(This is a sequel to "A Good Use of Bonus Money" stories I wrote a little over a year ago...)

It had been about a year since Craig had used his annual bonus payout to spend some quality time getting messy with Samantha and her girls. It had been everything he had hoped for and more with pies, slime, sexy ladies, and a mud surprise. As a single man, recovering from 2 bad relationships, it was a nice getaway from reality.
Not long after that, he started going out on dates again, and ended up getting introduced by a mutual friend to Paula. She was a 27 year old divorced woman very focused on her career as a real estate agent. After a few dates, things were going slow and steady but really as fast as either one wanted to go. Both of them hesitant to get serious and both focused on their careers.
Things really took off when they spent a weekend together in San Diego. It was time away from work for both of them and they really got to know each other. And it was something that Craig had not expected...While Craig was getting ready to go out for dinner, Paula was sitting on the bed, flipping through channels on the tv.
"Since we are sharing stuff with each other this weekend, I should tell you that I've always loved the thought of getting a pie in the face."
"What?" Craig stepped out of the bathroom, not believing what he had just heard.
"On whatever Nick show this is, one of the characters just got pied in the face. I like the thought of that. One birthday a few years back my best friend and her boyfriend knew about this and surprised me with a big cream pie. It totally ruined my outfit and my makeup, but it was so funny and worth it."
"Funny you say that...I've got a few stories I could tell you...". Craig responded. That night he told her the story of how he spent his bonus money last year (not all of the saucy details), she just laughed and laughed.
"That is absolutely ridiculous. But I I'd totally be on board with doing it too."
It was like the walls had all been broken down between them and for the rest of the weekend, they looked like the happiest couple in the world. They were inseparable after that point, every available moment they had was spent with each other. And for her birthday he did present her with a huge cream pie. She loved it and returned the favor to him on his birthday.
But their relationship was based less on the mess and more on two people connecting on every level.
Craig already had ideas for his bonus money and when it showed up in his bank account, he reached out to Samantha again...he already had most of it thought out in his head and it didn't take long to figure out the script and scenery. Craig got Paula to take some days off and everything was set...
The couple drove out the day before the shoot and Craig had yet to tell Paula exactly what all of the plans were. She knew they were going to get messy and she knew she was supposed to wear the nice dress and sexy underwear Craig had picked out. She knew there was a script, but Craig hadn't told her any lines as he had just told her to act natural and everything would work out and she definitely didn't know there was a second scene happening.
The next morning they met Samantha at the same coffee shop Craig had met her in last year. Samantha and Paula hit it off after a few minutes and it wasn't long before Betty joined them at the diner. Paula had lots of questions for both of them concerning what had happened last year. She laughed when Betty mentioned how timid Craig was at the start before really dishing out the mess.
Everyone piled into Samantha's car, and like last time, Craig and Paula were blindfolded. Upon arrival at the studio, Paula gasped when she say a cart filled with pies. "Oh my. You guys are serious."
Samantha took Paula back to a room to get dressed for the scene wile Craig was led to his room by Betty. "FYI. We've got a few surprises in store for you...". She said before slapping him on his ass as he headed into the room.
For this scene, Craig was going to wear an old suit he had bought at a thrift shop. It was cheap and not comfortable. But it served its purpose. He did use one of his good white shirts along with a tie he didn't wear very often. Paula was going to wear a dress he had spent some money on. It had a big, opening at the top where her breasts would poke out, with purple lace fabric flowing out of the opening. The rest of the dress was jet black and super tight. When she tried it on at the store, Craig knew immediately when she would wear it next. Underneath it were to be a white thong and a matching strapless bra.
He walked out of the small room and saw the setup he had planned with Samantha. There was a table for two, all set with silverware and glasses of water. To the side were two carts filled with pies, cakes, and various other sweet things that would be used to cover them.
He was so focused on the carts that he didn't even see Betty come into the room. She was wearing a very skimpy "waitress" outfit. He enormous breasts were barely contained. She was going to be "serving" them.
"You like what you see?" Betty asked, catching Craig looking at her.
Before he could answer Paula walked out. She looked amazing. Her long brown hair flowing down over her shoulders and the tight fit of the dress showing off every one of her perfect curves. She wasn't as overtly sexual as Betty but definitely was turning him on.
