I would definitely check out your store and be inclined to purchase something, just based on what I've seen in the photos and gif. Excessive amounts of pie and slime. Cute reactions when you are hit. What's not to love about that?
In terms of what to do... honestly, do what you and your husband like. I really love it when "regular folks" make content that is based on what they like to do and see. Just be genuine.
And besides, you can probably find a hundred old threads where producers gripe about how it's a losing game to try and make things that other people want to see.