11/23/24 - Added AI photos from past attempts from the similar stories and alternate (non-cuck) ending!

Author's Note: Once again needing to drown my sorrows from a loss, I thought it's a perfect opportunity to resurrect this couple. I also added a little cuck-theme at the end that I picked up from other authors here.

******************
It's been 10 years since Becky and I took our pie fights to live TV! I was famously embarrassed on behalf of all Bears fans by taking a bunch of pies in the face when the Packers trounced my team on Sunday Night Football. There was some consolation when they continued the pie series into the playoffs and Becky was pied ruthlessly by a sexy Seahawks fan for the NFC Championship Game. (see The Packers Suck Too!)

So fast forward to now and the Bears are on a 10 game losing streak to the Packers. Good thing I haven't made any bets lately! But we drafted a hot new quarterback for the #1 pick, signed some great receivers, and everything is looking up finally!! So with that momentum and wanting to scratch the itch of my pie in the face kink, I suggested to Becky that we resurrect our pies in the face for the next Bears/Packers Game. Given the recent history, she was amused at my confidence in the Bears.

Things with Becky and me were going great. We did have the occasional pie fight, so plenty of opportunity to get her back in private. We're also monogamish and found some other fun ways to spice things up!

We decided we'd keep similar rules for this game. A pie in the face for every touchdown, a pie to the body for every field goal. With some changes to the extra points/two point conversions lately, we also added that a missed extra point or two point conversion meant you had to throw the pie from 5 feet away. And a made two point conversion made it a two-pie in the face!

We set up in the kitchen where we could see the TV. Knowing how to get me going, Becky blew out her long, thick brunette hair, wore her push up bra under her Love jersey, which sat nicely over her shapely ass in a short denim skirt. I had on my new Williams jersey and grey sweatpants - yup, she's a grey sweatpants girl! I proceeded to put up the tarps during the halftime show while Becky made the 15 cool whip pies. We don't know how many scoring plays there will be, but we agreed that the winner also gets to deliver an extra pie to the loser, and all the remaining after the game pies are thrown.

"I'm surprised you're so confident, Jeff", Becky teased. "I mean, 10 games in a row! The Bears have been riding the Loser Train for quite a while. I should at least get to throw 10 pies in your face for each of those games!"

"You wish, Becky!" I retorted. "We're finally coming back and we're gonna take it to the house with our new quarterback! I'm going to really get you back, Ms. Packer Fan."

Becky picked up a pie and sauntered over to me. "Mmmm, I don't know it's gonna feel so good when I smash this pie in your face later." She bit her lip like she couldn't wait to pie me! "Don't worry baby," I said as I confidently got closer to her. "I'll go easy on you with all these." She scoffed, "don't even think about it! I'm gonna win. And make you the loser." As we stared competitively at each other, I reached around her, squeezed her ass and brought her in to me for a deep kiss. As she pulled away she said, "Mmmmmmmm, I can tell you're getting excited all ready", as she patted the front of my sweatpants. "Better watch out for all the cream today loser," I replied to her laughter.

Once the kitchen was ready and the pies were made, we sat down on the couch together to watch the game. There may have been more handsies back and forth as the game kicked off.

First quarter:

Well, it didn't take long for the Packers to jump out to an early lead with a touchdown. 7-0 and one pie to my face. "Better settle in and get used to it!" Becky celebrated.

But then after a long drive, the Bears responded with a field goal (7-3). "At least I'll get to show you what I think of that Love jersey!" I said as Becky rolled her eyes.

Second quarter:

The second quarter was a bit long and methodical, but I was pleased that the Bears scored a touchdown. 10-7. "YES!" I celebrated. That's 1 pie in each of our faces and 1 to Becky's body.

Third quarter:

The third quarter was a bit more eventful! It started off with a Bears field goal (13-7) and a touchdown by both sides (14-13, 19-14). The bad news was that the Bears missed their two-point conversion. "Haha!" Becky heckled. "We'll see if you have better aim!"

Going into the 4th Quarter, it's 2 pies to Becky's face (one thrown), and 2 pies to her body. And 2 pies to my face.