Samantha walked out, wearing her standard jeans and t-shirt, and announced, "Let's get this going!"
Craig walked over to Paula and whispered to her, "Just have fun. Act as natural as you can."
She smiled back and sat down in the chair at the table that Craig had pulled out for her. Craig sat down in his chair and everything was in place.
"Action!"
Betty walked out to behind the table, facing the camera. "Thank you for coming in to dine with us tonight. As you know we are the only restaurant in town focusing solely on the sweeter side of food. At "Just Desserts" we give you two menu options. You can order a la carte from the menu or you can choose the more popular option, the chef's choice. With this option, the chef will make selections for you based on your feedback to each dish. Which would you like to go with?"
Craig looked at Paula, who shrugged her shoulders. He then turned to Betty and said, "We'll go with the chef's choice."
"Excellent. The first course will be out shortly." Betty turned and walked off camera.
Betty quickly returned, setting two small bowls in front of Craig and Paula. Then she started to fill the bowls with a chocolate sauce she was squirting out of a big white bottle. As she was filling up Craig's bowl, a voice yelled out from off camera, "Hey Betty! What are we doing tonight?" Craig recognized that voice, it was Dina, the tall, red headed beauty that had gotten messy with him last year.
"We've got that party to go to, remember?" Betty responded, and as she did she raised her head up to yell back and when she did, she lifted bottle of sauce, squirting a little bit onto Craig's face and jacket. She didn't notice and went to fill up Paula's bowl.
As she filled it up, the voice yelled out at her again, "What time are we leaving?"
"10:00!" Betty yelled back, and just as she did before, she lifted up the bottle and squirted chocolate sauce onto Paula's face and a little onto her lap.
"What the hell!" Paula exclaimed.
"I think we need to speak to the manager." Craig told Betty.
A few moments later Dina came out, looking sexy as ever, wearing a tight red dress that showed off all of her amazing features, with her red hair just glowing under the lights.
"I'm so sorry sir. I will talk to your server about this." Dina said as she handed each of them a napkin.
Dina walked over to Betty, who was standing off to the side. "You've been talked to about this before. You cannot continue to mess up the customers. Now turn around and take your punishment."
Betty pouted and turned her back to the camera. Dina lifted up the back of Betty's skirt to reveal the black thong she was wearing and slammed a big cream pie onto her ass. Dina pulled the skirt back down over her cream covered rear and slapped her before telling her to get back to work.
Betty went off to the side and came back to the table carrying two small bowls. She looked off to the side for Dina and then got back to work on Craig and Paula. "The first course tonight is just a basic scoop of vanilla ice cream, which can be enhanced using the chocolate that I poured for you earlier." After that announcement, she walked over to Paula and proceeded to take one scoop of the ice cream from her bowl and place it right on top of Paula's head. The she took the bowl of chocolate from the table in front of Paula and dumped it over the ice cream on her head. The chocolate flowed down in streams over her face and it wasn't long before the scoop of ice cream slid down onto her exposed back, which caused her to squeal.
Betty turned to Craig and scooped the ice cream onto the top of his head. It was colder than Craig had imagined but he didn't have much time to process it as Betty poured out the bowl of chocolate over his head. Craig could feel it coming down over his ears and one stream flowed over his eye onto his tie. As he moved his head, the scoop slid off the top of his head and landed directly onto his lap, still cold.
Betty turned and standing right in front of her was Dina shaking her head. "I'm so sorry guys." She said to Craig and Paula and turned back towards Betty. "Time for your punishment. Please don't do this again. The owner is going to fire both of us at this rate."
Betty faced the camera (and Dina) and lifted up the front of her skirt at which point Dina slammed a big lemon cream pie right into her most private of areas. Betty gasped a little bit, before letting her skirt drop back down.
"Yes ma'am. I won't do that again." Betty responded.
Craig was starting to get excited because he knew things were about to get really messy. Betty came back to the table with two very small cupcakes, with just a little spot of frosting on each one.
"This is one of the chef's favorites. It's a blueberry cupcake with a little cream cheese icing. Enjoy." Betty announced as she left them at the table, both Craig and Paula still dripping chocolate and ice cream.
The camera turned to the side to see Dina talking to Betty. "Thanks for acting like you're supposed to. The chef wants me to run and get some more cake batter for the big finale. I'll be right back as long as you promise to be good?"
