(continued from Lauren's Story - Chapter 10...)

Lauren stayed true to her word and agreed to go on a date with Sarah's friend, David. But that didn't stop her from having Chris over a few times during the next week. The date with David was scheduled for Saturday night and when the night came, Lauren decided to tone back her sexy a little bit. It was, after all, a first date. They met at what Lauren had always thought was a sports bar.
As their date progressed, David and Lauren talked and laughed, and laughed and talked. Unlike her first date with Chris, Lauren wasn't drinking to pass the time she drank because she was enjoying David's company. He was smart, funny, and very cute, although not near as muscular as Chris. But he was a lot more fun to sit around and talk to. She learned he was a cameraman for the local ABC station news and that he liked brunettes better than blondes.
Lauren was trying to keep things going slow as she had made that mistake many times before. So, the night ended once he paid the check and she kissed him on the cheek. She got into her car and headed back towards the apartment. "Have to make one stop..."
When she did finally make it back, she sent Sarah a text. "If you want to know what happened you need to come over to my place immediately." Lauren thought that Sarah might have already talked with David but she knew she wouldn't be able to resist her invitation.
A few moments later, Sarah texted back, "On my way."
"Perfect," Lauren thought to herself.
About 5 minutes passed until Sarah rang Lauren's doorbell. Lauren waited a minute, just because she felt like Sarah had always done that to her, and cracked the door open. "Hello?" She whispered out to Sarah.
"Come on Lauren, open the door. You're the one that wanted me to come over."
And with that, Lauren pulled the door wide open and proceeded to slam a big chocolate cream pie into Sarah's face. The pie dropped down onto Sarah's sports bra, which was all she was wearing to cover up her "assets." Lauren smeared it all over her blonde hair then finished the pie off on her sports bra. Lauren then stepped back and took a picture with her phone. "Hi Sarah."
She pulled Sarah inside the apartment and closed the door.
"Why did you do that?" Sarah asked, scraping the pie out of her eyes, wiping it onto her yoga pants.
"Well...two reasons. First, because I've been wanting to surprise you for a while. Second, because I wanted to actually thank you for setting up the date with David. We might be compatible"
"Told you so."
"See, it's that kind of attitude that caused you to get a pie before I told you."
"Ok, if it went so well, why are you already back home?"
"I'm trying to act like a normal adult for a change, so I'm taking it slow. We are going to go out for lunch next week. Just trying to get to know each other better."
"Wow! That actually sounds reasonable."
"Weird, isn't it?" Lauren said as she scooped a finger full of pie from Sarah's face and licked her finger clean.
"So now what?"
"Time to get you out of those messed up clothes." Lauren then leaned over and pulled lifted off Sarah's sports bra. Sarah kicked off her shoes and socks and peeled herself out of her yoga pants, leaving her standing there covered in pie and wearing only her favorite white thong panties. "You look pretty good. Now there's one more thing I need to do in order to show you my thanks."
Lauren took Sarah's hand and pulled her into the kitchen which was covered by the tarp that she had purchased on her way home from the date. She sat Sarah down in a chair sitting in the middle of the room and immediately tied her hands to the chair behind her back. "This is new," Sarah said out loud. Lauren then spread open Sarah's legs and tied them to each side of the chair, leaving her completely exposed. "I'm shocked but also very intrigued." Sarah said while still licking the pie from around her lips.
Lauren walked over to her fridge, behind where Sarah could see, and pulled a pitcher of ice water. She poured it directly over Sarah's head and she screamed when the ice cold water hit her. "I've already done the ice bucket challenge." She said once she caught her breath.
"Oh, I'm so sorry. Let me see if I have any other options." She opened up the pantry and picked up an old bottle of cooking oil she almost never used. Lauren unscrewed the top and poured it out over Sarah's face and breasts. Her skin, which had lots of goose bumps from the ice water, now was slick and shiny. Once the bottle was emptied, Lauren ran her hands all over Sarah's body, spending considerable time running her fingers over Sarah's nipples. Sarah was starting to relax again, so Lauren stopped and went back to the fridge. She pulled out a large bowl of oatmeal. "Seems I made more than I was hungry for this morning, so you get to have the leftovers," Lauren said dumping the contents of the bowl over Sarah. This time Lauren used the big metal spoon to spread the oatmeal around, eventually ending up sliding the spoon just into Sarah's pussy. The spoon was cold from being in the fridge and Sarah jumped again, struggling a little bit to get undone from the ropes.
"How much more until you untie me?" Sarah asked.
"Well, I need to know a few things...First, how much did you tell everyone else about the first pies that we shared? And then everything that happened after that?"
"I...I...I just told them you came over for my birthday for a drink. That's all."
"How did everyone find out about the night I had in the rain and mud?"
"Same story. I just told them we drank too much and you left before James could give you a ride home."
"Just so you know...I asked James how I could make sure you were telling the truth...And he gave me a few things to try." Lauren said walking back to the pantry.
"What did he tell you? He's going to get it when I get home."
