Hi to all,

this is a question I had long time in mind to ask the community here...

Feel free to reply or just read the pro and con's of others...

Surgif

I personally have : paint !

Yes this is somethin a lot of people have not in there mind or are scared about.
But I like the way it messes perfectly.
Additionally It's smooth and silk, wothout any stones or other stuff.
It has no fat in like a lot of milk-based messy substances which give your clothes or skin a bad odor after.
And water is just mainstream... sorry! Ha ha ha!

The only things you have to be aware of are that you should use only water-based paint, no acrylic paint! And it's important to keep it wet until you wash it off. Then a lot of your clothes / shoes can be re-used if you want to.

And last but not least DON'T get it into your mouth, eyes or too deep inside your holes.

Custard.

The way it flows inside and soaks into clothing, the huge mess it makes, how it feels if you have it poured inside your own clothes, and that because it's not actually meant to be used for messing people up, it's "naughtier" than something like gunge. For messing with, custard rules!

Closely followed by mud.

Paint.
It gives a pleasant feeling on the skin and the body looks good in paint.

Mud & Chocolate Batter as i love the way it submerges the person to be completely unrecognisable from head to toe.

Yeah paint is a fave here as well. Proper emulsion paint. Kaydens did some great paint scenes with ever increasing quantities. And MessyFun also had some classics.
Also love grease play and the way it's just so messy and extreme

Shaving cream. I love the light fluffy feel and love the look when it is piled in a girl's face

This is such a tough question. I would have to say a thick buttercream or cool whip pie. There's something about the intentionality of having someone walk up, grab the back of your head, and slowly smear a pie into your face, forcing the filling everywhere. It's just a uniquely sensual way of saying "you're mine."

I like to create my own concoctions. For example, I may take Xanthan gum and mix up a thick batch with added paint mixed in. I even mix the paints or make it a marble mix of colors.

Another favorite is a polymer sold under the brand 'Yuck' and it is super slimy, gooey, stringy and slippery. You can mix it with anything from shaving cream (which makes it like marshmallow fluff) or just about anything else, such as food items.

Arrowroot starch or powder (same thing) when properly boiled and cooled, makes a really nice, gooey and sticky slime, but it is amazingly easy to rinse off or rinse out of clothing. It can also be mixed with paint, and it is cheap to make.

So you can see that my preference is in combining ingredients, rather than using something already made.

Greek yoghurt, the fatty kind It is
rather thick and melts a little on the body. It can run slowly down someone's belly or back (and in their underwear ). It doesn't leave the yellowish stains some custards do.

Taste and smell are ok, easy to clean/rinse out.

For me my favorite substance is mud.

Why? Because mud looks good when it's all over a persons body, especially if it's a hot woman that's fully naked and is lying their relaxed and getting the ultimate spa treatment.

Eggs!!!
Because having dozens of eggs cracked on your head is the greatest humiliation for me , plus you have to add the anticipation, the sound of the egg cracking, the surprise of where they will fall, the stickiness, the slimy, gooey and slippery the fun, the fact of being naughty breaking the rules of not playing with food or getting your perfect hair and outfit messy

Emulsion paint for me from head to toe totally naked. If someone can accommodate I would love to make this happen.

My favourite substance. I am a fan of two-part epoxy resin. It only take a few minutes to bond and is suitable for all rubber and metal repairs oh wait you mean to smear all over myself

Well, I like anything creamy which can be whipped into stiff peaks. Cake batter, cream, even foam. What does it for me is the soft texture, it's fluffiness and how it smooths gently over the face and hair when you get pied with it. Id love to make huge pie out of a paddling pool and dive into the stuff and wriggle about.

Just how you'd imagine it would be to stick your head in a large, fluffy white cloud!

Don't try this at hone, cumulonimbus are far off the ground and are just water vapour. You'll just get wet, which might not be a bad thing!

T x

For me, without a doubt, it's pies. Giving or receiving, it's such a fun and humiliating classic. I love mine with tons of whipped cream/cool whip and then a mystery inside. Straight to the face and smeared back into the victim's hair. Want more? Do a pie hat or a pie sandwich. And the crust is just another delightful humiliation as well. Nothing better.

Mostly I've done cake mix. This is the easiest, cheapest, and most readily available for me in terms of getting messy. You can fill up a good chunk of one of those big home depot buckets for around $10 bucks. All you need is water, which is nice. I add a little vegetable oil too to ease washing out (not really sure if it's even necessary). Nice consistency for gloppy coverage, and it's fairly easy to scoop back up for multiple dumpings.

Chocolate syrup is always lovely too. A little more pricey to get larger quantities of it, but I do love the consistency. Mixes well with cake mix, but if you've dyed your mix, it's turning brown on ya.

I tried molasses once, and it was pretty friggin' amazing. Really pricey though. I kind of scored on mine as I got some cheaper kind that was discontinued. Now all we have at my store is the Grandma's Molasses which is like 3 times more than what the kind I got was...