"Of course I will Dina." Betty replied, smirking at the camera.
Dina walked off stage past the table and Betty returned to the table. "How do you like the cupcake?"
Craig replied, "Not bad, could use a little more frosting."
"Do you feel the same way?" Betty asked Paula.
"I have to agree."
"Got it. Give me one second." Betty moved off camera and quickly returned with two pie tins in her hand. "Here's some extra frosting for you, ma'am." And she pushed the pie tin, filled with frosting directly into Paula's face. "And for you, sir." Betty turned and did the same to Craig's face.
Everything went dark as the frosting covered his face. It was super sweet and sugary. "I think that might be too much frosting." Craig said, his voice a little muffled from all the frosting.
"It might be too thick, let me help with that." Betty replied. And then she poured a pitcher of ice cold water over Craig and then Paula's head. They both gasped with how cold the water was, but it did clear off some of the frosting from their face. Craig's jacket was now completely soaked and messed up, so he pushed it off of his shoulders and onto the chair, revealing his white dress shirt, which was now a little wet as well. Paula's dress was largely unfazed by the water, other than leaving a trail of white frosting going down the front of it.
"Let's move onto the next course." Betty announced. This time she returned with two very large chocolate cream pies. "Who wants to be served first?"
Craig looked across the table at Paula and answered, "Ladies first." At which point Betty slammed the pie into Paula's face, pushing pie up and over her head. Craig was already getting very aroused and they weren't close to being done yet.
"How is it?" Craig asked.
"Great." Paula replied, somewhat sarcastically and muffled.
Before Craig could say anything else, Betty slammed the other pie into his face. But with his pie, she pushed it down onto his white shirt, coating his tie, and letting the pie tin fall onto his lap, which somewhat covered the erection he had.
"How's yours?" Paula asked as she wiped pie from her face.
"Great." Craig replied.
Just then Dina came back into the room and screamed, "OMG! What have you done?!?!"
"They asked for more frosting." Betty replied with an evil grin.
"You know the punishment you're going to get. But I'm going to let them do it this time." Dina pushed Betty to the side of the table and stood behind her, holding Betty, as she called for Craig and Paula to come over there.
As Craig got up from the chair, all sorts of mess dropped from his lap onto the floor and he figured that it must have been the same for Paula. They walked over to stand beside Betty and Dina handed each of them a large banana cream pie. Then she unbuttoned the back of Betty's blouse and threw it off to the side along only leaving on the bra that held in her gigantic, glorious breasts. Then she unzipped the skirt and let it slide to the floor leaving her standing there in just her pie covered thong. Samantha had suggested taking her bra off as well at that point but with Craig's girlfriend right there he thought it best to not go that far.
"Sir, please place your pie anywhere you see fit." Dina said to Craig.
It wasn't the first time Craig had pied Betty, but it wasn't any less exhilarating. He reared his hand back and slammed the pie right between her breasts, sending pie in all directions.
"Ma'am, it's your turn."
Paula reared back her hand and there was no question, she was going to aim directly for her clean face. Just as she pushed her hand forward, Betty ducked and the pie flew directly into Dina's face.
"What the !!!" Dina exclaimed.
As Dina tried to process what had happened and wipe the pie from her face, Betty had worked her way around Dina's back and unzipped the dress she was wearing. It fell to the floor and now Dina was standing in her thong and sexy, lace bra. Craig couldn't help but stare as he had done at Dina's videos for many years. She was amazing to look at.
Betty then dumped a bowl of yellow custard over Dina's red hair and it flowed all over her skin. Craig didn't realize that Paula was making a move at this point. She was going to get her revenge on Betty. She had grabbed another pie and was heading right towards her target. This time, when she threw the pie, Betty was not able to duck out of the way, but did just take a glancing blow, with the main part of the pie hitting Dina in the chest.
"Why do you keep going after me? I was trying to help you tonight!" Dina shouted.
Paula grabbed another pie and this time found her mark, hitting Betty squarely in the face. "Gotcha!"
Betty turned to Dina, "We've got a live one here." The two ladies grabbed Paula and Dina proceeded to unzip her dress and push it to the floor. Betty grabbed a pie and slammed it onto Paula's exposed chest. Craig hadn't realized she wasn't wearing a bra. But he stood there watching three ladies he had fantasized about, having a pie fight in their underwear. It was glorious.
