Home Coming Bakeoff Part 3
by KakeKid

"Charlie is this turning you on?!" Ally said as she had noticed a large bulge in the front of Charlie's pants that was totally pointless to try and hide because he was so aroused. Ally and Erica then looked at each other with a smirk and knew exactly what to do. Ally slowly walked over to Erica while holding the massive cream pie and placed one of her arms around Erica's shoulder. Erica and Ally stood side by side, Ally with her arm around Erica's shoulders and Erica holding a deep thick cake directly in front of her creamy face.
Ally then said with a playful questioning face "Is watching us hit each other with pies turning you on?"

Charlie simply nodded with a slight bashful look on his face.
Ally continued with her setup "So your telling me if I do this..." Ally then shifted her hand that was on Erica's shoulders to behind her head and with her other hand she smashed the creamy pie straight into Erica's face. Erica just stood there still holding the cake out in front of her not making the slightest gesture that she was resisting her facial treatment. "...would turn you on?" Ally said as she twisted the pie into Erica's face.

Charlie let out a slight gasp at the sight of Ally eyeing him with her sexy smirk and those luscious lips while she held Erica's face deep in the pie.Just as Ally dropped the pie tin away form Erica's face Erica said

"So your telling us Charlie if I did this...." Erica removed one of her hands from under the cake and placed it behind Ally's head. Then she lowered the cake to about waist level then forced Ally's face down towards the pie with noticeable force. Ally's head impacted with the cake making a satisfying *thud* and *Squish*. "...it would turn you on?" Erica asked as she picked up another cake on the edge of a near by table and brought it down hard on the back of Ally's submerged head making a complete and total cake sandwich out of Ally's head.

"Yes" Charlie said weakly, he could barely control himself at this point.Charlie noticed one of Ally's hands creep between her legs and began to massage herself while she enjoyed the feeling of having her face encased in cake and frosting. This had Charlie slowly rubbing his already erect dick as he watched the scene unfold in front of him.
Ally straightened up and both girls cleared their face's of cake and cream. Ally raised a sexy eyebrow and licked her lips when she saw how excited Charlie had begun. She couldn't wait to have that cock in her mouth but first she had some more teasing and a little something special in mind for Charlie.

Ally then moved a chair over behind Erica and placed a strawberry pie on the chair. Erica made a comically worried face as Ally placed both hands on her shoulders and forced Erica to sit hard into the Strawberry pie. Erica let out a *squeak* in surprise at the feeling of cream shooting up into her pussy and as pie filling shot out past her clit. She made sure to keep her legs spread so Charlie could get a full view of her creamy pussy.

"Charlie would you like a pie?" Ally asked, even though she already knew the answer.

Charlie nodded eagerly as he watched Ally help Erica up and lead her over to the nearest pie filled table. Ally placed a hand on the small of Erica's back and without much effort, slowly bent Erica over the table so her face was about a foot above the table top. Ally ran her hand up Erica's leg and over her round creamy ass and at the top of her booty she lightly flipped up Erica's skirt giving Charlie a full moon. Ally selected a chocolate cream pie and gently removed it from its deep pie tin,then placed it, cream side out, directly over Erica's bent over ass.

"Erica will you hold this please?" Ally asked sweetly.

Erica reached back with her hands and gripped the sides of the pie carefully and held it in place.Ally gestured Charlie to come over by rolling her finger towards her. Charlie slowly walked forward and stopped when he was standing behind Erica bent over the table. He was at the complete mercy of these two women, and he wanted for them to give him a pie more than anything in the world. Ally snapped her fingers and pointed for Charlie to get down on the ground. Charlie complied and got down on his knees and so his face was several inches away from the pie being held over Erica's ass. He was shaking from head to toe in anticipation. He glanced up and saw that Ally had picked up a large banana cream pie from the table that Erica was bent over.

"Well don't just look at it.....eat it!" Ally said then smashed the pie she was holding hard into the back of Charlie's head causing his face to smash hard and directly into the pie that Erica was holding.

Charlie's Face was encased in pie filling and ass cheek, his nose was pressed firmly against Erica's tight little asshole. Charlie began diving his tongue deep into Erica's pussy tasting her creamy filling. Erica began to moan and sigh heavily. She was getting so wet that Charlie could fill it run down his face. Her breathing become more intense and Ally could tell that Charlie was doing that thing he does with his tongue, he obviously had used it on Erica before or she had taught him how too. Ally leaned over and got very close to Erica's ear.

"Do you enjoy having my boyfriend with his tongue inside you?" Erica let out a weak "yes".

Ally then slid a deep pie directly under Erica's face. She then grabbed a fist full of Erica's hair and slowly made her look up away from the pie. Ally licked pie cream away from Erica's lips and kissed her deeply. Their tongues slipped past each over, all the while, Charlie continued to eat out Erica while his face was wedged in her pie filled ass. Ally slid her wet mouth away then gave Erica a wicked grin then slowly forced her to look back down directly into the pie below her face.

Erica knew what was coming next. "No, no, no ,no ,NO ,NO (Her voice getting more excitable since she was fast approaching climax) No not the pie!!!!!" Erica yelled.
Ally then pressed down hard on the back of Erica's head and forced her face into the deep cream pie. Erica orgasismed hard while her face was smothered in cream and pudding. Ally lifted Erica's face out from the pie and watched as Erica spit out a massive amount of pie filling as she blindly glanced towards Ally.

"Thanks" Erica weakly let out. Charlie mean while still had his face pushed into Erica's ass. Ally felt like he had had enough and pulled his face from its creamy tomb. Charlie gasped for breath and sputtered on pudding and cream.Ally lead Charlie over to the chair she had used with Erica earlier and stood him in front of it. She then undid his pants and pulled them and his underwear down around his ankles. She grabbed his erect member in her hand and began to stroke it softly, her hands glided over it due to all the cream that they were covered in.

