"The Pie Convention" was the first video I got from MG, and remembered thinking how well done that first pie throw was, and they haven't let me down since.
Overall though, I've always thought that the (very) old school "Gilligan's Pie Land" pie fight between Charlee Chase and Nicole. All of the hits throughout are great, but there's a part vaguely near the beginning that ramps up the action, where Charlee throws a pie with some force at Nicole, and Nicole goes "So we're gonna play like THAT!" and just as Charlee says "You better believe we..." Nicole hits her back with an equally hard thrown pie.
The realistic part of me knows how tightly setup these are ahead of time, but there's still a part of me that kind of hoped that that was a couple seconds of an actual pie fight, with Charlee's pie throw getting Nicole mad for a second and returning the favor.
That PiedPinups "red curtain" thrown pie on that beautiful model with her hair up is an amazing one. Totally forgot about it until you included that GIF! That has to be in my all time favorite thrown pies list!
Threw some pies at Maxxx the other day turned out really really well. I attached the gif of my favorite. I'm not sure if dropping a pie on someone from above counts as thrown, but I started doing that lately and I love it. My new favorite way of pieing. So I added a gif of that as well. Both gifs are from this video https://the-messy-maxxx-store.umd.net/download_info/maxxx-vs-the-types-of-pie