Home Coming Bake Off 4 Don't get cocky!
By KakeKid

It had been 2 months since that fateful night before the Home Coming bake off. Ally and Erica had since become best of friends and did everything together, including Charlie. Charlie had become one of the luckiest guys on the planet. Having sex with two of the hottest girls in the area AND slamming pies and cakes into their faces while he did it, things were going very well for Charlieuntil he became a bit cocky.

See Charlie started to talk, and talk A LOT about his little escapades with Ally and Erica. Telling people about how much of a stud he was banging two smoking hot chicks. He discreetly left out the whole part of having a pie fight while he got his brains fucked out and good thing he did or else the series of events that were about to unfold would have been much, much worse.

How this all came about was Charlie was on the football field talking loudly about how his parents were out of town on business and he had come home to Ally and Erica waiting for him. He said that they were both in catholic school girl uniforms and took turns blowing him as if they were fighting over a lollypop. What he left out of course is that while they went down on him he would sandwich their heads with massive cream pies. While he was explaining how he gets to nail these girls all the time one of the other cheerleaders, an underclassman on Ally's squad, over heard all this talk and of course wanting to suck up to the Cheer Captain immediately went and told Ally everything she had heard. This girl's name was Mindy.

Mindy was 5'10, long gorgeous legs, red hair like you've never seen before and had breasts that you just wanted to burry your face into. This girl was a 10 and she knew it. Mindy was the obvious choice for the next Cheer Captain, she was an excellent cheerleader, smoking hot, and most important of all she sucked up to Ally. This of course did not make her the most popular girl on the team and many of the other cheerleaders would love nothing more than to get revenge on her for her constant tattling to Ally whenever the other girls broke a rule of talked ill of Ally (Trust me, well get to that story another time).

Mindy found Ally in the girls locker room showering after practice, Mindy wasn't really into girls that way but looking at Ally's tight curved body glistening in the shower even made her a bit damp. Mindy quickly regained her focus and got Ally's attention. "Oh my god, you are not going to believe what I just heard Charlie talking about with the football team!" Mindy exclaimed. She then proceeded to tell Ally everything she had heard Charlie talk about and watched Ally's face slowly become more and more furious.

"So he wants to brag huh? Well I think we should teach him a lesson." Ally said with a wicked grin. Mindy loved to make Ally happy and wanted nothing more than to help with punishing Charlie; even though Mindy had an enormous crush on him but of course she would never ever let Ally know that. Ally pulled out her cell phone. "

"Hey Erica You'll never believe this! Charlie thinks its ok to run his mouth about our little sessions." Ally pauses "I know! Well what are you doing tonight? I have something in mind that should remind him that he isn't as cool as he thinks he is."
Ally hung up the phone and turned to Mindy, "Ok its set, meet at my house around 8 pm tonight. Oh and bring that French maid costume that you wore on Halloween." Ally grinned as she thought about the fun and punishment that was to come for the evening. Mindy on the other hand noticed that she got just the slightest bit damp thinking about what she was going to get to do to Charlie, hell maybe at the end they girls will let him take some revenge on them! Mindy of course had no clue as to what was in store for both her and Charlie that evening.

Mindy was instructed to show up at Ally's house around 7:30 to make sure that she was ready to go and help with the "set up?" whatever that was. Mindy was in black pumps with 5 inch heels and a cute black trench coat that just barely covered the bottom of the French maid outfit that she had on. She knocked on the door and waited patiently while looking around hoping that no one would notice her in her sexy shoes and fishnet leggings. Erica answered the door wearing a similar French maid costume, her skirt obviously much, MUCH shorter. This girl had always been known to have a booty but OH my god! Mindy couldn't help but admire how sexy Erica looked. There were a lot of weird feelings going on in Mindy's head lately.

"Oh good you're here, we are just about finished up. Oh wow you look fantastic! You're tits look amazing in that costume! Well Charlie will be here soon so go on into the formal dining room and see if Ally needs help with anything." Erica said with a wink.

"What exactly are we going to do to Charlie tonight?" Mindy asked with a shy smile.

"Oh dearAlly didn't tell you did she?! What a devious little bitch. Well you are in for some surprises and fun tonight. Now go on and find Ally." Erica gave Mindy a slight little pat on the ass and made the smallest little squeeze of her butt check that raised Mindy's eyebrows and made her even more curious as what was in store for her this evening.

"What was she talking about?" Mindy wondered. She walked down the hallway her heels clicking slowly on the dark hardwood floors. She rounded the corner to the Formal Dining room and could not even process what she was looking at. The center of the room had a long oak dining table with 8 chairs along it with nothing on it. The rest of the room was tables and carts loaded withpies and cakes? Mandy didn't understand. She saw Ally standing to the side of the table holding a massive cream pie like a waitress.

"So, you are probably wondering what all these pies and cakes are doing here?" Ally said with a smirk.
Mindy just stood and stared she still didn't fully process what was going on. She knew that Erica, Ally, and Charlie were all sleeping with each other, but what in the hell were all these pies for? Did they get a sweet tooth afterwards she wondered? Ally walked toward Mindy still holding the pie with a mischievous grin on her face.

