The air in the apartment turned electric when Lizzy walked in with Criss. Jean didn't waste a second, immediately turning on the charm to win him over. Overwhelmed by a surge of jealousy, Lizzy decided to mark her territory in the messiest way possible--by smashing a cream pie right into Criss's face.

Surprisingly, this only fueled Jean's excitement. "I don't want your boyfriend, Lizzy," Jean laughed, "I just want to see him totally undone." She punctuated the sentence by landing a second pie squarely on his jaw. For the next fifteen minutes, it was total chaos. The two girls relentlessly pelted Criss, burying his face and his long hair under mounds of whipped cream.

Seeking a more "shameful" punishment, Lizzy took it a step further. They stripped Criss down to his underwear and forced him to his knees. To finish the job, they emptied cans of shaving cream over him until he was completely submerged in white foam. Left shivering and sticky on the floor, one has to wonder... did Criss finally learn his lesson?