Gunge is pretty nice. You get a nice quantity for a decent price. Only downside is you gotta order it on-line and wait for it. I had a little bit of an issue with my second batch in terms of mixing. Had a lot of clumps, and that kind of made tub clean up a little bit more of a bitch as the clumps would dilute down to nothing with water.

I'm terrible at favorites.

Mud, of course. Everyone thinks water is just passe, but... unless you're just using dry sand or dirt, everything fun is wet, and wetlook itself is just a core interest for me.

I definitely have a thing for caramel, and I also love maple syrup. Eggs are so much fun, too.

And I could probably go on and on and list everything I've ever played with and some things I want to play with.

Local to me is a stream fed pool surrounded by trees. On the map it is called 'New Water' well it was about 200 years ago but now there is about 6 inches of water and then there is silty mud; I haven't found a bottom yet. If there is no wind and the sun has been on that pool all day, or days, it can be positively warm! Covered in this silty mud from naked head to naked toe I walk about a mile across fields then swim a river and come out clean, find my clothes then walk home very happy.
Can't see the point of Sploshing or WAM with cloths on as it must be mud, gung, food, really nice, gooey and sticky slime, or whatever skin to mess I can find - I draw the line at scat.... Not tried paint yet...

WOW!

Never expected to have this much replys...!
I LOVE any reply, and I'm surprised what a big bandwith you all use... Fantastic and interesting to read.

Hope there will be even more people who will give a comment here....

LOVE you all!

An Add-On by me: I love also the bright and thick colours you can do with paint....before you mix and mess them up. Ha ha ha!

Gunge. Looks good, feel good. Good value per bucket and relatively easy to deal with too.

My second favorite substance is thick, pitch-black mud. I love how mud changes me beyond recognition.

Mud all day!

It can come in so many different places and guises. Fields, estuaries, marshes, farmland.this list goes on. Soft, shallow, sticky, watery whatever. The unknowingness of the depth is one of the biggest draws for me. In wellies you can test the depth and not be in to much trouble but in football trainers, you could sink and cover your entire foot which is both a bit of a problem sometimes but such a turn on at the same time!

It really depends. I'm a hair guy, so my favorite substances depend on hair color.

I like darker things on blonde hair, so my favorite there is chocolate syrup or dark blue slime.
For medium hair colors, I like pink slime.
for dark hair colors, I like white whipped cream or eggs.

Custard in my underwear feels nice sloppy heavy and can sit in them for a long period of time

Eggs!
It's the best, hottest humiliation ever, yellow yok in blonde hair looks amazing.

There's a few good videos around but I'm actually to get a new custom of a fit blonde getting egged. Shout out if you know of anyone?

Mud is amazing, don't really do it because I'd hate to be caught, but it's super messy and clean up is so easy if there's a river near by.

Least favourite I've used is mayo, it burns my skin and the smell is terrible. Guess it could be the brand? But don't mind watching a video of it.

Easiest in door mess is gunge, no smell, easy to mix, feels amazing, makes lots easy to fill a bath to submerge and easy to clean up. Down side that it's expensive.

Pies will always be my favorite. I could give or receive (or preferably a mix of the two) an almost unlimited number of pies. Within reason, anyway. Or at least let's say that I haven't yet had a session where I started to tire of them, and I've done several two-person sessions with 40+ pies.

I also enjoy paint, mud, pudding, cakes, shaving cream and anything else along those lines.

Lately? I've been obsesssing over getting my hands on fluff. It's so diverse. You can do so much with it! You can keep it fluffy- you can add substances to it and have a ooey gooey sticky and heavy substance. I love that it is stark white. I love the weight. It's amazing.
But? Man. I have about 5 others in my top faves right now that is just one of a few. Bc it comes in a huge bucket/ you can color it- you can add to it, you can mix stuff with it. I just love it! I actually made a mix of fluff and a few other ingredients the other day that would make AMAZING thrown and smushed pies! Now? I'm like, obsessing over it!


I also want to get in some Nutella and pb so bad! All the girls have been doing it for years and the last time I got to? Was in like?.2018? 2019? (I got to in 2021 but it's not in my store/ and I was with someone else and the "Nutella" was not actual Nutella. It was a chocolate version of my mystery substance. Which I LOVE! But nothing beats melted Nutella and pb! together.

And I don't really have to say it but- mud.
I looooove outdoor mud. Seeing what I can find. But?im becoming increasingly obsessed with what I can fill my mud pit with! What kind of clay can I afford that I will love? What can I mix with it to make it last? Etc. I fucking love mud.

Oh man I remember doing an insane paint video with Ariel and that was SO INTENSE AND FUN! Tempera paint was especially fun in the big jugs! I even have a huge set of gallons of paints on my Amazon wish list! I would love to do paint again and paint a huge white cloth on the walls!

Chunky green slime is definitely my favorite. It's such a deep seeded fear of humiliation having that dumped on me and how embarrassing it is. The lumps running down your face, the colour, how gross it looks. It drives me wild. I love seeing it, receiving even mixing it.