My favourite pie to be pied with is whipping cream in a Pastry case, topped off with a cherry.

Photo below is me after a direct hit

What pie filling do you guys use?

Prefer shaving cream with a crust. Better coverage and easier to clean off after. Tastes disgusting though if you accidentally taste it xx

A cream pie in an aluminium foil plate for me, please

I ALWAYS buy real pies from the store. Freezer aisle, when it's discounted. There are better and worse kinds.

Got to be the classic custard pie with whipped cream, and if really pushing the boat out, in a large sponge flan case (but these are getting harder to find.)

Used them for years, now having to use crust

Proper custard pie in flan case or crust topped with cream classic

It's between a berry filling and coolwhip on top or else a pudding with cream. The sloppier the better for me!

Creme pies from bakeries.