Melody and Tori thought this was going to be a simple pie tasting. However, what they signed up for wasn't pie tasting... it was pie testing. There's white pies, bright pies, thrown pies, smooshed pies. There's pies with filling, pies in baked crusts, pies in tins, and cool whip pies. Just so many pies! After all 40 are used, Tori receives a test of contrast by way of white slime and chocolate syrup poured on her head. Meanwhile, Melody can't believe she made it through an entire scene without get slimed... until she does.

After footage includes both girls taking a cold and lumpy recycled sliming; made from all the mess used in the shoot, mixed together in buckets, and dumped onto them. Finally, each of them rub the mess on one another and show off their messy bare feet.