"Mindy, have you have been hit in the face with a pie? Or had your head slammed down into a cake?" Ally questioned Mindy.

"Uhhh no I can't say that I have." Mindy was looking back and forth between the pie and Ally now worried as to what Ally might do with such a massive creamy weapon.

"Well when Charlie gets here, you just play your part. I promise you'll have a blast!" Ally replied and with that she turned around bent over and set the pie down revealing that she was not wearing any panties. It was going to be one of those nights huh? This could get very interesting Mindy thought to herself. She had always wanted to fuck Charlie, but again she would never dream of betraying Ally.

30 minutes later Charlie arrives.

Charlie arrived right when Ally had told him to. He began to knock on the door but there was no answer. He tried the door handle and noticed that the door was unlocked. As Charlie walked into the entryway of the house he immediately could smell baked goods and hear the recognizable sound of heels walking on hardwood floors. He immediately began to get hard knowing that those two clues together meant that he was in for a tasty surprise. Charlie followed the sounds of the clicking heels towards Ally's dining room. When he rounded the corner his jaw dropped, all along two walls opposite of each other were several tables packed to their edges with cream pies, large deep cakes, and a couple massive sheet cakes that looked like they had double frosting applied to them. His eyes then wandered over to the long dining table in the center of the room where Erica sat on the edge of the table with her feet dangling off and her legs spread. In between her legs standing up was Ally; In her left hand she held a thick cream pie like a waitress, and her right hand was dipping a finger into the pie and slowly letting Erica lick it off. Both girls wore matching French maid outfits with their hair up in sexy buns, white stockings with a small black bow at the top, and skirts at would easily show off their ass if they bent over. Ally held the pie just in front of Erica's face while she let her suck the cream off her finger. Ally then turned to Charlie, blew him a kiss and winked at him, then turned back to Erica, placed a hand on the back of her head, waited a couple seconds just to drive Charlie crazy, then pulled Erica in for a deep passionate kiss. Ally then set the pie down as Erica hopped off the table, both girls began to walk over to Charlie who just stood there admiring how smoking hot these two girls were.

"We are so glad you could make it over here tonight Charlie, Erica and I have a problem and we don't know how to resolve it." Ally said as Erica and her lead Charlie over to the chair at the foot of the table each girl on one of his arms.

"Well what seems to be the problem girls?" Charlie asked as took a seat with Ally and Erica standing to each side.

"Ally and I have been baking these pies and cakes allll day long and she said that her pies were better than mine!" Erica said with a pout looking at Ally.

"My pies and cakes ARE better than yours, they are more fluffy, creamy, and they TASTE better too!" Allyson said as a matter of fact.
Erica turned around to the table behind her and grabbed the closest chocolate cream pie to her with two hands since it was so big.

"No way! Just look at this pie I made! Look how much pie cream is on top of that! It must weigh 5 pounds! AND not only does it look amazing but it tastes amazing too!" Erica exclaimed as she help the pie out a little ways in front of her like she was presenting it to Ally. Ally took the cue and leaned in close to the pie to inspect it. Charlie held his breath in anticipation, he expected to see Erica smash the cream pie right into Ally's face and an all-out pie fight-fuck fest would follow. But Ally just inspected the pie for a couple moments while Erica waited patiently and the leaned back away from the pie.

"I'm not impressed." Ally stated. Erica put on a face of mock shock and indignation.

"Now this is a real pie" Ally said as she selected a banana cream pie that was closest to her. She then held the pie out towards Erica directly in front of Charlie's face but much lower than Erica had held her pie. Then Erica bent at the waste and held her face just over the pie. Charlie immediately tensed up thinking that the moment had come, the anticipation was KILLING him. But again Erica just held her face over the pie, seemed unimpressed as well then stood back up as Ally withdrew the pie.

"I STILL think my pies are better!" Erica almost yelled.

"No way! You are nuts! MY pies are better!" Ally shouted back.

"Mine are better!" Erica yelled

"Screw you! Your pies are the worst! Mine are ten times better!" Ally looked almost pissed.
"There is no way your pies are better than mine!" Erica said with an insulted tone. At this point Erica raised her pie in one hand as if she was ready to deck Ally right in the face with it.

"I've been listening to you talk about how much better your stupid pies are than mine all day long, and now it's time to shut you up!" Ally yelled at Erica as she lifted her own pie into the classic retaliation pie throw stance.
Charlie could barely contain himself, he was rock hard under the table and kept looking back and forth between these two smoking hot girls who were poised to begin to start smashing pies into each other's faces. He couldn't decide in his head who he wanted to see hit first? Erica or Ally? OH! Or maybe they hit each other at the same time! He loved it when they did that.

Each girl held the pose glaring at each other ready to strike, then suddenly lowered their pies and changed their entire demeanor and turn to look at Charlie.