Betty and Dina each grabbed a pie and gave Paula a pie sandwich that completely engulfed her head. Dina grabbed another pie and slammed it onto her ass, while Betty placed one in the front. Craig was starting to get jealous, but definitely wasn't going to interrupt the action as his girlfriend was now pretty well covered from head to toe.
At that point, the ladies stopped and turned to give their attention to Craig. "Uh oh." he said quietly. Paula came over and undid his slacks, dropping them quickly to the floor, leaving only his black boxers on. Dina and Betty pulled at both sides of his shirt, completely ripping all of the buttons off. Now he was standing there, surrounded by three pie covered sexy ladies, in only his boxers and a messed up tie. Dina undid the tie and pushed him down onto the chair before using the tie to restrain his hands behind the chair.
Betty handed a pie to Paula, who slammed it directly into his face. Then Betty and Dina combined on another pie sandwich. He felt a hand on his erection, which he hoped was Paula, but at this point he couldn't tell or really care. "Someone is enjoying himself." He heard Paula say before smashing a pie right onto it.
"I think it's time for the final course." Dina shouted out.
He couldn't make out what Betty was saying to Paula, but he quickly felt Paula climb onto his lap. At that point he really wished they were alone, because he would have already been inside his girlfriend but he would definitely be there later. Paula wiped his face off a little bit so he could see the mess they had made.
"I love you." Paula said to him and as she kissed him, buckets of chocolate cake batter were poured over them. He lost track of how many, but there had to have been at least 5 or 6. When the flow finally stopped Paula wiped his eyes clear and he could see that both of them were completely covered in the batter. There wasn't a clean spot between them. And he could tell that Paula was definitely enjoying moving around on his erection.
Craig heard Betty and Dina talking in the background but couldn't make out what they were saying until Samantha sent him the video...
"We are never going to make money at this place." Dina said with a sigh.
"But it's fun." Betty replied. "Plus, what other restaurant can you work at that only has one table in it?"
They both laughed and pushed a pie in each other's face.
"CUT!" Samantha yelled from off camera. "Great job guys! That went perfectly! Paula, you were amazing!"
"I was really nervous at first, but then I...I just started enjoying myself." Paula answered, smiling through the layers of cake batter that covered her.
"Time for the cleanup!" Betty shouted.
Craig led Paula over to the "shower" area where Samantha and her garden hose awaited them. She started spraying down Paula first, and it took a little bit but once the water worked off some of the layers, Paula let out a little scream with each spray of the cold water. Then Samantha moved to Craig, spraying the water at his face and head, then heading down the rest of his body. After a few minutes, Samantha finally moved onto rinsing off Dina and Betty. It took a few more rounds for Paula and Craig to get completely rinsed off, but Craig didn't mind as he was enjoying the view of his wet, messy girlfriend in her skimpy underwear and the two other sexy ladies in the same condition within view. He was trying hard to not let Paula see him looking at Betty and Dina but he was sure she had to have seen him do it a couple of times.
They dried off and Craig and Paula returned to their dressing rooms. As far as Paula knew, they were done and headed back to the hotel, where she was looking forward to having some close relations with her boyfriend. Craig had other ideas...When planning for this session with Samantha, they had talked about going back out to the mud pond where Craig had been taken last year, but Samantha said there was a new development in that area and the privacy was gone. They talked about using the grunge booth that Craig had been put into with Dina last year, and Craig was ok with that, but he knew that as soon as he got in there all he would be able to think about was his experience with Dina. After many emails back and forth, they finally settled on using the big gunge tank. And that was just part of it...
Craig got dressed in what he wore to the session, knowing full well that it would get messed up but he had packed extra clothes for both of them, unbeknownst to Paula. He walked out of the room in his white/blue Nike's, his jeans, and a t-shirt he had got at a charity run a few years ago. Samantha was there to greet him.
"That was fantastic. Still on track for part two?"
"Thanks and yes we are definitely doing part two."
"And she still doesn't know?"
"Not a clue."
A few moments later, Paula walked out of the dressing room. She was wearing a yellow sun dress with matching flats. Her hair was pulled back in a ponytail, and Craig thought she looked as sexy as she ever did.
