Continuing from the Top 5 Models post.

Who's in your top 5 Messygirl's of all time??

Mine are:

Brittany MG
Liz Ashley
Leah aka Messygirl
Sara
Wednesday

And special mentions for.....

Tori
Willa Prescott
Amy (Redhead/Strawberry Blonde one)
Amber (Dark Long Haired One)
Stephanie
Sabrina
Linda
Amy (Blonde One)

Vika (best pie throwing Messygirl ever, and Titty Bar Bake Sale is an amazing scene).
Amy (red hair)
Vicky
Penelope
Danielle Trixie

1. Amy was gorgeous and took pies like a champ. Best Messygirl model ever.
2. Penelope is also beautiful and gets longevity/consistency points. Her "pied poetess" vid is a favorite.
3. Liz Ashley seemed to actually enjoy herself.
4. Vicki/London got messy with gusto.
5. Vika is the Scandinavian ice queen who looks delicious covered in cream.

Katie (early Messygirl model, just my type): https://dl.messygirlvideos.com/cgi/autogal.pl?vidnum=tws-75-0170
Sara: (great WAM actress) https://dl.messygirlvideos.com/cgi/autogal.pl?vidnum=tws-75-0238
Christina (absolute KILLER body) https://dl.messygirlvideos.com/cgi/autogal.pl?vidnum=tws-75-0505
Amy: (legend and also a great WAM actress) https://dl.messygirlvideos.com/cgi/autogal.pl?vidnum=tws-75-0825
Payton (gorgeous-- newer models need some love) https://dl.messygirlvideos.com/cgi/autogal.pl?vidnum=tws-75-1073

List can change at any time. Others: Original Amber, Kerry Taylor (one of the hottest women on the planet IMHO), Liz, Zoey, etc.

Lexi
Sarah
Michelle
Cassandra
Anastasia

Probably

Dakota
Misty
Celeste
Cassandra
Alice

That is hard to narrow to 5.

In no particular order:

Amy
Sara
Stephanie
Penelope
Vika

But that list could easily change as there are several that are close to making the list.

Vicky/London
Penelope
Lane
Leah/Messygirl
Zoey

Shame to have some great models squeezed out, like Liz, Linda, Sara, Amy, MewMew, Jasmine, Tilly, and Stephanie. Helluva site.

Leah/Messygirl
Amy/2nd Amy
Liz
London Andrews
Lexi

Super tough task picking only 5 Messygirls. Here is my Mt. Rushmore:

Penelope
Zoey
Tilly McReese
Amy (blonde)
Megan Jones

My pics.

Two of the newer ones: Dakota and Sofia. Both super sexy and go for the gold.

Sabrina. I like that she was game but still kinda awkward, she's fun and did hardcore so there's that.

Two older school: Lexi whio was a lot of bubbly fun and had an amazing body, and Linda who just seemed like a totally regular lady who got involved. Just wish she had ever done nudity.

Bonus for all the Messygirl Blowjobs ladies, some of whom didn't seem to have done a ton of regular MG videos.

Off the top of my head....(No particular order)

Amy
Jasmine Mendez
Michelle
Amber
Penelope

But i have to also mention Vika, Sofia, Stephanie, Vasantra, Terra Mizu, Hannah Perez, Christina, Tammy, and Carmilla (I'm missing so many, they're all wonderful)

MewMew, Penelope, Raven, the first Amber, & Vicky/London

Michelle
Stephanie
Amy
Penelope
Vika

Anything with bondage, panty filling, pies, and some extreme humiliation. It would be a dream come true to play with any of these girls. They are legendary.

Amber Redhead - not just a beautiful, curvy ginger with a deep sexy voice, but she seems so happy she makes her GG scenes seem magical
Penelope - Not just sexy, not just doing great GG stuff, but she's been with MG so long she feels like an ambassador for the brand
Amy Blonde - Her time seems brief in the grand scheme, but she felt like another ambassador for the brand during that time. Some of her videos with listmates Amber and Penelope are some of my favorites
Amber classic - A combination of girl next door charm and sultry allure. I also thought curvy Amber subbing to BBW Raven was legit hot
Zoey - Most of what I said about the other models could be said about this hotty

HMs:
Dakota and Sofia - Lots of good stuff but unfortunately I haven't seen enough, tho I could see one of them taking a top spot
Wednesday and Tammy - The time for these over the top curvy gingers was brief but wonderful. Whether it was Wednesday's GG scenes or Tammy's big jiggly booty
Michelle and Karen - low sample size, but Messy Housewives is one of my favorite videos

Hard to nail just five, but these girls were just consistently great, really got it and were extremely charismatic, in addition to obviously being total smokeshows. In no particular order:

Lexi
Amy
Sara
Justine
Michelle

I'll add a shoutout for JustJade, more of a 'special guest' Messygirl, but an all-round fearless sexy goofball trouper.