"See that's where we need your help Charlie." Ally said simply to him.

"Wha?" Charlie managed to mumble in total disappointment as his expectations were suddenly crushed.

"You see Charlie, we need you to tell us which you think makes the best pies and cakes, and the only way to do that is if you try them." Erica said with a wicked grin at the end.

"Wha?" Charlie mumbled again as he looked up at Erica. He then felt Ally grab his chin firmly and pull his face over and up so he was looking directly at her. Ally then SMASHED the pie that she was holding straight into Charlie's face HARD and slowly began to twist it back and forth. All he could hear was Ally talking over his muffled cries of objection.

"This is my special banana cream pie. See how creamy and tasty it is?" Ally could help but giggle a bit at Charlie's predicament. Her hand was removed from the pie tin and it fell with a clang on the dining room table. Pie slowly fell from his shocked face as he then felt Erica grab his chin and force him to look at her. He caught glimpse of Erica still wearing that wicked grin right before his vision went dark by another massive cream pie being just crushed into his face. These girls were hitting him A LOT harder than normal Charlie thought.

"That is MY special Chocolate cream pie!" Erica said as she ground the pie into his face roughly.

"So Charlie which do you like better? My yummy tasty creamy banana cream pie?" Ally said as she threatened him with a second helping which of course was a fresh overflowing Banana Cream pie.

"Or MY world famous Deep thick delicious Chocolate cream pie" Erica almost purred as she too brandished a round mound of creamy pie in front of him.
Charlie quickly looked from pie to pie in almost a panic as to the best way to reply to avoid more of this creamy onslaught.

"Well Charlie?" Ally said impatiently.

"Which do you like better?! " Erica followed.

"Ummm I like them both?" Charlie said weakly.

Each girl let out a pissy "humpf!" And then proceeded to sandwich Charlie's face in-between the two pies. Almost his whole head was in cased in pie he could barely hear Erica break character for a second as she giggled. Charlie had no clue what was going on, usually the girls started by dong a little tit-for-tat play with eachother and it was almost like the girls were teaming up on him and punishing him!

Both girls regained their composure and prepared for their next move.

"You aren't helping Charlie! Maybe you can make up your mind about which of our CAKES is better." Ally said.
Charlie just groaned as he drug his hands down his face trying to remove as much pie cream and pudding as possible. When he opened his eyes he was staring at a deep round white cake that looked like it was bought at a store then someone placed an extra coating of frosting on it, which in fact all of the cakes in that room had had the same treatment. Ally and Erica were now down the table a little ways leaning over with their elbows on the table and their chins resting on their fists like a kid waiting in anticipation for something to happen. Charlie just looked from girl to girl as they just stared back at him with big shit eating grins on their faces. He was not amused, he didn't like them teaming up on him with out and of the sexy fun part where he gets his dick sucked or gets to fuck one of them.

"That one is mine, classic vanilla with white cake and extra frosting!" Erica said "Well aren't you going to taste it?!"
Charlie just sat there pouting and shook his head.

"Awww do you need help?" Ally asked

"No! I'm not going to play anymore and I'm not tasting your stupid ca" That's as far as Charlie got before he felt an unfamiliar pair of hands on the back of his head pushing his face down hard and fast into the round white cake. His head landed with a dull thud as is sank into the cake.The girls couldn't hold back any longer, they all started busting up laughing at the site of Mindy holding Charlie's face down in the cake.

"Nice going Mindy! I see some raw talent in this one Erica!" Ally said while laughing.

"I've never smashed a guy's face into a cake but Oh my god did that feel good!" Mindy said as she still had her hand on the back of Charlie's head with him still face down in the cake.

"Pull him up outta there he still needs to try my cake!" Ally instructed
Mindy then lifted Charlie's face out of the cake by his hair, frosting smashed into every corner of his face just sitting there arms at his side. Ally then removed the destroyed white caked and replaced it with a similar sized but obviously chocolate cake.

"Hope you like chocolate Charlie!" Ally said as she gave Mindy a wink. With that cue Mindy again smashed Charlie's face into the chocolate cake. Charlie could feel Mindy not being shy at all and pressing his head down until his nose bumped with the glass plate that the cake sat on. The girls burst out laughing again at the predicament that Charlie was in. Charlie could feel his face getting hot, he never been more humiliated in his whole life. "They invited Mindy? What the fuck!?" Charlie thought. The girls high fived each other over their success.

"Well you've broken your pie fight cherry now Mindy!" Erica said as she high fived Mindy.

"Mindy go over there in the corner and grab that sheet cake! I want Charlie to 'Taste Test It' next!" Ally yelled as she almost tripped in her heels laughing, which would have been a disaster since she would've fallen face first onto one of the tables filled with pies and cakes.

"So this is what you guys do? You take the hottest guy in school and make him look like a chump?! I love it!" Mindy exclaimed and began laughing again as she walked over to pick up the massive sheet cake.


That was it for Charlie.It was time to turn the tables on the girls, in a big way.