"How are you doing?" Samantha asked.
"Great." Paula responded.
"Did you have a good time?"
"The best. Thanks for doing this."
"You have to thank Craig as he really funded the operation. I'm glad you had a good time. Before we take you back, there's a couple things we need to do..You know, paperwork, signatures, etc. Is that ok?"
"Sure." Both Craig and Paula replied.
"Ok, I'll be right back." And with that Samantha left them alone in the area by the area where they had just made a complete mess of everything.
Paula grabbed Craig and kissed him. "I can't wait for you to fuck me. I am so turned on right now."
"Same." Craig replied.
Before Paula could do anything else Samantha came back out with a clipboard. "Ok, this is just a formality for all first time people, so please follow me." Samantha led them both through another door. Samantha went through the door first, then Craig, and when Paula walked through it, Dina and Betty jumped out with a big cake and smashed it into Paula's face, smearing it all over her head and onto her sun dress.
"Sorry, it's just a tradition for all first timers. Congrats on your first session!" Betty said laughing.
"OMG!" Paula yelled out, but she was laughing too, her entire head covered in blue and red frosting with pieces falling onto her dress. "I can't believe I didn't see that coming!"
"We do have something else planned for you, if you could climb up the ladder and sit on the platform, that would be great." Samantha directed her to a ladder that was connected to a very large dunk tank looking thing. And the tank was filled with what looked like thick green slime. "Craig, if you'll get on the platform on the other side." The tank was so large it had two platform sticking out over the tank. If you were looking at a clock, one of the platforms would have been at 2:00 and the other was at 10:00.
Paula was climbing up and called out to Craig, "You knew about this, didn't you? And I don't even have other clothes to wear when we leave! I'm so going to get you for this!"
Craig didn't say anything, he just laughed back at her as he climbed up onto the platform. He sat down on it, with his legs hanging over. The bottom of his shoes were resting right at the level of the slime in the tank. When Paula sat down, her toes were pointed down and scooped up some slime as she got settled. When she lifted up her shoe to take a look, it fell off and sank down into the slime.
"You'll be getting that for me at some point." She said, pointing directly at Craig with an evil laugh.
"Okay, let's play the game. Betty and Dina are each holding the dice." Samantha took the lead as the host of this game show type atmosphere.
Craig looked over at Dina and she was holding a die the size of a basketball. Betty had the same.
"They are going to roll the dice. If the roll, for both dice combined ends in an odd number, one of you will win and the other will get dumped into the tank. We'll do this for a few rounds and then the stake will get higher. A loss will not only end up with you in the tank, it will require you to remove some clothing. Eventually, one of you will be completely naked and in the tank with the other named the winner. Paula, do want to be Odds or Evens?"
"I have no idea what to pick, so I'll be Odds since it's been an odd day to say the least."
"Great. Dina, Betty, let's see that first roll."
Betty rolled first and the big die rolled around util finally landing on three.
"YES!" Paula yelled out.
"Dina still has to roll, ma'am." Craig replied a little sarcastically.
Dina rolled and it also landed on three.
"So, that makes the roll a 6, which means Evens win, so here you go Paula!" And with that announcement, Samantha pressed the large button on her right and the platform Paula was sitting dropped out from under her. She immediately dropped completely under the surface of the slime before quickly coming back up. The frosting that had covered her face was mostly gone, but the thick slime just coated her hair and body. She climbed up the ladder and sat back down on the platform that Betty had put back in place.
Craig couldn't take his eyes off of Paula. He wasn't expecting it, but he thought Paula looked amazing covered in the slime and he couldn't wait to touch her. But it was time for the next roll.
Betty rolled a two and Dina followed that with a six. "It's Evens again, sorry Paula." Paula was a little more prepared for this drop and she made sure to extend out her body as much as possible, trying to splash slime onto Craig. A little bit did, but more ended up going towards Betty than Craig.
The third roll started with Betty rolling a one. Dina rolled and this time the die rolled and leaned up against the tank, never completely landing. "It's a 1!" Craig shouted.
"I'm going to rule that wasn't a valid roll. Try again Dina." Samantha pronounced.