Fourth Quarter:

After a long back and forth, the Packers finally scored as we knew they would. But they missed the two-point conversion, so it's just a thrown pie. "A third pie and the lead - meaning a fourth pie when I win!" Becky was so pleased, she stood and did a little dance to show off. God her ass looked good!

The Bears started to march down the field in response. Down by only 1! A field goal wins! A few great catches set up the game winning field goal as they run down the clock.

"Let's get ready in the kitchen," I excitedly encouraged. Becky reluctantly followed me in. "A lot can happen - we're still winning," Becky jeered. "Let me just get this ready" I said as I picked up a cream pie. I mimed pieing her in the face like she did earlier. She gave me a look like "you wouldn't dare", which I found SO sexy. "You're gonna get so creamed!" I kept going.

The thing I knew, they were kicking the field goal, but I couldn't see the ball. I stood there dumbfounded as the refs waved the 'no good' sign. Becky yelled "we blocked it!!" I waited for confirmation as my mouth fell open. We lost AGAIN? Becky looked at me and started laughing. I couldn't believe it. We were so close!!

"Well, I guess you won't be needing this!" Becky exclaimed as she took the pie out of my hand. She didn't wait and immediately slammed the pie in my face. I barely had time to close my mouth! "Oooooh, yeeaaaaahhhhhh" she teased as she rubbed the pie around my face. "Feels good to deliver this defeat to you again!" She let the pie tin drop as she continued laughing at my fate. I slowly turned toward her and cleared my eyes. This gorgeous wife of mine was taking so much pleasure in my unending humiliation.

"I bet it feels worse knowing you were SO CLOSE!" she teased. Making an inch with her fingers, she added like, you were this close to getting to throw all these pies at me!" She laughed again. "Yeah, you know, I have expected this," I responded dejectedly. "But I still get to throw some of these pies at you!"

"Oh right, with your points, you get to give me 2 pies in the face and 2 pies to my body. And one of those pies has to be thrown!" Becky counted. "Meanwhile I," she emphasized, "get to throw 3 pies in your face, and 1 has to be thrown. That's on top of the 1 I already smashed in your face, and don't I get to decide what happens to the rest??" Becky gave me a mischievous look. "There's SEVEN pies left after our little tit for tat." "Oh great" I added, although I was already starting to get aroused.

From there, Becky picked up two more pies and proceeded to slam each of them in face, one at a time. She paused between them for effect and so that I'd clean my eyes. "I want you to see me do this" she said. So hot! Then, she picked up her third pie. She turned around and, giving her booty a shake, proceeded to walk back a few paces while I stood there. I started to rub my cock over my sweatpants with the cream accumulating on my hands.

"Uh uh" Becky stopped. "No touchy. Put your hands behind your back. I don't want you cumming too early." "Yes baby," I responded as I put my hands behind my back. "Good boy," she said as she smiled. She held up the pie confidently as she inspected it. She gave me a knowing smile as she fixed her long brown hair, giving it some more volume. She tilted her hip to one side, know it was driving me crazy to see her hold that pie. "Are you ready baby?" she asked. "Yes," I responded quietly.

And with that she threw the pie and it landed smack dab in the middle of my face! "Mmm, looks like I have better aim than your kicker." she teased. I slowly removed the cream from my eyes and face. I picked up a pie of my own, walked over to her and said, "now it's my turn." Then I smushed the pie in her face and gave it a heavy twist. She let out a muffled cry. As I let the pie tin drop she said, "oooh you're bad."

"That's just the start!" I responded. I grabbed two more pies. The first one I smashed all over the front of her jersey. I really let the numbers have it! She started cleaning off her face and I could see her smile as I rubbed the pie all around each breast. I love to cup each breast in the pie tin.

I took the second pie and spun her around and smashed it on the back of her denim skirt. After rubbing it around, I pulled up her skirt and got a little cream underneath for good measure. As I let it go, I pulled out my already hard cock from the sweatpants. I pulled her close so she could feel my raging hard-on against her ass. " oh someone's excited already." And we shared a deep kiss as her hands slid down and started stroking me slowly.