Doing 5 old school and 5 new school

Old School:
Vicky
Liz
Kim
Candle Boxxx
Tammy

New School:
Dakota
Penelope
Zoey
Anastasia
Santana

1. Leah
2. Vicky/London Andrews
3. Tatum
4. Brittany
5. Zoey

Again a cool idea for a thread

1) Amber (long-haired one mentioned in original post)
2) Liz Ashley
3) Raven
4) Lexi
5) Danielle Trixie

A slight bias for back in the day perhaps

Top five would have to include:

1. Payton. Just lovely and sensual, and enthusiastic for the metallic paint scenes. How many has she done? Four or five?
2. Tori. Utterly adorable, and I love how giddy and happy she always seems on camera. I imagine there are some models who treat WAM gigs like a weird modelling job, but Tori genuinely seems to have fun in her clips.
3. Willa Prescott. No reason other than I really loved her face, she seemed very sweet and down-to-earth, and also seem incredulous at the craziness in her pie scenes.
4. Amber (the more recent one). Just completely at ease in front of the camera, she makes her scenes seem casual.
5. Linda. If there was ever a MessyGirl model who was "my type" it was her. Terrific actress and such a striking face. Never even went topless, if memory serves, but her work was really memorable to me

Special shoutouts to Allison (Asian girl from very early on) and Nevaeh, who's only got one shoot in the store but it's one of my favorite gold scenes ever. Also Wednesday, Courtney and Lexi. Classics all.

Payton + metallics = instant buy for me.

Allison is definitely on my list of lesser-known models, along with Zeyda. Her curly dark hair does it for me. I could swear that Zeyda did a gold blowjob video, but I'm only seeing chocolate. I'd forgotten about Nevaeh. I think I have her gold video somewhere.

Tatum
Vicky/London
Zoey
Penelope
Amy

Penelope
Amy (blonde)
Zoey
Jacy
Lexi

About the most recent
Dakota, Cassandra, Carmilla, Anastasia and Michelle

1) amy
2) jacy
3) penelope
4) stephanie
5) Tilly

Vicky (London Andrews)
Amy
Liz
Zoey
5th place tie: Raven and Sasha Sparks

I could love about a million Messygirls!

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=ofK9cN2wotA

Only five?
Damn, I will have to cheat then!

Top 5 among the retired Mesygirls:
1) Justine
2) Lexi
3) The "second" Amy
4) Liz
5) Debbie

Top 5 veterans but still doing videos :
1) Penelope
2) Zoey
3) Vika
4) Sabrina
5) Michelle

Top 5 "new faces":
1) Peyton
2) Celeste
3) Cassandra
4) Dakota
5)Jasmine

Vika
Vika
Vika
Vika
Vika

Another near impossible task wi th answers that could change out on any given day. But for my current mood:

1. Leah the Original Messygirl - despite being shot before HD became the industry standard, Leah's scenes are still absolute favorites of mine. You simply can't beat the real thing.

2. Linda - I've always been a huge Linda fan. She took pies wonderfully and I remember being so pleased when she made a brief return a few years ago. I'd love to see her come back again some day.

3. Vicky/London Andrew's - aside from the fact that she starred in a few of my first cigar/pie customs, London has always been a great model and looks fantastic covered in pie. I remember when I first saw London pop up in a smoking fetish forum I was a part of, I thought, "Man, that looks like Vicky from Messygirl." I saved the picture, emailed Messygirl asking if they were one and the same, and she kindly responded back that it in fact was. At the time, she mentioned that they had parted ways. A short while later, London made her return to Messygirl. Probably just a coincidence, but I like to think I played a positive contribution to that reunion.

4. Wednesday - there's just something about Wednesday's expressions when she is in the midst of an especially messy scene. She just looks like she is truly enjoying every sensual minute of her experience.

5. Raven - Great personality, great look, and a great pie target as well as pie thrower.

Thank you for the trip down memory lane.

I'll be honest, no one has mentioned two that I actually thought completely got it, in terms of reactions -- Tracy Jordan and Gia. There's a shot where Tracy is getting a version of the "pie sandwich", and she gives a mock nervous look, as she moans when she gets hit on both ends, and then her "Messy Wake Me Up" scene with Vicky (as was her other video) is worth it for her slightly exaggerated reactions alone.

Gia only appeared in two scenes, but the pie fight between her and Wednesday was my first introduction to MG, and the way that scene goes from antagonistic to enthusiastic flirtation to the very end where Gia grabs Wednesday's breast as she's on top of her and gives it a couple smacks -- the two just had great chemistry.

Oddly, the other ones I would list would be Amy 2, Vika, and Penelope, all of whom do more of a slow burn in their reactions in their scenes (not exclusively), so I can't say there's any method to my madness on this one. But as everyone else has basically commented, it's basically the 1927 Yankees with their roster past and present. Good problem to have.