"Oh, he knows not to wait up. We've already talked." As Lauren responded she grabbed another bucket from the pantry floor. She had never even tasted this substance before but James had said that it was definitely not one of Sarah's favorites. She walked over to Sarah and didn't let her see inside the bucket but she could definitely smell it.
"Molasses...ugh!"
"So, are you telling me all of the truth about what you told the other ladies?"
"Yes!"
"I'm just not completely 100% convinced yet..." And with that Lauren dumped the bucket over Sarah's head. The thick molasses slowly covered Sarah's head and body. Lauren had to admit the smell was not great. It was going to take a lot of air freshener to get her to step back in her kitchen after this. The molasses just stuck to her everywhere. As the last of it dripped out of the bucket, Sarah threw her head around, throwing molasses all over Lauren's kitchen and Lauren. "That was not nice. I was going to stop but now I have to go to the next step."
"No, I'm sorry. We can stop now."
"If only..." and Lauren walked back to the pantry for the last item she had purchased for the night. She pulled it out of the grocery bag and set it on the counter, all where Sarah couldn't see. She opened it up, smiled, and walked over behind the chair that Sarah was tied to. As she looked over Sarah's molasses covered head and body she started to feel bad. Maybe she should stop.
"Go ahead, get it over with. I have a good idea what you've got so you better be ready for a 2 hour shower with me. We're going to use all of the hot water in the complex to get this out."
"I could think of worse places to spend two hours." Lauren said as she lifted up the 5 pound bag of flour over Sarah and let it rain down onto the sticky molasses. She came around the front of the chair and made sure her breasts got a good coating and then just filled in anywhere she could see molasses. When the bag was empty, Sarah was a big white glob. Lauren ran and grabbed her camera to get the picture she had promised James.
"James told me if I was really mad at you I should just do this and walk away, leaving everything to harden on you...But I'm not mad, I'm really happy you set me up with what seems to be a really great guy. I'm going to untie your ropes now. Be nice to me."
Lauren untied the ropes and Sarah quickly stood up out of the chair, stretching her arms and legs that had been tied up for what seemed like forever.
"Just so you know, I was going to do some other things to you after the flour, and those things were going to be much nicer. But James kind of scared me about leaving the flour on too long. So, maybe we should just head to the shower?" Lauren said to Sarah using her sweetest voice.
"Wait a minute, you don't even need a shower. You did all of this to me and I get to do nothing to you? After I hooked you up with a great guy? That's not right. Get out of those clothes and sit down in the chair...right now" Suddenly Sarah became forceful. Lauren couldn't tell if she was serious but she didn't want to take any chances, so she stripped and sat down in the chair.
Sarah tied her up and started looking through Lauren's fridge and pantry. "There's a sheet cake in the fridge!"
"Yes, that was one of the nicer things I was going to do for you. Have you sit on it and I would go down on you."
"That would have been nice, but I'm a big white flour blob, so this is what's going to happen with it..." Sarah slammed the cake from behind Lauren into her face and smeared it all over her naked body. Sarah went back to the fridge and pulled out a 1/2 gallon carton of milk. She dumped it over Lauren's head and Lauren screamed when it hit her skin. She had no idea what was coming.
Next she grabbed the jar of peanut butter from the pantry, looked in the fridge and pulled out the bottle of grape jelly. She grabbed a spoon out of the sink and scooped out a big glob of peanut butter onto Lauren's left breast, smearing it all over her nipple. Lauren kind of enjoyed that. Next Sarah scooped out a glob of jelly and put it in the same fashion all over the other breast. "PB&J breasts!"
"Are we done now? I'm worried about the flour," Lauren asked.
"Look at me, look at you, we are not even close to being done." Sarah walked back to the pantry looking for a few finishing touches. She pulled out a half empty bottle of pancake syrup and poured it all over Lauren from the waist down. Next she looked at Lauren's hair and realized that it was still mostly intact. She reached in the fridge and pulled out the bottle of balsamic vinaigrette. She took off the lid and rubbed the salad dressing all into Lauren's hair.
"Gross!" Lauren yelled as some dripped down through the cake frosting to her mouth.
"You have a lot to learn, young one." Sarah said laughing. "Time for the final lesson." She went back over to the fridge and opened up the freezer. She grabbed a fruit rocket popsicle and unwrapped it. She walked over in front of Lauren and took a long lick of the popsicle.
"What is that for?"
"This," and as she responded she slid the rocket shaped popsicle into Lauren's pussy. She screamed because of the shock of the cold in that area and desperately fought to get out of the ropes. Sarah kept moving the popsicle around in what felt like an already very wet area. In fact it was so wet and warm that the popsicle was melting. Sarah had to keep going deeper with the popsicle stick. There was fruit juice and Lauren juice flowing from her pussy and Sarah decided popsicle time was over, pulling the stick out of Lauren. She showed the empty stick to Lauren then bent down to get a good taste of what was happening down there.
Lauren was overwhelmed and came almost immediately when Sarah's tongue entered her. She leaned back in the chair, as Sarah stood up. "Can we shower now?" Sarah asked smiling.