"Mmmm, one more!" I stopped her. "Yeah, but you have to throw it like I did," she added. So I grabbed a pie and stood back a few feet and admired my sexy wife. Fuck, she looked so good with a pie in her face and Cool Whip covering her front and back.
"Don't get used to it!" she jeered, as she confidently stuck her face out towards me. "I've still got all of these" she added, gesturing to the rest of the pies. She stuck her tongue out and said, "because we all know, the Bears still suck!"

At that, I launched the pie at her face, but in the excitement I sent it a little too hard and high. I really wanted to smack that girl in the face with that pie! But unfortunately, it only caught the top left of her face and splattered on the wall behind her

"Awwww you poor thing! But that aim is a really good way to honor your team today, hahaha! Sucks to be you!" Becky was just relishing in her taunts! She cleaned a little bit of cream off the top of her face and out of her eye. "I know how badly you wanna throw the rest of these pies in my face. Sucks for you to be a loser again. So Bear Down and get on your knees again! Arms behind your back!"

I did what I was told. She was the dominant winner again. "Seven pies! What am I going to do with them?" she joked. Becky picked up the first pie and walked slowly towards me and looking so proud of herself. "I think the first thing I should do is show you how to throw a proper pie since you can't seem to do it." She gave me a pouty look signaling my poor pie throwing skills. And with that she smashed that pie in my face and rubbed it all around. "Oh yeah!!! Taste the defeat. This is how you do it," she playfully taunted.

"But that's not throwing the pie" I said a little teasingly. "Oh, you want me to throw it?" she mocked. Becky stood back and grabbed another pie. She held it up like a pissed off waitress. "Okay, you asked for it!" she exclaimed as she launched the pie straight at my face and smacking me dead center once again.

"Hahaha oh you poor thing! You can't even talk shit without getting pied!" Becky was so enjoying my humiliation. "Getting hungry?" she asked. She picked up two more pies and came back over to me still kneeling in front of her. "Do you want a sandwich?" I knew what this mean. "Yes baby."

"Great!" Then she gently brought the pies to either side of my face and turned my head into a giant pie filling and cream covered mess. She rubbed it around from the sides to the front and back and wiped it all off as she brought them up over my head. "MMMM", Becky taunted again. "So good! And three left! What should I do?... I know, stand up!"

My cock was still out from earlier, and it was raging from not being able to touch it and having all the pie cream fall over it. Becky grabbed another pie and held it low by my dick. Holding it in two hands, she looked up at me with a mockingly sad face, knowing what she was about to do. After a couple seconds, she two handedly smashed that pie under and up my cock. She held it there and rubbed it around with a knowing smile, with how badly I wanted to cum right then.

"No, no no loser boy, you don't get to come yet" Becky teased. "I still have two more pies to deliver." So she dropped the pie tin and left me standing there. She denied my impending orgasm from that cock pie! Becky picked up the last two pies. "This is it, the moment of truth!"

She had mostly cleaned herself off by now. Still needing a shower but it was just streaks of Cool Whip on her outfit now and framing her hair. "11 games in a row! I hope this teaches you to once and for all stop putting yourself in this position to be humiliated!"

I responded with, "You'll get your comeuppance and I'll get you back, baby! Mark my words!" Smirking with satisfaction she said, "Well that's not today!" and she slammed that first pie in my face and rubbed it around. "Nope you'll continue to suffer these defeats at my hands."

