aew? I watch every week and never saw that on an episode. Are sure your not confusing her with Penelope Ford?

It was during a QTV segment on Rampage. really dry cake,hardly any mess at all. There was also another time when she poured something over her own head...Again, not very good.

https://l.clips4sale.com/clip/27059629/blonde-bimbo-gets-cream-pied-by-bbw-female-suplexs-submssions-face-smashes


https://l.clips4sale.com/clip/26505431/thick-girl-sploshing

Nadia has also posted links to her onlyfans where shes deffo been pied and also i remember i poor quality clip of her getting a pie to her face on an indie show she posted on her twitter

Greatest wrestling pie segment for my money whilst we're on the topic (as ya mention Layla here has been pied and caked multiple times, shes got a real knack for it God bless her)

https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x57522u

Also cant recall Melina being pied but do recall her being in the pudding match with Candice Michelle if thats what yer referring to. If not would love to see the Melina pieing assuming its good

I don't remember that happening at all. I remember there was in episode of Qtv where John Morrison threw his cold coffee in her face. You sure your not thinking of that?

Anyone happen to have links to these pies and cakes? Some are easy to find but others, like the asuka or zelina scenes are neigh improbable

Zelina should be easy, she wasn't caked. She was pied. I think it was a bit setup for her birthday so whatever raw or smackdown around that time should be on the wwe YouTube channel. She gets misted by asuka and then pied. The pie kinda misses tho. The Asuka pie I've never heard about and is probably hard to find. It's probably under her old wrestling name Kana.

Anyone have links to Gail Kim and Chelsea Green?

Wrestlicious (all same episode, Takedown May 17, 2010)

Amber Lively (Madison Rayne)
Marley
Shauna Na (Kristin Flake also said to be aka Danielle French)
the Be-bops (one source names them as Wanda and Rhonda)

I don't have links but I can tell you where to look on YouTube. Gail is on a thanksgiving food fight segment. Should be on the tna channel.
Chelsea Green was pied on a nxt pie challenge vid on YouTube around pandemic time I think and she was caked at Gcw event. I think there are clips on Matt Cardona's ( her husband) channel.

Leila Grey and Tiffany Nieves- pied in ovw

Dream Girl Ellie- pied in ovw

ODB, Katie Lea, and a few others- pied in ovw

Mary Jane Payne- caked at an indie show

Miley- caked at an indie show

AJ Lee- caked at a house show

I think it might be referring to Milena Roucka (Rosa Mendes). She got pied in the Diva Search and got caked in OVW.

Any links or pics for the OVW stuff, know it can be hard to find so would appreciate it

I tried to find the OVW stuff a few years back, ODB, Katie-Lea thing was part of a non televised pie-fight match with all the female wrestlers on the roster at the time. Which included Mickie James, Serena Deeb and I think Beth Pheonix might've been there too, but no video exists to my knowledge. I found one youtube video with one pic of the event but it's so dark and faded nothing can be seen of worth. It's like a dark faded picture of ODB standing in the ring. I do know they promoted the live event on an episode of OVW where ODB got pied, but I don't know what episode that was, but maybe someone can track that down. ODB was the heel champ at the time, if I remember correctly.

This is the best I could find the pie fight via the wayback machine. As you'll see, Roucka is present there as well so you could say she got pied/caked three times. Add in her getting gunged with fake manure (most likely mud), and she got messy four times between 2006 and 2007.

The ladies involved were ODB, Katie Lea, Roni Jonah, Beth Phoenix, Roucka, Victoria Crawford (Alicia Fox), Serena (Deeb), She Nay Nay (?) & Jill (?). Katie was actually the heel champ at the time, and her getting pied was payback for her getting ODB earlier in the week, as mentioned earlier.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o5BDS-xCoc4

Whilst searching for OVW related stuff found this!!!! Never seen this before and its class! Tiffany Nieves and Leila Grey are the pied lasses.

Pies are thrown around 2 hours 43 mins in

1 24 30 I think this is Shalonce Royal. I love the setup.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WRmuDYgYiDE

I know this is about pied and caked female wrestlers, but Sunny (Tammy Sytch) also got a bucket of slop dumped on her by Phineas Godwinn. I remember that, as it was one of the first instances of Wamming I recall, that I would watch over and over again, along with Sunny getting caked by Ahmed Johnson.

Kayla Braxton got slimed with green slime on Smackdown.

Leah Knight was caked on DC wrestling December 14 2023

I am not looking at the list, did we forget Stephanie McMahon pied by Chris Jericho? Probably not

The iiconics were caked

Indy wrestler named Ravna got caked

Here's Miley and Mary Jane Payne and Lisa Phoenix, and an eggnogged Becky Lynch because I had it around.

OK, I've made a few contributions, does anyone have any more info, pics or links on this?

Rita Reis - pied Nxt

She seems amazing.

Or Shakir, I couldn't find that one.

Here's one of Steph De Lander after getting a fairly dry cake in the face in GCW. Also, Maxine Perez getting pied in old NXT.

Don't remember a Harley Cameron one, but I do remember Penelope Ford falling face first into a cake, a cake so dry that she later said she almost broke her nose.

Zelina was supposed to get pied with whipped cream last year in a Christmas themed match, but she said in an interview that a production assistant forget to add the whipped cream, resulting in what we got. She got a pumpkin pie and then misted. It does inspire hope though, because they were willing to do a match with mess with the ladies, and Christmas and Thanksgiving are right around the corner.

FYI despite teh same last name they are not related.


Just Peyton and it was so dry there was literally no mess

Since someone mentioned Asuka I thought I would include the pic

Also a few others to mention. During the famous Memorial Day Pie fight Summer Rae and Natalya got caked/pied but it was never seen on TV but there was a clip on summer rae's instagram (Becky was also a little messy)

Also missing from the List
Miss Jackie/Jaquiline/Miss TEXAS

Also, cant forget Karen Jarrett getting caked as well.

Oh and desrveing of their own post,.....The Worsties Salina De LA Renta of MLW and Alicia Atout (MJF'S fiance...aka Tits MCgee)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qx1q1Jom928
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Sx1Bs2y860
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GOnuhpBp-VM

and the piece de resitance and possibly the best until Tiffany and Leila got it
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K-PG8o1WZ3g

Probably my favourite type of scenes (even though it is rare they are any good). This is a great list. Normally a lurker, but compelled to contribute:

Dawn Marie Vs Torrie Wilson trick or treat match (cake and pies have terrible angles)
Amber Nova (pie in the face match: women warriors wrestling custom wrestling match)
Mariah May (dreamhouse death match - youtube - cake face, not great coverage - but pretty good set up)

I was thinking this would make a great set up for a producer like slapstickstuff:
Woman plays female wrestler (tight shorts etc). She has challenged her former male manager to a slapstick match. But she ends up receiving all the mess. No actual wrestling; just slapstick mess set ups. Set ups could include:
"Hey you in the audience. Give me that pie!" Gets hit in the face with a pie.
"My new manager is up in the rafters with a bucket a slime. Pour it... what are you waiting for?" Looks up, gets it poured on her instead.

Many pratfalls into cakes and bowls of gunge. Etc etc etc.

I have been meaning to write a custom like this, but I am on a custom hiatus for the moment.