She gently blew into his ear and whispered "Do you want your rock hard cock to be shoved into my mouth?" Charlie just nodded rapidly as he locked eyes with her. He was so excited about what Ally had said that he failed to notice that Erica had placed a pie on the chair he was standing in front of. Erica then reached over Charlie's shoulders and forced him to sit down into the pie. Suddenly having pie filling shoot up into you ass startled Charlie at first but then he began to enjoy the sensation. Ally then handed him an overflowing Boston cream pie with extra creamy topping. It was so large that Charlie had to use two hands to hold it in front of him.

"What's this for?" Charlie asked with a grin.

"Oh you'll see" Ally replied as she took another pie from Erica who now had become her pie assistant.

Ally then carefully removed the pie from its tin and stuck two fingers into the bottom of the pie through the crust. She made the hole off centered so it was closer to the edge of the pie than the center. She then slipped Charlie's hard dick through the hole she had just made in the pie and rested it in his lap so it was cream side up. Ally looked up and locked eyes with Charlie as see slowly licked a little bit of cream off of the head of his dick. She then placed her mouth over his shaft and opened her her mouth, this was Erica's cue. Erica placed one hand on the back of Ally's head and waited a couple beats just to watch Charlie squirm in anticipation. Then suddenly she pressed down hard and forced Ally's awaiting face hard into the pie and Charlie's dick deep into her throat.

"Oh god!" Charlie yelled, almost losing control as she held him in her mouth.

Ally began to slowly raise and lower her mouth on Charlie's rock hard cock as Erica held on firmly to her hair. As she began to work him harder and faster he felt himself begin to lean forward as he desperately tried to keep from finishing too fast, he wanted to enjoy this for as long as possible. He also began to wonder what the pie he was holding was for, he hoped Ally would let him smash it into her face before he painted it with his own white cream.

"Oh my god, yea keep doing that, right there! I'm going to cum!" Charlie exclaimed. Ally had no intention of letting Charlie bust his load just yet.

At that moment right before Charlie released Ally lifted her mouth off of his dick which caused him to open his mouth in protest but at the same moment, without looking up, Ally placed one of her hands under the pie that Charlie was holding and shoved it hard into Charlie's face. Not only was Charlie still in shock from getting denied of his blow job climax but he now had his face shoved deep into a pie which he had smashed into his own face! All he could hear is the laughter of both girls at the sight of him holding the pie in his own face.

"Oh Ally! You are terrible!" Erica laughed as she caressed Ally's pie filled hair. Ally stood up and kissed Erica gently again.

"Time for the big finale" Ally said as she walked over to Charlie, who still had the pie held in his own face.

"Let me help you with that babe." Ally said as she lowered the pie from Charlie's face.
She then instructed him to sit on the ground in front of the chair he was sitting on currently. Ally then straddled Charlie's rock hard cock and slowly lowered herself onto him. Charlie let out a gasp at the sensation of Ally's tight wet pussy being slowly lowered onto his erect member. Erica walked over to Charlie and pressed firmly against his forehead until his head rested on the seat of the chair he was sitting in front of.

"Can I sit on your face Charlie" Erica asked, Charlie just nodded vigorously.

Erica then walked over to a near by table and selected a large Chocolate cake, she then slipped both hands under the cake between the cake itself and the glass tray it was sitting on. Erica gently lifted the cake up, holding the sticky confection in her bare hands keeping the cake's structure in tact. When she turned around she lowered the cake just above Charlie's face.

"Oh my.." was all that Charlie was able to get out before Erica dropped the cake onto Charlie's face.

She then turned around and dropped her pied booty firmly onto the cake. Erica twisted and turn slightly until she felt Charlie's nose and mouth rub against her pussy and bootyhole.

Meanwhile Ally was bucking back and forth and she climaxed on Charlie's dick. She could feel that he was close to finishing again. Ally would let him cum this time but with a slight twist. Again Ally jumped off Charlie's dick right before he came and grabbed a near by pie, she then proceeded to jerk him off quickly. A groan could be heard from under the cake that Erica was currently sitting on. Ally placed the pie in the path of Charlie's hot cum as he jerked and bucked under Ally's grasp. Erica's eyes got wide.

"Is that a cum pie you have there Ally?!" Erica said as she licked her lips.

"It is and its all mine!" Ally placed both hands under the pie getting ready to smash it into her own face.

"Awwww but I want to hit you with that pie! Please let me do it!"

"You really want to pie me with this pie" Ally asked

"Yes yes please! It gets me so wet thinking about smashing a gooey cum pie into your beautiful face!" Erica said as she slowly fingered her clit.

"So you want me to give you this pie then?" Ally asked with a wicked grin.

"Yes! Come on now! I can't wait any more! Give me that pie!" Erica yelled

Almost immediately as Erica had said the last statement she knew what her fate would be. The creamy cum pie Ally held was projected forward straight into Erica's face. Erica simply held her ground and scrunched up her face at the last second as the pie impacted her face. Ally twisted and turned the pie to make sure to get maximum coverage, Erica just sat there and moaned with pleasure as pie filling and cum was pushed deep into her face. At this time Erica stood up giving Charlie a gasp of air before she dropped her hips back down to smother his face once again.

"This has been fun, when are we doing it again?" Ally asked EricaErica slowly wiped her eyes clean as she licked her lips.

"What are you doing this weekend?" Erica asked with a smirk.

Both girls embraced in another passionate kiss as they contemplated what kinds of pieing they would do to each other come the weekend.