As I cleaned out my eyes, I saw her switch the last pie to her dominant hand. "Are you ready, baby?" She asked mockingly. I didn't answer so she said again, "Are you ready?"
"Yes", I said quietly. "Yes, what?" she added. "Yes, please."
"Yes, please you want this pie? Don't you?" she continued teasing.
"Yes, I do. Please give it to me."
"You want me to give you this last pie?"
"Yes, please I want that pie."
"You want it? You want me to give it to you?"
"Yes baby, I want you to give me that pie."
Becky grabbed my cock and started stroking it.
"Okay baby, I'll give you the pie when you finish asking nicely. So I'll ask you again." She pumped harder and faster, all while staring me in the face, and knowing how turned on I was.
"Yes, please, baby, please give me that pie."
------see below for alternate ending------

At this point she smashed the pie in my face and continued stroking my cock so that as she rubbed it around my face, I started to cum.
"Oh, you naughty boy!... it's too bad you couldn't hold it in yourself. I was going to let you fuck me in this! Bend me over my skirt and throw me around in all this cream. But I guess that's for winners."
I felt a little let down and spent. But not too bad because she's so fuckin hot when she makes me cum like that!
"Oh well I'm going to go shower."
I sat down in a nearby chair and started to come around from my intense orgasm. I started to get aroused again watching her finish wiping herself with paper towels. She looked back at me satisfied at the mess she left me in.

"I feel great baby, thank you for that" I trailed off feeling so relaxed, but messy. "Give me a little bit and I'll see about bending you like you wanted."

She finished checking her phone. "Oh, didn't I tell you? I have a date tonight!"
"Oh really??"
"Yeah sorry! I forgot to tell you about him. His name is Patrick and he's actually a Packer fan too. He's pretty jazzed about beating the Bears again! And he knows you're a Bears fan. So we're going to go out and have a celebratory drink. After all this taking charge, I'm looking forward to getting a good fucking."

I couldn't believe it! Yes I was spent but I still wanted to fuck her! I watched as she started to walk to the shower leaving me in a puddle of mess and jizz.

Becky turned back and giggled, "oh yeah, Patrick wanted me to tell you, the Bears Still Suck."


*******************************************
11/23/24 - Okay, I didn't like the cuck ending. I've fantasized about it but really with the idea of being the bull. Because these characters hit so close to home, I needed a new ending.


She then smashed the pie in my face and continued stroking my cock harder and faster. She rubbed it around my face for a few seconds and I could feel myself edging closer to orgasm. Becky stopped stroking and squeezed my throbbing cock, and she paused with the pie tin on my face. She leaned close to me and taunted, "Mmmmm, it's too bad the Bears Still Suck, and I don't!" She opened her hands to let go of my edged member and drop the pie tin. She laughed aloud to herself at the state I was in.

"Oh you naughty thing," I said as I started to move again. My dick felt so close yet yearning for more.
"Thought you'd like that," Becky said proudly as I cleared the pie from my face.

"Mmmm, you're bad now come here!" I said as I reached out for her. She tried to move away but I got her quickly in a bear hug. She tried to playfully fight me off, to no avail. She lightly screamed as I covered her in all the cool whip I had on me.

In the struggle we slipped and fell to the floor. "Ooh baby" I said as we laughed and rolled around. I was getting even more turned on. She was giggling as cool whip was getting all over her skirt and jersey, even her thick brunette hair. She looked delicious! In the fun I reached under her skirt and pulled down her underwear. After getting them off around her feet, I flipped her over on her stomach and on her hands and knees. My cock still throbbing from earlier and wrestling around in all the cream.

She looked back at me, and I could see strands of uncovered brown hair wild around her half-plastered face. She gave me a look that said, 'I'm ready.' I look down her body, at her cream covered jersey and denim skirt. Becky was so sexy and begging to be fucked. So I didn't waste any time bringing to dick closer to her pussy, and you could feel the magnetic pull of our genitals coming together. I slid inside her and she let out an excited moan. My cold cock immediately warmed by her wet pussy. I basked in the sensation, and then started thrusting hard. I grabbed her waist and pounded her over and over. She screamed in ecstasy and started falling back into the pie cream. I pushed her down and got deeper inside her. She screamed again, burying her face into the cream. I could feel her pussy clench around my cock, which triggered an explosive orgasm. Becky pulled her face up, flushed with her mouth open. Breathlessly she said "I can feel you cumming" as she started writhing around. I had to hold her tighter to my pelvis so I wouldn't slip out and could finish giving her this extra special cream pie of my own. Even though my team sucks, I still finish the big winner. And her too.