Dina rolled again and this time Craig had no defense as it ended up on the four. "Odds win!" And with that Craig was dropped into the slime. He had never been completely covered in slime before, let alone submerged in it. It felt odd, but fun at the same time. All those years of watching Nickelodeon probably caused that.
He climbed back up onto the platform and saw Paula laughing, fully enjoying his turn in the tank.
"Time for Round 2!" Samantha announced.
Dina rolled first in this round and ended up getting a six. Betty rolled and got another three. "Odds win again!"
Craig wasn't sure when he was supposed to take off his clothes, let alone what clothes he was supposed to remove. Before he could ask, he was dropped into the tank. This time he was a little more accustomed to moving around in the mess. When he stood up, Samantha ordered him to remove some clothing. Craig reached down and took off one of his shoes and showed it to the group.
"If you're doing that, it needs to be both shoes and both socks. I don't even have socks on and I've already lost one shoe." Paula yelled at him, pointing her one shoe at Craig. When she did that, she lost her balance a little bit. She didn't fall in, but her other shoe did drop into the tank, causing Craig to laugh out loud at her. "Ok, shoes don't count, take something else off. It's only fair."
Craig started to protest but decided this would lead to more fun soon enough. He took his shoes and sock over to the side of the tank, but was stopped by Dina. "In the tank, sir. Both of her shoes are in the tank, so yours will be too." He felt them sink to the bottom as he took off the shirt that was pretty well stuck to his body. And for fun, he let it sink to the bottom of the tank as well. It started to float but he pushed it down with his feet. He wanted Paula's dress to end up in the same place.
Another roll happened and Craig ended up in the tank again. Things were really working against him now. It took him a bit, but he managed to work his way out of his slime soaked jeans, leaving him in his boxer briefs. Thankfully for him, the next roll ended up with Paula getting dropped into the slime. And just as he thought, she tried to put her dress on the side of the tank before reminding her that it belonged at the bottom of the tank. She looked a little sideways at him, but did as directed. Now they were both sitting on the platforms in their underwear.
"I think, due to the nature of how you are both dressed, this next roll will be the last one. Winner take all." Samantha announced.
Dina rolled a one. It was all up to Betty's roll now. It was surprisingly tense for Craig. He felt like a winner no matter what happened but now he was invested in the game. Betty rolled, it bounced around for a but before finally settling on another one for her.
"Evens Win!" Samantha shouted. And with that Paula was dropped into the slime again. Once she regained her footing, she reached down and removed her thong bikini underwear, flinging it at Craig.
Then she removed her bra, revealing her beautiful, slime covered breasts. Craig was doing his best to cover up the erection that was happening at that moment.
"Congrats Craig! You're the winner! And as the winner, well, we really don't have anything else to give you, so here you go!" And with that Samantha hit the button for Craig's platform. He dropped into the slime tank next to Paula who wasted no time in diving into the slime to pull off his boxer briefs. She came back up with them and wrapped her arms around him.
"We have one more thing for you two lovebirds. And when we're done with that, you have the place to yourself as long as you need it. Enjoy!" Samantha called out to them.
At that moment a stream of blue slime dropped from above the tank onto Craig and Paula. Paula didn't waste any time and started to kiss him as the slime flowed over the two of them. The slime then switched to pink, before finishing up with a long stream of orange slime coated them. Craig heard the door shut and just as he had planned they were alone and naked, in a tank of slime. He began to run his hands all over Paula, caressing her breasts, grabbing he sexy ass, and running his fingertips over her pussy.
She was definitely not expecting that, but gladly played along, placing her hands onto his enlarged cock. "Oh my. Are we about to do what i think we are?"
"Yes we are." Craig pushed her over to the side of the tank and slid his cock into her. She gasped and grabbed on tight to him, letting him do with her as he wanted. And Craig, was just as turned on, and probably was more aggressive and physical than he usually was when inside her but there was no stopping him. Everything about this moment was so good. Everything about her was so good. Everything was so good.
Eventually they finished up, which meant they had to fish out all of their stuff out of the tank. There were no towels in the room, so they put their slime covered outfits back on, minus the shoes, and walked back out to the main area. There they found Samantha and her husband, the cameraman, sitting in a couple of chairs, having a quiet conversation. "Ready to get sprayed down?" She asked.
"Yes we are." Craig replied. "Thanks."